Rd 16 Sturt v North

[Hondo]

Has BEn Hart played in a winning game for North yet this season ???

No - and doesn't that say something?

Well, he has been in our best players so, to me, it says these 2 posters have an axe to grind

Why?

[Hondo]

i'm just asking, this it is not to upset anyone i'm just curious


is norths lack of form & reading between the lines off field problems have anything to do with a.jarman putting his hand up to coach melbourne ? (it seems to have happened at the same time)

Geez, lose 2 games and the team is falling apart?

Now there are 'off field' problems too?

Bayman - how many 'I'm just curious, but.....' questions can you pose about North in one season?

Guess its flattering you spend so much time thinking about the mighty Roosters

[BPBRB]

i'm just asking, this it is not to upset anyone i'm just curious


is norths lack of form & reading between the lines off field problems have anything to do with a.jarman putting his hand up to coach melbourne ? (it seems to have happened at the same time)

Geez, lose 2 games and the team is falling apart?

Now there are 'off field' problems too?

Bayman - how many 'just curious' (stirring the pot) questions can you pose about North in one season?

Guess its flattering you spend so much time thinking about the mighty Roosters

Well Hondo - I wouldn't say all is well "off field" at North and you can read into that what you want.

[heater31]

does this disharmony involve the coach in any way?????

[Hondo]

Well Hondo - I wouldn't say all is well "off field" at North and you can read into that what you want.

You know BPBRB - for someone who seems in the know at the club, or seems to have the confidence of someone close to the club, it's very concerning for me as a member how often you come on this public forum with negative innuendo about the club. Either you are betraying someone's confidence or you are knifing the club for reasons I don't know?

Tell it like it is or shut up. Leave this rumour stuff where it belongs. If you are going to say something, come out and say it up front.

[smithy]

Do you have an "official " role at the club Drebin ?
Honest question..

[G]

Hondo I tend to agree with you and cant see too many positives coming out of his threads.

[BPBRB]

Well Hondo - I wouldn't say all is well "off field" at North and you can read into that what you want.

You know BPBRB - for someone who seems in the know at the club, or seems to have the confidence of someone close to the club, it's very concerning for me as a member how often you come on this public forum with negative innuendo about the club. Either you are betraying someone's confidence or you are knifing the club for reasons I don't know?

Tell it like it is or shut up. Leave this rumour stuff where it belongs. If you are going to say something, come out and say it up front.

Tell it like it is or shut up! hmm issues here - what do I do first?

Do you want me not to post negative stuff about North or just bullshit and pretend all is right presently? Well email Wedgie and tell him not to put up any losing scores, comments, injury reports etc about North because you might see that as a negative for starters.

Tell it like it is and up front hey? Well here is how it is - I'm entitled to post what I like so don't tell me I'm knifing the club etc etc. Get your head out your a*se and find out yourself what's going on instead of pretending everything is alright all the time. Issues happen in all clubs off field for a variety of reasons over a season.

Ever thought that some people at the club in positions of authority like some "issues" to be made public so changes can be made or start to be made and supporters are not being kept in the dark or having bullshit told to them by certain parties?

[johntheclaret]

The official line is a neck injury (carrying his ego around can't help that!) but the real issue is his groins - he has been struggling since the end of 2006 hence his inability to get his fitness and weight right during the pre-season. He competed with North's permission on Sat. arvo.

Allan is in the same boat with groin issues causing extra strain on his hammies. We missed them both yesterday but more so Allan.

Think I only 1/2 agree with you BPBRB. A fit Ladhams on form would have been a big plus up forward. Maybe Wundke, Gill and Ladhams, crumbing, up front, with Alleyway at CHF. Agree though that Allan was a big miss on Sunday, although it is questionable whether he would have got near anything from the rucks such was Sturt's dominance.

[johntheclaret]

Has BEn Hart played in a winning game for North yet this season ???

No he hasn't Jar Man Out, so is this question just out of interest or are you fishing for some other reason.

I take it by your user name you have a real interest in North both on and off the field. Well if you are that interested in North, you will have taken a look at the Roost's Fans Player of the Year award and would have seen the number of votes he received this week, so I guess you are just fishing.

Hart was one of our few stand outs on Sunday, and we would have probably lost by more but for him playing. I for one thought he should have had a run in the two's last week instead of coming straight in, but last weeks run out seems to have done him some good. Well done to him too.

By the way, if your question wsa loaded along the lines of Hart playing = North losing, then take a look at the results so far. We have done quite well in managing to lose without him.

[BPBRB]

Has BEn Hart played in a winning game for North yet this season ???

No he hasn't Jar Man Out, so is this question just out of interest or are you fishing for some other reason.

I take it by your user name you have a real interest in North both on and off the field. Well if you are that interested in North, you will have taken a look at the Roost's Fans Player of the Year award and would have seen the number of votes he received this week, so I guess you are just fishing.

Hart was one of our few stand outs on Sunday, and we would have probably lost by more but for him playing. I for one thought he should have had a run in the two's last week instead of coming straight in, but last weeks run out seems to have done him some good. Well done to him too.

By the way, if your question wsa loaded along the lines of Hart playing = North losing, then take a look at the results so far. We have done quite well in managing to lose without him.

Disagree JTC - we have lost only 1 game (at the Bay) with Ben Hart out - again what does that say?

[johntheclaret]

Has BEn Hart played in a winning game for North yet this season ???

No he hasn't Jar Man Out, so is this question just out of interest or are you fishing for some other reason.

I take it by your user name you have a real interest in North both on and off the field. Well if you are that interested in North, you will have taken a look at the Roost's Fans Player of the Year award and would have seen the number of votes he received this week, so I guess you are just fishing.

Hart was one of our few stand outs on Sunday, and we would have probably lost by more but for him playing. I for one thought he should have had a run in the two's last week instead of coming straight in, but last weeks run out seems to have done him some good. Well done to him too.

By the way, if your question wsa loaded along the lines of Hart playing = North losing, then take a look at the results so far. We have done quite well in managing to lose without him.

Disagree JTC - we have lost only 1 game (at the Bay) with Ben Hart out - again what does that say?

Sorry Skeff, but you can't blame Ben IMO for Sunday's loss. Last week, against Port, we lost the game in the 1st qtr, playing Perrie at CHB and showed nothing all over the park. Sturt are a much better team than Port ATM, and on both occasions, Jarmans team selection had as much to do with the losses as the poor player performance.

[BPBRB]

Has BEn Hart played in a winning game for North yet this season ???

No he hasn't Jar Man Out, so is this question just out of interest or are you fishing for some other reason.

I take it by your user name you have a real interest in North both on and off the field. Well if you are that interested in North, you will have taken a look at the Roost's Fans Player of the Year award and would have seen the number of votes he received this week, so I guess you are just fishing.

Hart was one of our few stand outs on Sunday, and we would have probably lost by more but for him playing. I for one thought he should have had a run in the two's last week instead of coming straight in, but last weeks run out seems to have done him some good. Well done to him too.

By the way, if your question wsa loaded along the lines of Hart playing = North losing, then take a look at the results so far. We have done quite well in managing to lose without him.

Disagree JTC - we have lost only 1 game (at the Bay) with Ben Hart out - again what does that say?

Sorry Skeff, but you can't blame Ben IMO for Sunday's loss. Last week, against Port, we lost the game in the 1st qtr, playing Perrie at CHB and showed nothing all over the park. Sturt are a much better team than Port ATM, and on both occasions, Jarmans team selection had as much to do with the losses as the poor player performance.

I agree JTC - especially your last line.

[Hondo]

Ever thought that some people at the club in positions of authority like some "issues" to be made public so changes can be made or start to be made and supporters are not being kept in the dark or having bullshit told to them by certain parties?

That's what I thought ..... can't escape club politics hey? Sounds like some disgruntled club political faction to me - a faction looking for a change in the coach. At least just be honest and say so.

As usual, you still haven't actually said what these off-field problems are like I asked. You state your right to 'expose' the issues but haven't told us what the issues are ... all you say is there are 'issues'. And then you try to say that is a way of supporting a club and creating positive change?

My challenge to you, to put it another way, is to stop lurking in the shadows with your innuendos/hints/rumours and come out, stand up like a man and tell us EXACTLY what's going on.

If you aren't prepared to spill the facts for fear of it becoming obvious who you are or who those people in 'positions of authority at the club' are, then you're just a rumour-monger to me with no credibility. Prove me wrong ....

[BPBRB]

Ever thought that some people at the club in positions of authority like some "issues" to be made public so changes can be made or start to be made and supporters are not being kept in the dark or having bullshit told to them by certain parties?

That's what I thought ..... can't escape club politics hey? Sounds like some disgruntled club political faction to me - a faction looking for a change in the coach. At least just be honest and say so.

As usual, you still haven't actually said what these off-field problems are like I asked. You state your right to 'expose' the issues but haven't told us what the issues are ... all you say is there are 'issues'. And then you try to say that is a way of supporting a club and creating positive change?

My challenge to you, to put it another way, is to stop lurking in the shadows with your innuendos/hints/rumours and come out, stand up like a man and tell us EXACTLY what's going on.

If you aren't prepared to spill the facts for fear of it becoming obvious who you are or who those people in 'positions of authority at the club' are, then you're just a rumour-monger to me with no credibility. Prove me wrong ....

Okay I am a rumour monger with no credibility.

[Jar Man Out]

Has BEn Hart played in a winning game for North yet this season ???

No he hasn't Jar Man Out, so is this question just out of interest or are you fishing for some other reason.

I take it by your user name you have a real interest in North both on and off the field. Well if you are that interested in North, you will have taken a look at the Roost's Fans Player of the Year award and would have seen the number of votes he received this week, so I guess you are just fishing.

Hart was one of our few stand outs on Sunday, and we would have probably lost by more but for him playing. I for one thought he should have had a run in the two's last week instead of coming straight in, but last weeks run out seems to have done him some good. Well done to him too.

By the way, if your question wsa loaded along the lines of Hart playing = North losing, then take a look at the results so far. We have done quite well in managing to lose without him.

Geesh ask a simple question and some people get all upset.

brilliant reaction boys. hahahaha!!!!!

This post is funnier than some of the dummy spits on the roost. Play on.

[johntheclaret]

Has BEn Hart played in a winning game for North yet this season ???

No he hasn't Jar Man Out, so is this question just out of interest or are you fishing for some other reason.

I take it by your user name you have a real interest in North both on and off the field. Well if you are that interested in North, you will have taken a look at the Roost's Fans Player of the Year award and would have seen the number of votes he received this week, so I guess you are just fishing.

Hart was one of our few stand outs on Sunday, and we would have probably lost by more but for him playing. I for one thought he should have had a run in the two's last week instead of coming straight in, but last weeks run out seems to have done him some good. Well done to him too.

By the way, if your question wsa loaded along the lines of Hart playing = North losing, then take a look at the results so far. We have done quite well in managing to lose without him.

Geesh ask a simple question and some people get all upset.

brilliant reaction boys. hahahaha!!!!!

This post is funnier than some of the dummy spits on the roost. Play on.

Not a dummy spit at all Jar Man Out and trust me, theres nothing you could write that would upset me. Just don't see the point of a so called supporter of one club, having such a odd user name clearly pointed at the coach of another team.

Just pointing out that, as usual with you, your post was just fishing. Clearly you have nothing of interest to post about your own team or any other team in the SANFL for that matter.

Still, it is good to see you did a backflip by pretending that you were asking a "simple question".

So here is a simple answer.

No??????????????

Apologies to you Jar Man Out for my original reply.

Keeping it simple is probably best for you .