by firstblood » Wed May 16, 2007 11:23 am
by BPBRB » Wed May 16, 2007 11:54 am
mal wrote: HARGY Heard some heckling in a preseason trial game, but dunno who the supporters were
by finn » Wed May 16, 2007 1:11 pm
firstblood wrote:I pose a question...why did Jericho choose Norwood to go to? Why wasn't he sent to the
next team (Sturt) that finished second to bottom last year ? Willetts didn't have a choice
although i'm happy he's with West. Doe's this open a can of worms for Crows/Power listed
players to choose who they want to play with if their not happy with the club they are tied to?
by HeartBeatsTrue » Wed May 16, 2007 1:25 pm
finn wrote:firstblood wrote:I pose a question...why did Jericho choose Norwood to go to? Why wasn't he sent to the
next team (Sturt) that finished second to bottom last year ? Willetts didn't have a choice
although i'm happy he's with West. Doe's this open a can of worms for Crows/Power listed
players to choose who they want to play with if their not happy with the club they are tied to?
This may be wrong but I think afl listed players have to go to the team that is bottom at that time that they wish to transfer. previously they could go to their team of 'choice'. Is this the case?
This case may be muddied by the fact that he was a west player prior to be being afl listed - can anybody enlighten me as to whether this changes things?
by doggies4eva » Wed May 16, 2007 1:28 pm
finn wrote:firstblood wrote:I pose a question...why did Jericho choose Norwood to go to? Why wasn't he sent to the
next team (Sturt) that finished second to bottom last year ? Willetts didn't have a choice
although i'm happy he's with West. Doe's this open a can of worms for Crows/Power listed
players to choose who they want to play with if their not happy with the club they are tied to?
This may be wrong but I think afl listed players have to go to the team that is bottom at that time that they wish to transfer. previously they could go to their team of 'choice'. Is this the case?
This case may be muddied by the fact that he was a west player prior to be being afl listed - can anybody enlighten me as to whether this changes things?
by HeartBeatsTrue » Wed May 16, 2007 1:36 pm
doggies4eva wrote:finn wrote:firstblood wrote:I pose a question...why did Jericho choose Norwood to go to? Why wasn't he sent to the
next team (Sturt) that finished second to bottom last year ? Willetts didn't have a choice
although i'm happy he's with West. Doe's this open a can of worms for Crows/Power listed
players to choose who they want to play with if their not happy with the club they are tied to?
This may be wrong but I think afl listed players have to go to the team that is bottom at that time that they wish to transfer. previously they could go to their team of 'choice'. Is this the case?
This case may be muddied by the fact that he was a west player prior to be being afl listed - can anybody enlighten me as to whether this changes things?
I don't think this is correct - see the thread on AFL/SANFL relations. Port have been a major gainer and I don't remember them being bottom lately.
by dash61 » Wed May 16, 2007 2:25 pm
HeartBeatsTrue wrote:finn wrote:firstblood wrote:I pose a question...why did Jericho choose Norwood to go to? Why wasn't he sent to the
next team (Sturt) that finished second to bottom last year ? Willetts didn't have a choice
although i'm happy he's with West. Doe's this open a can of worms for Crows/Power listed
players to choose who they want to play with if their not happy with the club they are tied to?
This may be wrong but I think afl listed players have to go to the team that is bottom at that time that they wish to transfer. previously they could go to their team of 'choice'. Is this the case?
This case may be muddied by the fact that he was a west player prior to be being afl listed - can anybody enlighten me as to whether this changes things?
by MST » Wed May 16, 2007 3:33 pm
Punk Rooster wrote:an ex-North Premiership player?Wedgie wrote:Pesonally Ive only been bitter about one North player lining up for another club and that was because no other club in the state would play him after what he did.
by redandblack » Wed May 16, 2007 3:36 pm
HeartBeatsTrue wrote:doggies4eva wrote:finn wrote:firstblood wrote:I pose a question...why did Jericho choose Norwood to go to? Why wasn't he sent to the
next team (Sturt) that finished second to bottom last year ? Willetts didn't have a choice
although i'm happy he's with West. Doe's this open a can of worms for Crows/Power listed
players to choose who they want to play with if their not happy with the club they are tied to?
This may be wrong but I think afl listed players have to go to the team that is bottom at that time that they wish to transfer. previously they could go to their team of 'choice'. Is this the case?
This case may be muddied by the fact that he was a west player prior to be being afl listed - can anybody enlighten me as to whether this changes things?
