2012 Reports & Tribunal Discussion

[Dying Swan]

Please let North meet Centrals in the finals, cant wait for the rematch, could be a few square ups.

Yes - could be interesting with those Gowans squealing like a stuck pig when things don't go their way. There are 8 umpires out there (if there were 3 boundary guys) and none of them saw any incident, there is no vision and then both players are cited by the flawed Review Panel, but one did some striking and the other obviously just stood there and got hit. Yeh - right! I wonder which one of the Gowans was wrestling on the ground with a North player in the centre, and then pummeling him and no umpire saw that either. Very selective!

[sjt]

Please let North meet Centrals in the finals, cant wait for the rematch, could be a few square ups.

Yes - could be interesting with those Gowans squealing like a stuck pig when things don't go their way. There are 8 umpires out there (if there were 3 boundary guys) and none of them saw any incident, there is no vision and then both players are cited by the flawed Review Panel, but one did some striking and the other obviously just stood there and got hit. Yeh - right! I wonder which one of the Gowans was wrestling on the ground with a North player in the centre, and then pummeling him and no umpire saw that either. Very selective!

So you know what happened and what evidence was produced? Because no umpire saw it and there's no video means it didn't happen? I saw macintosh once knock out Brenton sickerdick behind the play, no report no video but I'll always remember it.
You wonder which gowans was wrestling with a north player on the ground. You saw it and don't even know the two players involved. I saw it as did the umpire standing over them at the time.

[on the rails]

Gowans is a cowardly sniper - lucky the racial card was not played!

[Big Phil]

Gowans is a cowardly sniper - lucky the racial card was not played!

Did you see the incident, Skeff?

[The Sleeping Giant]

Did you Phil?

[Big Phil]

Did you Phil?

No. Did you?

I did see James with a massive fat lip in the rooms after the game though...

[smac]

Gowans is a cowardly sniper - lucky the racial card was not played!

Sounds like it just was.

[sjt]

Gowans is a cowardly sniper - lucky the racial card was not played!

Clinch got two games, we know who the sniper is. To call him a coward is pathetic, as is your inference.

[The Sleeping Giant]

Did you Phil?

No. Did you?

I did see James with a massive fat lip in the rooms after the game though...

Now we know why you thought he had teeth missing. Obviously his lip was hiding them.

[sjt]

Did you Phil?

No. Did you?

I did see James with a massive fat lip in the rooms after the game though...

Now we know why you thought he had teeth missing. Obviously his lip was hiding them.

It was probably just another north "love tap to the guts" or "punch to the stomach".

[CENTURION]

Please let North meet Centrals in the finals, cant wait for the rematch, could be a few square ups.

you mean like what some Norwood supporters have been threatening Us with since 2010?

[CENTURION]

Gowans is a cowardly sniper - lucky the racial card was not played!

Are you implying that James Gowans called Clinch a black c**, or something similar? If so, why hasn't Clinch taken this further? Most clubs these days would.

[whufc]

Gowans is a cowardly sniper - lucky the racial card was not played!

Are you implying that James Gowans called Clinch a black c**, or something similar? If so, why hasn't Clinch taken this further? Most clubs these days would.

Well his not a green c is he!!

[Jim05]

Please let North meet Centrals in the finals, cant wait for the rematch, could be a few square ups.

you mean like what some Norwood supporters have been threatening Us with since 2010?

Nah said all along that incident didnt bother me.
Just thinking a cut throat final with the Gowan's and Alleway retiring could get a little intetesting. My money would still be on Alleway going out with a bang especially if North was a few goals down in the last.
Cant see Clinch being involved as id be surprised if North won 2 finals but you never know

[cennals05]

Gowans is a cowardly sniper - lucky the racial card was not played!

How convenient to get on a football forum and accuse someone of being a racist when they can’t defend themselves. Yet the person that was allegedly racially vilified hasn’t reported it to anyone or taken it further.

I take it you were out on the field and heard James racially vilify Clinch?

If not your comments are the kind that could get sites like this sued.

[CENTURION]

this site? SUED? NAH....

[JK]

this site? SUED? NAH....

It's been Pseud a few times though (at least 34)

[doggies4eva]

Please let North meet Centrals in the finals, cant wait for the rematch, could be a few square ups.

I'd be happy to see that - providing it was the Grand Final

[sjt]

Gowans is a cowardly sniper - lucky the racial card was not played!

How convenient to get on a football forum and accuse someone of being a racist when they can’t defend themselves. Yet the person that was allegedly racially vilified hasn’t reported it to anyone or taken it further.

I take it you were out on the field and heard James racially vilify Clinch?

If not your comments are the kind that could get sites like this sued.

Can the poster plead ignorance? He has a history of interpreting facts incorrectly.

[CENTURION]

interpretating? that's a new one!