Page 1 of 1

VFL vs SANFL

PostPosted: Mon Oct 22, 2007 12:44 pm
by Rushby Hinds
Have heard a few whispers that with the ever changing league that is the VFL, with the changes for 2008 some of the clubs have some pretty big cheque books and are offering big bucks enticing ex-VFL types to go home again, more then they are getting from the SANFL.

Obviously makes it harder to recruit new players as well.

Also did hear of another SANFL (ex VFL) player who did not want to go back to his old VFL team as the clubs keep changing so much over there (with the AFL teams sticking their noses in all the time) he didnt know anyone at the club from only a few years ago.

Re: VFL vs SANFL

PostPosted: Mon Oct 22, 2007 1:04 pm
by FlyingHigh
Rushby Hinds wrote:Have heard a few whispers that with the ever changing league that is the VFL, with the changes for 2008 some of the clubs have some pretty big cheque books and are offering big bucks enticing ex-VFL types to go home again, more then they are getting from the SANFL.

Obviously makes it harder to recruit new players as well.



Unfortunately I have always thought that this was only a matter of time, and we'd been farily lucky to keep our comp strong up until now. I certainly hope I'm wrong, but eventually the VFL will get it's act sorted out (obviously AFL don't give a rats'), bit like the A-League finally has.

Re: VFL vs SANFL

PostPosted: Mon Oct 22, 2007 6:26 pm
by BPBRB
The non AFL aligned VFL clubs have an unlimited Salary Cap to sign ex-AFL Victorians or keep present players at the clubs. The only problem is that the VFL clubs don't have the income to support spending huge amounts and they are not likely to improve that either .So that's one area where we will stay ahead with our income levels and if some clubs bit the bullett, the Salary Cap shoud increase here to really nail the interstate recruits to keep our comp as clearly the second best in Oz.

The VFL's biggest competition re player retention is the Vic Country where there is no salary cap restrictions as such (brown paper bags and cash in hand is the way they do it). The VFL and AFL have tried with no success to limit the spend in the Vic Country leagues but have given up as it is way too hard to police plus they are at least grateful the players stay in Vic.

Re: VFL vs SANFL

PostPosted: Mon Oct 22, 2007 8:17 pm
by topsywaldron
BPBRB wrote:(brown paper bags and cash in hand is the way they do it)


Unheard of here of course.

Re: VFL vs SANFL

PostPosted: Mon Oct 22, 2007 8:25 pm
by dash61
BPBRB wrote:The non AFL aligned VFL clubs have an unlimited Salary Cap to sign ex-AFL Victorians or keep present players at the clubs. The only problem is that the VFL clubs don't have the income to support spending huge amounts and they are not likely too improve that either .so that's one area where we will stay ahead with oour income levels and if some clubs bit the bullett, the Salary Cap shoud increase here to really nail the interstate recruits to keep our comp as clearly the second best in Oz.

The VFL's biggest competition re player retention is the Vic Country where there is no salary cap restrictions as such (brown paper bags and cash in hand is the way they do it). The VFL and AFL have tried with no success to limit the spend in the Vic Country leagues but have given up as it is way too hard to police plus they are at least grateful the players stay in Vic.


With the right club and coach i still dont believe their will be a problem keeping or attracting ex AFL & current VFL players :twisted:

Re: VFL vs SANFL

PostPosted: Mon Oct 22, 2007 8:47 pm
by BPBRB
topsywaldron wrote:
BPBRB wrote:(brown paper bags and cash in hand is the way they do it)


Unheard of here of course.


Yep - never heard of it at North!

Re: VFL vs SANFL

PostPosted: Mon Oct 22, 2007 10:25 pm
by Sojourner
Rushby Hinds wrote:Have heard a few whispers that with the ever changing league that is the VFL, with the changes for 2008 some of the clubs have some pretty big cheque books and are offering big bucks enticing ex-VFL types to go home again, more then they are getting from the SANFL.


Coburg didnt seem to do so well in retaining Andy Collins! :?

Re: VFL vs SANFL

PostPosted: Tue Oct 23, 2007 9:36 am
by smac
Sojourner wrote:
Rushby Hinds wrote:Have heard a few whispers that with the ever changing league that is the VFL, with the changes for 2008 some of the clubs have some pretty big cheque books and are offering big bucks enticing ex-VFL types to go home again, more then they are getting from the SANFL.


Coburg didnt seem to do so well in retaining Andy Collins! :?

Spot on, it will take a long time for the Vics to alter the perception of both comps. As long as we continue to improve, they will remain a long way behind us.