2007 Ins and Outs

[Wedgie]

Just for those that wonder where some posts from this topic went.
To keep things relevent Ive moved topsy's outburst along with reactions to his outburst to a new topic in the General Discussion Forum and kept the posts related to ins and outs here.
Nothing has been deleted, just reorganised to keep things on track.

[sydney-dog]

just to provide clarity in regards to my Ben and Josh

I am not saying North has breached or is in danger of breaching the salary cap, what I am saying is ex AFL players like Ben and Josh, do not come to the club for minimum wages

[Wedgie]

Its all conjecture anyway.
Jars has given Josh until the middle of December to make a decision but all reports are that he'll give it away as he only wants to play if his mind is 100% for it and that's not the case at this stage.
And who knows? Ben Hart could end up lining up on a half back flank for Geelong next year.

[sydney-dog]

it's interesting

Geelong and the Bombers were the big tip, but this morning Essendon has ruled out Drafting Hart

the Cats seem solid with tall defenders on their list, I think if an opportunity comes for Ben at AFL level it will be from a club straight out of left field who has played it's cards pretty close to their chest

all the best to Ben, no matter which way the cards fall for him

[sturt1]

Congradulations to North if they can bring former players back after they finished in the afl. I love it when my club does it to. As a matter of fact, there should be a provision for former players coming back from the afl, not be part of the salary cap. These boys have their sanfl club at heart should be given every opportunity to give back a little bit. They should be treated very much like marquee players are in the A-League. Only if they decide to continue with another SANFL club then they should be part of the salary cap.

This aside I still disagree with most things you say Wedgie

[mal]

Congradulations to North if they can bring former players back after they finished in the afl. I love it when my club does it to. As a matter of fact, there should be a provision for former players coming back from the afl, not be part of the salary cap. These boys have their sanfl club at heart should be given every opportunity to give back a little bit. They should be treated very much like marquee players are in the A-League. Only if they decide to continue with another SANFL club then they should be part of the salary cap.

This aside I still disagree with most things you say Wedgie

Great post.
Agree local players should not be totally included in a salary cap, makes sense.
The stalwarts coming back should be virtually exempt.

Maybe a compromise where a we could have 2 salary caps
A SA bred cap.
A non SA bred cap.

Each club should have concessions for their own bred players.

Ben Hart should be exempt from a salary cap being a veteran as well.

[sydney-dog]

A SA bred cap.
A non SA bred cap.

this would be a nightmare to police

why dont we scrap the cap all together and just have an import rule

[Wedgie]

This aside I still disagree with most things you say Wedgie

That's OK mate, I disagree with most things I say too!

[sturt1]

This aside I still disagree with most things you say Wedgie

That's OK mate, I disagree with most things I say too!

Why?

[Wedgie]

This aside I still disagree with most things you say Wedgie

That's OK mate, I disagree with most things I say too!

Why?

Why not?

[Blue Boy]

just to provide clarity in regards to my Ben and Josh

I am not saying North has breached or is in danger of breaching the salary cap, what I am saying is ex AFL players like Ben and Josh, do not come to the club for minimum wages

When did they become yours Syd !!!

[dash61]

Lets be honest, its going to come under a lot closer scrutiny this year and any breachers just need a Tuckey to get the pooh's on and other clubs may be in the same boat, a koops, a haynes, a cuppido, a baird, an anyone could really upset the apple cart and any one caught until it is more transparent " I say stiff shite"

[RustyCage]

Looby was going to play for Port Melbourne next year, but instead will be back for the Magpies

[Dogwatcher]

Not really effecting league sides, but certainly the depth of the clubs:

Renmark has picked up former Central Districts utility Aaron Camplin.
Moving to Renmark as a high school teacher.

North Adelaide under 19 captain Matt Bartlett also transferring to Renmark.

[Jimmy]

Not really effecting league sides, but certainly the depth of the clubs:

Renmark has picked up former Central Districts utility Aaron Camplin.
Moving to Renmark as a high school teacher.

North Adelaide under 19 captain Matt Bartlett also transferring to Renmark.

good stuff for campo, went to uni with him, good bloke

all the best to him up there and glad he is teaching now

[Dutchy]

Joel Perry, again from the Kangaroos, rumoured to have signed with the Port Magpies...

