Top 10 Most Hated Players ???

[Footy Chick]

I just thought of another one.
Rohan Smith (never bothered me while playing for Port. But he took out a PHOS player behind play in the dieing minutes of a preliminary final in A1 amatures while playing for port district. That guy missed out on playing in a premiership. How many premierships did you get to be a passenger in Rohan you bald headed prick?)

Nothing wrong with Rohan Smith mate, he is a quiet acheiver and was always a much under-rated player... I was fortunate enough to have a good chat with him before our game a few weeks ago. A nicer bloke you'll never meet..

[yeva]

J. Gowans
C. Gowans
E. Ware
D. Schell
S. Salisbury
J. Clayton
T. Clements
B. Chambers
S. Carslake
S. Sims

I havent listed any gayfl players because thers not point!

can understand j.gowans and c.gowans..... but could also be in the "wish they played for my team" category but where does e. ware and d.schell fit into the scheme of things????????

[Barto]

No particular order and I'm sure others will come to mind later:

Scott Salisbury
Stephen Hay
Phil Harrison
Wayne Mahney
Neville Roberts
Michael Aish
Andrew Jarman
Darren Jarman
Ross Gibbs
Phil Gallagher

[Blue Boy]

No particular order and I'm sure others will come to mind later:

Scott Salisbury
Stephen Hay
Phil Harrison
Wayne Mahney
Neville Roberts
Michael Aish
Andrew Jarman
Darren Jarman
Ross Gibbs
Phil Gallagher

Barto - how can anyone hate Fud ???

[Footy Chick]

No particular order and I'm sure others will come to mind later:

Scott Salisbury
Stephen Hay
Phil Harrison
Wayne Mahney
Neville Roberts
Michael Aish
Andrew Jarman
Darren Jarman
Ross Gibbs
Phil Gallagher

Barto - how can anyone hate Fud ???

I knew there was someone I forgot... Never did care for Darren much, always been an Andrew fan..

[eaglehaslanded]

I've picked 3 from each team.

J Gowans (CD)
C Gowans (CD)
S Dew (CD)
S Salisbury (GL)
J Fidge (GL)
N Chigwidden (GL)
T Antrobous (NA)
J Riley (NA)
T Clisby (NA)
M Aish (NWD)
C Balme (NWD)
G McIntosh (NWD)
G Wanganeen (PA)
D Granger (PA)
B Cunningham (PA)
D Squire (ST)
S Feast (ST)
J Sheedy(ST)
B Warren (SA)
M Naley (SA)
S Palmer (SA)
G Goss (WA)
T Burgess (WA)
G Fielke (WA)

[JK]

I just thought of another one.
Rohan Smith (never bothered me while playing for Port. But he took out a PHOS player behind play in the dieing minutes of a preliminary final in A1 amatures while playing for port district. That guy missed out on playing in a premiership. How many premierships did you get to be a passenger in Rohan you bald headed prick?)

Avoided body contact like the plague when we played against Districts ... Mind you ya can when you win by about 30 goals, think Tylor pulled a "Havelberg" that day

[Blue Boy]

No particular order and I'm sure others will come to mind later:

Scott Salisbury
Stephen Hay
Phil Harrison
Wayne Mahney
Neville Roberts
Michael Aish
Andrew Jarman
Darren Jarman
Ross Gibbs
Phil Gallagher

Barto - how can anyone hate Fud ???

I knew there was someone I forgot... Never did care for Darren much, always been an Andrew fan..

Is this gonna be our first fight

[MST]

I've picked 3 from each team.

J Gowans (CD)
C Gowans (CD)
S Dew (CD)
S Salisbury (GL)
J Fidge (GL)
N Chigwidden (GL)
T Antrobous (NA)
J Riley (NA)
T Clisby (NA)
M Aish (NWD)
C Balme (NWD)
G McIntosh (NWD)
G Wanganeen (PA)
D Granger (PA)
B Cunningham (PA)
D Squire (ST)
S Feast (ST)
J Sheedy(ST)
B Warren (SA)
M Naley (SA)
S Palmer (SA)
G Goss (WA)
T Burgess (WA)
G Fielke (WA)

Not sure why you 'hate' those three particular blokes??

Gentlemen on and off the field.

As far as Feast and Squire go, I can understand why you don't like them.....

Because they were (Squiz) and are (Feasty) champion players.

[southee]

[quote=Has there been a reason to hate anyone from South?

Their supporters are more annoying than their players...[/quote]

Yes I agree, Mike Rann!!!

