I used to enjoy reading no-mercy's input.

number2 wrote:All gone quiet on here! Unusual considering we are in the best part of the year!

My pick's
A grade
Kilburn
Salisbury
B grade
Salisbury
Kenilworth

Black and White in both games for me

Rather than speculation from people who are not involved with the club maybe we could talk about some facts like the Chics are in the GF. The club suffered enough and deserves to be celebrated for their accomplishments this year and not condemned for things have not even happened.

Any club in the league could be effected by the salary cap, perhaps it could be a separate thread.

12 months after both clubs are on their knees both Kilburn and Mitchell Park make Grand Finals.

Very impressive all things considered.

I guess thats what happens when its 6 minutes a div whats the point in going all that way for that. Bring back the old days when there would be different div counts at different venues.

I've always liked kilburns set up which is the Sunday after their last season game. Calls for a huge Sunday funday and it gets the boys together for finals. I don't think finals should be included, selflessness wins finals, not blokes thinking about if that are getting in the best.

Sounds like everyone might not be on the same page out there pag, apparently u guys are dirty at the league for docking u points and u guys are out of cash?!? Best side we came up against all year! I think u will take care of kilburn easily

Please tell me it's Shrek!?

Hello Boys and Girls! Seeing as Nearly Was is the only person with common sense on this thread, she who can not be named has reinstated the Greatest Poster of all time.

Bad luck to all you Haven sooks on here. If it's any consolation it only costs $10 to get into the Big Shrek Show tomorrow down at your neck of the woods. It will probably be the last outing you can afford once the Submarine Corp go under!

Kilburn by 4 goals tomorrow!

Hi Dols. I hope your schnitty at the Rob Roy tastes as good as last week when you were very confident that North Haven would not only beat Salisbury, but would knock us in the GF! Might want to check that your mushroom sauce wasn't made from mushies of the magic variety.

Don't worry, a 5 turns into a 6 really easily so you can use those shirts again next year when you win the flag in March.

Up the shrek

I don't know about the Truscott red card and how long until he was replaced, but to anyone who thinks our A Grade was drinking alcohol in the last quarter while the game was in the balance is completely delusional. I would know, I was drinking from the said bottles during the game. Its good to see facts aren't getting in the way of the drunken rumours though.

Duncs, you clearly weren't at the game, if you were you would know that at no stage would anyone have said the game was done. Instead of relying on misinformation, if you wanted to get something as stupid as that confirmed or denied, how about just flicking us a PM instead of running with tripe?

The best lawyer is at Kilburn

I strongly disagree with that Jimmy.





No one pays their bills at Kilburn!

The grey area is allowing umpires to do this can create bias its either a yellow off for 10 can replace or a red off for the game can replace after 10 mins
The whole leave it up to the umpires is rubbish they can barely call the game right let alone have the right to pick and choose if a player can or cant be replaced !

Sigh......please take it as ABSOLUTE FACT

Yellow card - player off for ten minutes and CAN BE REPLACED IMMEDIATELY

Red Card - player is reported and sent off for a minimum of 10 minutes, or up to the rest of the game (at the umpires discretion) They are allowed to be replaced after 10 minutes - not "maybe" - but they will be allowed to - no grey area, it is clear.

If a team has not sought to replace them after 10 minutes - that's their own fault.

You had two highly experienced Division 1 Umpires (both have done Div 1 GF's) - so they would have done exactly the right procedure.

And Wonder Kid - saying the umpires can barely call the game right.........you are a knob.

However, I have heard that the amateur league confirmed to North Haven that Salisbury will be staying in div 4.

That's what I've heard too.

You would THINK that the winner will be forced to go up at least! I suppose this also hinges on how many clubs from Div 3 have put their hand up to come down.
Our club doesn't know where we are playing due to factors completely out of our control, so I don't know how others can possibly know. Unless other people know something about the make-up of the league in 2016 that we don't?

With that being said, I'm preparing for Div 3.

Regarding the original point, wouldn't it have just been easier to confirm that the player wasn't in the SFL game and thereby shouldn't have been on the team sheet?