[RustyCage]

Joel Perry, again from the Kangaroos, rumoured to have signed with the Port Magpies...

All signed, sealed and delivered.

Also got a young ruckman from Whyalla, 204cm.

[Jar Man Out]

INS & OUTS THUS FAR

CENTRALS : OUT : P.Scoullar L.Mcabe S.Cochrane D.Kellett K.Officer (ret) C. Norsworthy (South) S. Brooks A.Bawden M.Taylor A.Camplin R.Butler H.Commane C.Mclean

IN; Nathan Grima & Ian Callinan (Tasmania) Charles Slattery (West) Lachlan Mcghie & Heath Lawry (Williamstown) Trent Goodrem (Easts NSW) Dylan Pfitzner (St Kilda) Ryan Williams (Power)



EAGLES : OUT : R.Potter (ret) A.Shattock (Qld) H.Skipworth & T.Oakley (VIC) S.Jacobs(Carlton)

IN: J. Rimmington (Coburg) B.Schwarze (Kangaroos) N.Batsanis (Power)



GLENELG - OUT - J.Kreuger (Perth) A.Rogers (VIC) B.Gibbs M. Austin (Carlton) M.Burdett T. Redden B. Yeomans J.Miller A.Button

IN: B.Murphy (Frankston) A.Cook (Geelong) S.Lewis (West) B.Kane (Hawthorn) S.Kane (East Rangers) J.Willoughby (Sydney) J.Juniper ( Fremantle) S.Rudolph (Box Hill) T.Boack (Power)



NORTH OUT - S.Koops G.Kellett (ret) D.Hargraves (Port Magpies) R.Nye (WA) B.Mcentee (Marion) S.Edwards (Ricmond) M.Campbell (Kangaroos) A.Moritz, B.Walton

IN- S.Motlop (Melbourne) B.Hart (Crows) T.Sporn (Carlton) J.Allen (Werribee) T.Stribling (Frem)D.Harris (Nth Ball) G.Grouse (Power)



NORWOOD - OUT - B.James (Ret) G.Hughes (W/Bulldogs) B.Vassall

IN- I.Vigglio (St Marys) C.Wynne (East Perth) K.Mcguiness (W/Bulldogs) E.Mcconnell (St Kilda) D.Rodan (Port)



PORT MAGPIES - OUT - P.Evans (Ret) M.Bullen S.Morrison J.Baird C.Davis (VIC) L.Thomas (Kangaroos) I.Weetra (Melbourne)

IN- L.Jarjoula (Sturt) D.Hargraves (North) B.Murray (Myrtleford) B.Lecras J.Perry J.Perkins (Kangaroos) H.Miller (Hawthorn) D.Stringer (Whyalla) T.Looby N.Krakeour (Power)



SOUTH - OUT - D.Cupido (West) A.Davey (Ess) L.Kruger

In- I . Prendergast (Carlton) C.Norsworthy (Centrals) D.Mckay (Crows)



STURT - OUT - D.Squire A.Beveridge A.Klun S.Graham M.Curtis D.Wicks A.Burton (Ret) L.Jarjoula (Port Magpies) B.Colreavy (WA)

IN- T.Gum (X-North) L.Crane (Zillmere) R.Darling (Snowtown) A.Lee P.Hardy (Power)



WEST - OUT - N.Prokopec M.Illman B.Newberry A.Purchase M.Miller (Ret) B.Haynes A.Bonaddio, R.OSullivan , K.Archibald, J.Oswald (VIC) C.Slattery (Centrals) S.Lewis (Glenelg) C.Schmidt (Brisbane) B.Vennings

IN- B.Dray (O'S) J.Barling D Galea (Williamstown) S.Mccormick (Wodonga)D.Cupido (South) J.Smith (Carlton) M.Hooper (Nth Bullants) J.Rowe (Wagga) M.Barber (Ainslie) L.Buckland (Geelong) P.Walsh R.Gray (Power)K.Tippett (Crows)

[Jimmy]

so ducker, brooks is a definate for Sturt? Also, add Billy Neely to that i reckon unless backwell was pulling our legs

[ando]

Sturt ins: Ty Habner and Joel Fitzgerald from Eyre Peninsula