by Sojourner » Fri Aug 24, 2007 8:08 pm
If the club does not make some fairly dramatic changes, anyone who coaches the club will be recieving a poisoned chalice irrespective of who they are.
Still with the review underway being led by Kevin Morris hopefully these issues will be concisively dealt with.
Luke Darcy is my no 1 choice at present, yet it is unlikley that he will be moving from Vic at this stage which rules that out.
Michael Nunan is my next choice, yet it comes back to if he has the desire for it or not and my feeling is that with SANFL footy he has been there and done that and looks to different challenges.
I feel that of all the candidates put forward, the best one for South Adelaide is Phil Carman.
Phil Carman is one candidate (along with Nunan) that can show that he has taken a bottom tier SANFL club and made them competitive. He has been there and done the hard yards before. Gary Cameron would do well to serve an apprenticeship under Carman if he has senior coaching ambitions.
Cameron is a good candidate, yet whatever Kevin Morris report is, the likely result is that a number of players and maybe even some staff need to be let go. Someone like Cameron is going to be comprimised in making those decisions, wheras someone like Phil Carman has no such loyalties to anyone and can make the hard decisions that South so desperately need to have made.
Steamranger, South Australia's best ever Tourist Attraction, Treat Yourself, Let your Money Buy you Happiness!!!