I don't think this is correct - see the thread on AFL/SANFL relations. Port have been a major gainer and I don't remember them being bottom lately.
I did say my theory was a long shot. Perhaps players can choose in this situation.
by Coorong » Wed May 16, 2007 5:39 pm
by dash61 » Wed May 16, 2007 6:11 pm
by Coorong » Wed May 16, 2007 6:15 pm
dash61 wrote:The crows were not a factor, jericho and norwood are the facts
by Wedgie » Wed May 16, 2007 6:37 pm
Armchair expert wrote:Such a great club are Geelong
by mal » Wed May 16, 2007 6:47 pm
BPBRB wrote:mal wrote: HARGY Heard some heckling in a preseason trial game, but dunno who the supporters were
You seriously make sh*t up don't you? Hargy was injured for the North vs. Port trial and the only heckling he got was when he joined his North mates (me included) for a beer (or two) during the game because he was wearing the slimming black PAMFC polo shirt.
As pointed in other posts, North supporters are angry with the fact he got sacked from North and would love to have him finish his career at Prospect. Now Weatherley is out for up to 8 Weeks Hargs would be invaluable at FF. Should still be at Prospect.
by dash61 » Wed May 16, 2007 7:04 pm
Wedgie wrote:Just on this issue I got a bit of clarification today.
Don't expect the Power or Crows to ever be in dispute with a SANFL club about their player but DO expect lots of players requesting to move (in most cases, obviously null and void in cases like Willits).
a) If its a dispute exists then the rules saying the player goes to the previous year's bottom club.
b) If a player just wants to move basically he can go where he wants to.
Both situations incur a transfer fee but the transfer fees for case a is minimal and goes up slightly if the bottom club turns him down, etc but a points system exists as per normal transfers which can mean a pretty hefty fee (someone did mention one somewhere for Jericho) exists for the 2nd case.
Glenelg actually played pretty hefty fees for both Clarke and Parker and ended up with about 7 games in total to show for it.
by BPBRB » Wed May 16, 2007 7:52 pm
mal wrote:BPBRB wrote:mal wrote: HARGY Heard some heckling in a preseason trial game, but dunno who the supporters were
You seriously make sh*t up don't you? Hargy was injured for the North vs. Port trial and the only heckling he got was when he joined his North mates (me included) for a beer (or two) during the game because he was wearing the slimming black PAMFC polo shirt.
As pointed in other posts, North supporters are angry with the fact he got sacked from North and would love to have him finish his career at Prospect. Now Weatherley is out for up to 8 Weeks Hargs would be invaluable at FF. Should still be at Prospect.
He was standing at the parade goals,
a couple of guys yelled something at him from around the forward pocket area
The 2 other guys I was with commented on what appeared to be heckling
But then again the 3 of us should get our ears checked out in case theres a problem
by doggies4eva » Wed May 16, 2007 9:19 pm
Wedgie wrote:Just on this issue I got a bit of clarification today.
Don't expect the Power or Crows to ever be in dispute with a SANFL club about their player but DO expect lots of players requesting to move (in most cases, obviously null and void in cases like Willits).
a) If its a dispute exists then the rules saying the player goes to the previous year's bottom club.
b) If a player just wants to move basically he can go where he wants to.
Both situations incur a transfer fee but the transfer fees for case a is minimal and goes up slightly if the bottom club turns him down, etc but a points system exists as per normal transfers which can mean a pretty hefty fee (someone did mention one somewhere for Jericho) exists for the 2nd case.
Glenelg actually played pretty hefty fees for both Clarke and Parker and ended up with about 7 games in total to show for it.
by Wedgie » Wed May 16, 2007 9:22 pm
doggies4eva wrote:Interesting. So theoretically if an AFL club was to whisper in a player's ear that he should request a transfer using rule b) above because it suited the agenda of that AFL club better then they could manipulate the system![]()
Lucky that both of our AFL clubs are too ethical to do this
Armchair expert wrote:Such a great club are Geelong
by dash61 » Wed May 16, 2007 9:24 pm
by sturt1 » Wed May 16, 2007 9:42 pm
firstblood wrote:I pose a question...why did Jericho choose Norwood to go to? Why wasn't he sent to the
next team (Sturt) that finished second to bottom last year ? Willetts didn't have a choice
although i'm happy he's with West. Doe's this open a can of worms for Crows/Power listed
players to choose who they want to play with if their not happy with the club they are tied to?
Competitions SANFL Official Site | Country Footy SA | Southern Football League | VFL Footy
Club Forums Snouts Louts | The Roost | Redlegs Forum |