New Import rule

There was an article in the Sunday mail re next years introduction of the import rule. With a bit of a follow up article on the attached thread.
http://www.adelaidenow.com.au/sport/afl ... 5890227940
Personally, I can't see the value of the rule. Clubs no doubt are trying to develop their younger players already. With the introduction of GWS and the GC teams in the AFL, the local league will be further depleted.
According to the benchmark document the number of "imports" has decreased, over the past few years.
Players drafted have to be replaced, and sometimes the younger local talent might not be there.
Quantity of imports doesn't equate to success or an even playing field anyway.
From the benchmark document (as mentioned previously)
One snippet is "Woodville-West Torrens used 11 interstate players in 2009, the lowest of the clubs, followed by Central District and North Adelaide with one more."
Last year 31 players transferred to the SANFL, 19 less than 2007. This year only 20 have been recruited from interstate.
I believe the introduction of the rule will reduce the SANFL standard. It, as the article mentioned may lead to more intra SANFL recruiting.
I'm yet see how the positives outweigh the negatives. We are not merely an AFL feeder comp. I'd like to see the SANFL try to maintain the SANFL at a strong standard not reduce it.
http://www.adelaidenow.com.au/sport/afl ... 5890227940
Personally, I can't see the value of the rule. Clubs no doubt are trying to develop their younger players already. With the introduction of GWS and the GC teams in the AFL, the local league will be further depleted.
According to the benchmark document the number of "imports" has decreased, over the past few years.
Players drafted have to be replaced, and sometimes the younger local talent might not be there.
Quantity of imports doesn't equate to success or an even playing field anyway.
From the benchmark document (as mentioned previously)
One snippet is "Woodville-West Torrens used 11 interstate players in 2009, the lowest of the clubs, followed by Central District and North Adelaide with one more."
Last year 31 players transferred to the SANFL, 19 less than 2007. This year only 20 have been recruited from interstate.
I believe the introduction of the rule will reduce the SANFL standard. It, as the article mentioned may lead to more intra SANFL recruiting.
I'm yet see how the positives outweigh the negatives. We are not merely an AFL feeder comp. I'd like to see the SANFL try to maintain the SANFL at a strong standard not reduce it.