Round 12: Central vs Glenelg Review

[Pseudo]

I only thought we got two free kicks we shouldn't have - McConnells in the third when he goaled from 45 m out - the bumps on TV appeared to be in the side and Westoffs when he was disrobed no real prior opportunity - can see why it was paid as he took two steps to play on but IMO that was a tough one. Everyone other free kick was warranted IMO. I thought they we're consistent in the holding the ball rule - players were pinged only if they had prior (except my one example).

I thought the Bays got 2 goals from wrongly awarded free kicks. McConnell's as described above was one of them, but the other was big Sellar's goal in the second term. For the life of me I don't remember exactly what the free was paid for now - might have been interference in the marking contest - I just remember thinking that it was a pretty stiff call.

I disagree with your call on the Westhoff tackle though - I thought that was just about perfect.

[MagareyLegend]

.... the other was big Sellar's goal in the second term. For the life of me I don't remember exactly what the free was paid for now - might have been interference in the marking contest - I just remember thinking that it was a pretty stiff call.

It was paid for knocking away arms. Agreed it was stiff but that is the (ridiculous) rule.

[CENTURION]

Bumped into the Manna Hill constabulary yet Centurion ?

Why would I? I'm a good boy

[tigersupporter]

I only thought we got two free kicks we shouldn't have - McConnells in the third when he goaled from 45 m out - the bumps on TV appeared to be in the side and Westoffs when he was disrobed no real prior opportunity - can see why it was paid as he took two steps to play on but IMO that was a tough one. Everyone other free kick was warranted IMO. I thought they we're consistent in the holding the ball rule - players were pinged only if they had prior (except my one example).

I thought the Bays got 2 goals from wrongly awarded free kicks. McConnell's as described above was one of them, but the other was big Sellar's goal in the second term. For the life of me I don't remember exactly what the free was paid for now - might have been interference in the marking contest - I just remember thinking that it was a pretty stiff call.

I disagree with your call on the Westhoff tackle though -

I thought that was just about perfect.

He was gone for all money from where I was standing.

[Punk Rooster]

but common sense prevailed. It's a pretty good thing these days, you might want to check it out.

This coming from someone who wants a job in the media but who spends the majority of his time nitpicking the media's errors. Now that's common sense.

this coming from someone who starred in Lord of the Rings?

[doggies4eva]

.... the other was big Sellar's goal in the second term. For the life of me I don't remember exactly what the free was paid for now - might have been interference in the marking contest - I just remember thinking that it was a pretty stiff call.

It was paid for knocking away arms. Agreed it was stiff but that is the (ridiculous) rule.

Have watched this multiple times on the replay and don't agree with it. Lawry puched the ball with one hand and then grabbed it on the way down - should have been a mark. He was playing the ball, was in front. The resulting goal probably stopped any hope that the doggies had of stealing a win so was a crucial error by the umps.

[TigerBoss]

[dogs01]

No ones said anything about the stupid 25 - 50?metre penalty given against Paul Thomas that also resulted in a goal. As i see it people have pin pointed 3 or 4 goals the bays got which resulted in goals. What was the end margin?
The bays WERE the better side, but the dogs out scored them after qtr time.

[tigersupporter]

yes you did out score us after quarter time, but it took you until the last quarter to kick two goals in a row, so once and for all, stop going on about the umpires, your team played SH1T!. We have had the worst of the umpires for years, because we were SH1T..... PLAY ON.

[stampy]

christ talk about sour grapes , good comment dan, the fact is that when the game was there to be set up for victory, glenelg smashed central district - simple as that really,

[Big Phil]

but common sense prevailed. It's a pretty good thing these days, you might want to check it out.

This coming from someone who wants a job in the media but who spends the majority of his time nitpicking the media's errors. Now that's common sense.

this coming from someone who starred in Lord of the Rings?

Don't quite know what that means Punky....

But Topsy...

Yeah, what he said...

Big Phil...

[TigerBoss]

Is there an award for the person that uses the most emoticons in each post that I haven't heard about on this site?

[Dirko]

Is there an award for the person that uses the most emoticons in each post that I haven't heard about on this site?

[smithy]

You can see all 90 minutes of emoticons on his movie.

[smithy]

Sorry Jardog I don't get ya ?

OK you deleted.....disregard.

[Jardog]

What does emoticons mean?

[smithy]

What does emoticons mean?

Here you go Jardog

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emoticon

[Big Phil]

You can see all 90 minutes of emoticons on his movie.

I might be a bit of a chubber like the fella in the picture and my Fat Albert avatar BUT unlike either of them mate, I'm not dark skinned Smithy...

Other than that, nice one mate...

Big Phil...

[CENTURION]

You can see all 90 minutes of emoticons on his movie.

I might be a bit of a chubber like the fella in the picture and my Fat Albert avatar BUT unlike either of them mate, I'm not dark skinned Smithy...

Other than that, nice one mate...

Big Phil...

Careful, big fella, someone might call you a RACIST!

[whufc]

Umpiring was a disgrace, the worst i have ever seen it and yes Glenelg got the better of it BUT IT HAD NO IMPACT ON THE RESULT, Glenelg were the far better side and easily deserved the win. Us Dogs have some catching up to do but i think we can with the inclusion of C.Gowans and Callinan plus a few more games under Symes belt and hopefully he will qualify for finals.

And im out for one week in soccer with my ankle, and i have a feeling Callinan will be one more week away.