SA Footy

At this stage my choices are:

Colin Rowston, Richard Williams and Tony Dey.

I vote that whoever gets it, they let the freakin' play go, like we used to see...none of his hack wannabe AFL shite I've seen lately...

True mate.

Unlike the guys who Umpired at House Brothers on Sunday.

sturtpeter wrote:At this stage my choices are:

Colin Rowston, Richard Williams and Tony Dey.

No, no and no...

I would go with Derek Woodcock, Tim Pfieffer and Theron Philp...

Doesn't matter who is officating anyway sturtpeter, IF your side makes the GF, you will be berrating them regardless

sturtpeter wrote:Unlike the guys who Umpired at House Brothers on Sunday.

SP, Williams was one of the officials on Sunday and yet you are now suggesting he officiates the big one, WTF

TigerBoss wrote:I vote that whoever gets it, they let the freakin' play go, like we used to see...none of his hack wannabe AFL shite I've seen lately...

TB, for possibly only the second time ever, I totally agree with you. This year when they have let the play go, we have seen some great action and high scoring affairs. The men in white are at their best when you hardly notice them out there. Start blowing the whistle every 30 seconds and get all ticky touchwood and over technical and the game goes down the gurgler...

Well maybe we should ask Shane Harris his early opinion?

sturtpeter wrote:Well maybe we should ask Shane Harris his early opinion?

Maybe you should put your hand up to Shane to give them some advice prior to the big one

Big Phil wrote:

sturtpeter wrote:At this stage my choices are:

Colin Rowston, Richard Williams and Tony Dey.

No, no and no...

I would go with Derek Woodcock, Tim Pfieffer and Theron Philp...

Doesn't matter who is officating anyway sturtpeter, IF your side makes the GF, you will be berrating them regardless

sturtpeter wrote:Unlike the guys who Umpired at House Brothers on Sunday.

SP, Williams was one of the officials on Sunday and yet you are now suggesting he officiates the big one, WTF

TigerBoss wrote:I vote that whoever gets it, they let the freakin' play go, like we used to see...none of his hack wannabe AFL shite I've seen lately...

TB, for possibly only the second time ever, I totally agree with you. This year when they have let the play go, we have seen some great action and high scoring affairs. The men in white are at their best when you hardly notice them out there. Start blowing the whistle every 30 seconds and get all ticky touchwood and over technical and the game goes down the gurgler...

I'm trembling with excitement that you agree with me BP...it's nice to have my thoughts endorsed by a complete superstar.

My advice.

Let our wonderful game flow.

Inappropriate holding the man, holding the ball not on.

Protect ball players like Sheedy and Crane!

TigerBoss wrote:I'm trembling with excitement that you agree with me BP...it's nice to have my thoughts endorsed by a complete superstar.

You have to be a peanut don't you TB

I'm not the superstar mate, you buddy 1980TM was blowing your trumpet so in my eyes, you are the star around here...

Can I please have your autograph mister

I was having a little chuckle, you can take it how you like

Mine is worth $2.50

sturtpeter wrote:My advice.

Let our wonderful game flow.

Inappropriate holding the man, holding the ball not on.

Protect ball players like Sheedy and Crane!

Some would argue that inappropriate holding the balls would occur naturally when there is inappropriate holding the man...

Big Phil wrote:

TigerBoss wrote:I'm trembling with excitement that you agree with me BP...it's nice to have my thoughts endorsed by a complete superstar.

You have to be a peanut don't you TB

I'm not the superstar mate, you buddy 1980TM was blowing your trumpet so in my eyes, you are the star around here...

Can I please have your autograph mister

I was having a little chuckle, you can take it how you like

It's great having someone else blow my trumpet...must be weird for you having to blow your own all the time...

Big Phil wrote:
SP, Williams was one of the officials on Sunday and yet you are now suggesting he officiates the big one, WTF

Unless there was a late replacement on Sunday, Richard Williams was at Elizabeth Oval Saturday night Big Phil....

True!

Ralston, Carey and Pfeiffer

1980 Tassie Medalist wrote:

Big Phil wrote:
SP, Williams was one of the officials on Sunday and yet you are now suggesting he officiates the big one, WTF

Unless there was a late replacement on Sunday, Richard Williams was at Elizabeth Oval Saturday night Big Phil....

Richard Williams and 2 others. Richard is still so far in front of the others its not funny.

S Hay, R Williams, C Rowston, C Bowen (emg)

Hay and Rowston umpired in the State Game. R Williams is a GF ornament. D Woodcock is the best umpire but will probably miss out - no pre-season

1980 Tassie Medalist wrote:
Unless there was a late replacement on Sunday, Richard Williams was at Elizabeth Oval Saturday night Big Phil....

Bloody hell, I hate it when the media get it wrong

yes, he was, sorry gentleman. I was getting him slightly confused with Tim Pfieffer, my bad

Back to the topic at hand, I think Woodcock, Williams and Pfieffer are the 3 best SANFL umpires and hope it's them on the GF and think Dick will get in with his record alone. Really don't care about who it is to be honest, as long as Rowston isn't there, that's all I ask

sturtpeter wrote:At this stage my choices are:

Colin Rowston, Richard Williams and Tony Dey.

Tony Dey has gotta be the worst ump in the comp by an absolute mile. Seen far too many games ruined by his p!ss weak decisions

You'd have to Put Williams & Hay as the top 2 at this stage