You love me though Clarrie!!

[stampy]

he also used to frequent the deli opposite the marion pub

"Bob's place". Back in the day, there wasn't a kid anywhere in the Marion area who didn't go there to play the pinnies and video games. Bob used to offer advice on the games, and would occasionally send a kid across the road to pick up his consignment of the News, and reward said kid with 20 cents for the machines. Memories...

i reckon the bloke that run it when kidney was around there was eric someone, does that ring a bell psuedo

[smithy]

if i remember rightly robin kidney made his debut 1983 against the dogs at elizabeth and he might have even kicked a goal with his first kick.

Indeed he did Stampy.
For some reason I remember watching the game on tv and the commentator said he kicked a goal with his 1st kick. (not sure of opposition though)
The umpire (Argent I think) also congratulated him immediately.

[stampy]

its funny how you remember things come to think of it i reckon he kicked it after the quarter time siren had gone, and i think that was the game that greg edwards suffered his injury - was it an eye injury? that just about ended his career

[Hondo]

Guys I remember hating:

Robin Kidney
Wayne Stringer
Alan Stringer
Brenton Klaebe
George Fiacchi
Wayne Mahney
Craig Kelly
Alan Bartlett
Scott Salisbury
Craig Balme

Can you tell the North supporter suffering in 85-86

[Aerie]

10 most hated players....

1) Sam Phillipou when he played for Port
2) Greg Phillips (for sitting on Laurence Schache and injuring him)
3) Damian Squire (didn't like him, but always admired him)
4) James Gowans (didn't like him, that is all)
5) Nathan Bock (the only player that I've ever known to play for the Eagles that didn't want to)
6) Brett O'Hara (easy, soft option)
7) Beveridge (can't remember his first name, FFS - he went to Sturt)
Clive Waterhouse (Yes, I admire him a little bit, but what a meat-head)
9) Brant Chambers (see Clive Watherhouse)
10) Bamford (most over-rated player in the history of SANFL)

[dogs01]

1) J.Ciccolella - Everyone hates the Gowans but this bloke is no different than them, if not worse.
2) P. Lindsay - ( see above ) - also gets away with murder.
3) J. Pedlar - ( see above )
4) B. Backwell - Good skill , but biggest seagull in the game.
5) D. Howard - Sniper, nuff said.
6) D. Cupido - Complete tool.
7) N. Gill - Overated. ( good mark, but Not AFL worthy.)
R. O'connor - Should never have won a magarey.
9) R. Williams - Hope umpires count
10) Pfieffer - Another shocking umpire.

[eaglehaslanded]

10 most hated players....

1) Sam Phillipou when he played for Port
2) Greg Phillips (for sitting on Laurence Schache and injuring him)
3) Damian Squire (didn't like him, but always admired him)
4) James Gowans (didn't like him, that is all)
5) Nathan Bock (the only player that I've ever known to play for the Eagles that didn't want to)
6) Brett O'Hara (easy, soft option)
7) Beveridge (can't remember his first name, FFS - he went to Sturt)
Clive Waterhouse (Yes, I admire him a little bit, but what a meat-head)
9) Brant Chambers (see Clive Watherhouse)
10) Bamford (most over-rated player in the history of SANFL)

What theeeeee (5) Bocky like all our other Crows listed players love the opportunity of pulling on the blue, green & gold of the Eagles I don't know where you've pulled this one from Aerie but I can assure you are wrong . (8) Andrew I believe mate - apparently sighted that Sturt would give him a better chance of playing in a premiership. Wooooops he stuffed that one up didn't he . (6) apparently along the line of bevo this one also sought opportunities else where to win a premiership. Wooooooooops not bloody likely me thinks.

[Barto]

No particular order and I'm sure others will come to mind later:

Scott Salisbury
Stephen Hay
Phil Harrison
Wayne Mahney
Neville Roberts
Michael Aish
Andrew Jarman
Darren Jarman
Ross Gibbs
Phil Gallagher

Barto - how can anyone hate Fud ???

Wouldn't piss on him if he was on fire.

[Jimmy]

im still waiting on the explanations for anyone hating beatle?

[Blue Boy]

No particular order and I'm sure others will come to mind later:

Scott Salisbury
Stephen Hay
Phil Harrison
Wayne Mahney
Neville Roberts
Michael Aish
Andrew Jarman
Darren Jarman
Ross Gibbs
Phil Gallagher

Barto - how can anyone hate Fud ???

Wouldn't piss on him if he was on fire.

Well explained