No idea how the League verifies school games, particularly when it's an "older" returned scholar.

My biggest qualm with the Old Scholars as zero points system is that SMOSH, Unley and SHOC get to effectively "double dip" by being aligned to a school and running their own junior programs.

We've given passing thought to changing our name to Payneham Norwood Union Marryatville Morialta to jig the same system.

We need another oval: PAOCPNUFC?

*PNUPAOCFC

Actually, compromise, PPAOCNUFC

We can return to the Payneham Football Club Maroon guernseys, use yellow numbers, and I can take my rightful spot as an H Grader

Edit, you'll also have to ease up on the #CommunicationCareResponsibilityRespect business. That won't go down well with our membership, players or committee in the slightest.

Mrs 041 has noted, on more than one occasion, that #CCRR is a new phenomena completely foreign to me

Pffft. Allen is overweight. Skinny Scott Galbraith's the man to watch!

Put the game in September and pick the Kilburn side. Chics don't lose in September.

I always tell people not to judge others because you don't al know what they're going through or what information they're basing their decision on. I'm also shit at taking my own advice

SOFT, SOFT, SOFT!!!

Salisbury easily have the ability to complete in div 3. They are not going to improve by playing against weak opposition each week. The money issue is bullshit, they have enough players as it is and other clubs go up the divisions with no or minimal payments.

Sounds like some of the board members are trying to be too clever by half, God knows what their reasoning is but it is wrong. If I was a player I'd be shattered. It would be like last years efforts and accomplishments were worth nothing. Salisbury FC you've let your players down!

What I would give for the City of Norwood, Payneham and St Peters to be even mildly supportive of Australian Rules Football

Likewise Port Adelaide Enfield

I suppose it could be worse, you could be stuck in a shit fight with the North Adelaide Residents Association like PAOC


Literally - very amusing

As the footy director of CLG i can tell you that this is the biggest load of BS i have read on this forum. We have had no contact with Heccies and have no intention of doing so. We look forward to being in div 4 next year and are not a club who believe in nominating where we want to play.

Have heard Rhys o'keiff from North Adelaide, formally on carltons list for s few years off to the chics after being cut by the roosters, great get if true

Wristy that doesn't mean the players aren't college poofs.

Sass Modbury is a shit hole, shit heap deck, wet stinky changerooms. Should ask for $3mil to knock the dung heap down and start again.

Saafl did this when they let brahma go down to div 5!

And history will suggest saafl knew exactly what they were doing because they had all the information. Even letting them into Division 5 didn’t save them from relegation to Div 6 and they were 1 win from relegation to Division 7 this year. It’s not like they went to Div 5 and won a flag so hardly apples for apples. What happened to Brahma resulted in a new rule of 3 player limit from one club to another state wide too

As keen as I wasn't on it at the time, the reality is the brahma thing was another chapter in the “beware Div 4 clubs going to Div 3’ book…….Kilburn, Salisbury West, and now Salisbury. Saafl should have had the power to say no to Salisbury based on below

Salisbury A grade played in grand Final and lost by two points.
Salisbury B grade went through the season undefeated winning a flag
Salisbury C grade won 7 matches (no forfeits) in C2
Salisbury have an U 18 team

Seaton Finished 9th (bottom) in the A grade and won 2 matches
Seaton B grade won 1 match
Seaton C grade won 5 matches in C3 (3 by forfeit) and forfeited 4/5 times themselves.
Seaton do not have an U18 team

if it was an application to stay down as against a right, there is no way Seaton should be in Division 3 over Salisbury.

If you work for Newscorp you're not the only person at your place of employment that needs a proof reader!

Quite, in Year 7 for English lessons our teacher used to give us grammatical tests. The content of the test was to identify the errors in Advertiser articles.

You felt rather high and mighty until you discover it's being written for a reading age of 8 or something along those lines

Just quietly, Chics don't lose finals. I'm still drunk. Up the fist!

Negative. The club is finalising negotiations with Corey Pressler to come back to the club to attempt a hat trick of premierships as captain.

Congrats to the big shrek on the weekend bagging the big 10. Pity that he was on the wrong end of them.