Rate A Player

[Jimmy]

Name a player from any team and let the ratings begin...

Ill start...

Andrew Whiteman

and from a rival team

Dale Ellis

edit: you can rate them out of 10 or just a few choice words...

[Wedgie]

Do we rate them out of ten?

If we do I'll give Whiteman 8.5/10, one of my fav non North players, good skills and hard at it, him and Lukey Ivens are like brothers.

Dale Ellis, never seems to do a lot against North, must admit haven't noticed him a whole lot so will leave the jury out on him.

[Macca19]

Whiteman - good solid player. One of the better small defender pushing thru the midfield players in the league.

Ellis - Paid very close attention to him since he was on the Powers rookie list for two years. Reasonable 2003, we picked him up, a good 2004 but failed to develop any further this year and went backwards. His complete lack of finals form makes me rate him even less. Has two or three great games a year.

If I may add another player then id choose Ports Daniel Lees. If not then ignore

[Jimmy]

sure macca

Lees: I am actually mates with him from uni. A good bloke and he gives it his all on the field. Underated player with good skills, good leg and fitness. Doubt he is draft material so could have a good career for the pies.

[Jman]

For courage I rate Clay Sampson
For skill Stephen Kenna he is a gun.

Players from other clubs I rate.
Luke Ivens from North
Jade Sheedy from Sturt
Anyone from Centrals