Page 1 of 2

Pick-a-player

PostPosted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 10:27 pm
by CUTTERMAN
Selecting SANFL listed players only, (no AFL lists), pick a player from a rival club that you would most like to have playing for your club.

Re: Pick-a-player

PostPosted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 10:43 pm
by fester69
Callinan

Re: Pick-a-player

PostPosted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 10:43 pm
by Big Phil
Well...

Who is yours Cutterman ?

From a Cetrals supporters perspective and based on current player shortfalls (due to a few players we lost last year) I would have to say...

Corey Ahchee from Port Magpies...

I've felt that our weakness this year would be a lack of key position players, especially down in defence...

I wouldn't stuff around with Corey playing him up forward, I would have him play full back every week. That way it would free up Yves Sibenaler to take that next tall forward. A close second was Glenelg's Sam Rudolph for very similar reasons but I went with Maggies skipper in Ahchee because of his experience and leadership qualities.

Actually got me thinking if he was to play for Centrals, (never gonna happen) he would only be one of a few to switch between these 2 hated and once, big arch rival clubs. The only player to switch in recent times I can think of is Michael Wakelin. Current 2008 and very very talented reserves player Ash Duncan was zoned to Port and did train with them for a while but they told him he wasn't good enough. I reckon they got it wrong there...

Happy for anyone to inform me of players of previous ers that made the switch either way between Alberton and Elizabeth...

Sorry, got a little off the topic there Cutterman... Good topic raised though mate, well done, it makes for interesting thinking...

Big Phil...

Re: Pick-a-player

PostPosted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 10:45 pm
by Wedgie
Daniel Hargraves

Re: Pick-a-player

PostPosted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 10:46 pm
by Big Phil
fester69 wrote:Callinan


Yeah, great pick there fester69... :wink: :lol:

I'd definatley pick the little Tassie superstar if I was a supporter of another club... !!?? :shock:

:shock: What am I saying, that would never happen... Doggies man for life from the day I was born !!! :wink: 8)

GO U DOGGIES...

Big Phil...

Re: Pick-a-player

PostPosted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 10:47 pm
by bayman
it would really depend on who or what you needed

if you want a full forward = chambers
'' '' '' '' small forward/onballer = callinan
'' '' '' '' ruckman = 3 or 4 ruckman in the comp

etc etc

Re: Pick-a-player

PostPosted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 10:53 pm
by smithy
Josh Cubillo

Re: Pick-a-player

PostPosted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 10:53 pm
by Big Phil
Wedgie wrote:Daniel Hargraves


Is this another in house thing that I've missed there Wedgie... :-k

You're not being sarcastic are you sir, :roll: :wink: :-k

You'd honestly take Hargy back over all of the other talent in the league... ](*,)

Guys like Havelberg, Passador, Warren, Vlatko, Grima, Schell, Chambers just to name a few... :shock:

Are you taking this serious mister !!! :roll: :lol:

Big Phil... :wink:

Re: Pick-a-player

PostPosted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 11:01 pm
by Wedgie
Who's leading the goalkicking table?
(Despite having come up against last year's top 3 sides in the early rounds)

Re: Pick-a-player

PostPosted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 11:06 pm
by Big Phil
Wedgie wrote:Who's leading the goalkicking table?
(Despite having come up against last year's top 3 sides in the early rounds)


Um, Ah, Oh yeah, it's Daniel Hargraves isn't it, I think... !!?? :wink:

Was just having a laugh with ya mate... :lol: :D

But in saying that, if Chambo doesn't win the Ken Farmer by a country mile... 8)

I'd take Chambo everyday of the week over Hargy, sorry Wedgie... :wink:

Big Phil...

Re: Pick-a-player

PostPosted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 11:08 pm
by johntheclaret
Wedgie wrote:Who's leading the goalkicking table?
(Despite having come up against last year's top 3 sides in the early rounds)


And he would be happy to be at Norf

Re: Pick-a-player

PostPosted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 11:09 pm
by Wedgie
Big Phil wrote:
Wedgie wrote:Who's leading the goalkicking table?
(Despite having come up against last year's top 3 sides in the early rounds)


Um, Ah, Oh yeah, it's Daniel Hargraves isn't it, I think... !!?? :wink:

Was just having a laugh with ya mate... :lol: :D

But in saying that, if Chambo doesn't win the Ken Farmer by a country mile... 8)

I'd take Chambo everyday of the week over Hargy, sorry Wedgie... :wink:

Big Phil...


Don't be sorry, Cutterman asked our opinion and I gave a response and backed it up with facts! :wink:

If I couldn't have Hargy then Gum or Cubillo would be next in line. :wink:

Re: Pick-a-player

PostPosted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 11:40 pm
by redden whites
Summerton,Mouse,Treeby

Re: Pick-a-player

PostPosted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 11:53 pm
by rod_rooster
I'm with Wedgie. Hargs for me.

Second option would be any bloke who can ruck and take a mark around the ground. Kicking would also be a bonus. Been a while since North had one of those.

Re: Pick-a-player

PostPosted: Sun Apr 20, 2008 11:54 pm
by Wedgie
rod_rooster wrote:I'm with Wedgie. Hargs for me.

Second option would be any bloke who can ruck and take a mark around the ground. Kicking would also be a bonus. Been a while since North had one of those.


lol, good call.

Perhaps we should coax Mick Redden out of retirement? :wink:

Re: Pick-a-player

PostPosted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 12:33 am
by JK
If the question were asked a few years earlier it would have been a Gowans ... Can I say Roy Laird? :D

Re: Pick-a-player

PostPosted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 12:39 am
by brod
As a Norwood supporter, can I choose one from EACH club, give us a chance at respectability (or at least playing EVERY quarter of a game, not just a couple)

Re: Pick-a-player

PostPosted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 1:55 am
by johntheclaret
I'd go for Josh Cubillo.

or Crane

or Callinan

or De Luca

Re: Pick-a-player

PostPosted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 5:52 am
by Thiele
Backwell

Re: Pick-a-player

PostPosted: Mon Apr 21, 2008 8:12 am
by drebin
Callinan & Crane - that adds class and pace to the midfield and fwd line.

Any ruckman who can take a mark in field play - Deluca, Maric, Feast, Shaw, Parry - hell anyone!!! :roll: :lol: