Page 1 of 9

2012 Qualifying Final - West v Central POST GAME DISCUSSIONS

PostPosted: Sun Sep 16, 2012 6:42 pm
by Big Phil
LIVE @ AAMI STADIUM

QUALIFYING FINAL

Final Scores

West - 13.7 = 85

Central - 8.10 = 58

Bloods win by 27 points




GOAL KICKERS:

West - Br. Fisher 4, T.Silverlock, A.Fielke, Be. Fisher, J.Ezard 2, B.MacReadie 1

Central - A.Hayes 2, T.Goodrem, T.Menzel, A.Obst, R.Williams, S.Dutschke, B.Symes 1

Re: 2012 Qualifying Final - West v Central POST GAME DISCUSSIONS

PostPosted: Sun Sep 16, 2012 6:47 pm
by Norwoodman78
Great result West,.... top effort.......
Centrals goodluck thats all i can say...........
GOODLUCK!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Re: 2012 Qualifying Final - West v Central POST GAME DISCUSSIONS

PostPosted: Sun Sep 16, 2012 6:50 pm
by Brodlach
You faaarken beauty.

Well played lads, Andy Collins resting players over the past two weeks helped us run over the dogs in the last quarter.


Kicked a decent score too ;)

Re: 2012 Qualifying Final - West v Central POST GAME DISCUSSIONS

PostPosted: Sun Sep 16, 2012 6:53 pm
by SimonH
So ends what must be the longest ever minor-final winning streak not just in SANFL, but probably in all top tier Aussie rules competitions. When did Centrals last lose a minor final?

Re: 2012 Qualifying Final - West v Central POST GAME DISCUSSIONS

PostPosted: Sun Sep 16, 2012 6:57 pm
by Norwoodman78
I dont look at history!!!
who cares...... a stuff about history!!!
West won today!!!

Re: 2012 Qualifying Final - West v Central POST GAME DISCUSSIONS

PostPosted: Sun Sep 16, 2012 7:02 pm
by saintal
Only caught the final term, but well done to the Bloods.

Re: 2012 Qualifying Final - West v Central POST GAME DISCUSSIONS

PostPosted: Sun Sep 16, 2012 7:02 pm
by JK
Well done Westies, that was pretty impressive .. Brad Fisher worth every penny, really delivered when most needed.

Best of luck to young Menzel, hope his knee isn't as bad as feared.

Re: 2012 Qualifying Final - West v Central POST GAME DISCUSSIONS

PostPosted: Sun Sep 16, 2012 7:06 pm
by sjt
Congrats to west.

What a crap game, (it was crap even when we were leading).
Why didn't someone run past Menzel when he couldn't kick? We had to win, take the loose man out of defence. West would have killed us with marks inside fifty ( I assume), even with our loose defender. Should have played up the ground. Out tall forwards were killed in the packs, at least we could have had some crummers.
I thought we would have learnt from the Elizabeth game, earlier.

Re: 2012 Qualifying Final - West v Central POST GAME DISCUSSIONS

PostPosted: Sun Sep 16, 2012 7:06 pm
by scott
Ferguson was a general down back. Good stuff Westies

Re: 2012 Qualifying Final - West v Central POST GAME DISCUSSIONS

PostPosted: Sun Sep 16, 2012 7:09 pm
by Brodlach
Ferg didn't do much early but really stood up in the second half. Hartlett, Schmidt and Caire were fantastic all day


Agree JK, hope Menzel isnt too bad

Re: 2012 Qualifying Final - West v Central POST GAME DISCUSSIONS

PostPosted: Sun Sep 16, 2012 7:11 pm
by NO-MERCY
Great effort Westies today, Collins masterminded this perfect result.
After making 10 changes coming into a final i thought :shock: WTF is this bloke doing, but Collins must be given alot of credit for how he prepared his team for this final, now for the 2nd semi v Norwood.
End of the Centrals era?
I hope so, go Westies, i think West can play alot better than they did today, how many times did West hang onto the ball too long & turn the bloody thing over? Maybe it was their 1st finals appearance for a while contributed to that, if they can clean up their disposal they'll go a long way in this finals series & they are capable of winning the flag but Collins wouldn't let his side get too far ahead of themselves & he'll be keeping a lid on things & take 1 week at a time.

Re: 2012 Qualifying Final - West v Central POST GAME DISCUSSIONS

PostPosted: Sun Sep 16, 2012 7:17 pm
by locky801
Well done Westies, best side on the park in that game but hell, do the Gowans ever shut up whinging to the umps :roll:

Re: 2012 Qualifying Final - West v Central POST GAME DISCUSSIONS

PostPosted: Sun Sep 16, 2012 7:17 pm
by Brodlach
NO-MERCY wrote:Great effort Westies today, Collins masterminded this perfect result.
After making 10 changes coming into a final i thought :shock: WTF is this bloke doing, but Collins must be given alot of credit for how he prepared his team for this final, now for the 2nd semi v Norwood.
End of the Centrals era?
I hope so, go Westies, i think West can play alot better than they did today, how many times did West hang onto the ball too long & turn the bloody thing over? Maybe it was their 1st finals appearance for a while contributed to that, if they can clean up their disposal they'll go a long way in this finals series & they are capable of winning the flag but Collins wouldn't let his side get too far ahead of themselves & he'll be keeping a lid on things & take 1 week at a time.


:shock: :shock:

Great post No Mercy, just about the first bit of credit Collins has received by a non bloods supporter all year.

Re: 2012 Qualifying Final - West v Central POST GAME DISCUSSIONS

PostPosted: Sun Sep 16, 2012 7:50 pm
by SDK
Congrats West thought you were gone 20 mins into the 3rd quarter but the last 2 goals through sheer guts and will set up the game.
Westies quality talls are a real worry for opposition and Ferguson ( 25 ) showed he is the danger player at Richmond.
Young Crouch did not do a lot early but showed his class. He is a Crows star in the waiting, like his cool head.
Made my guts turn to see young Menzel go down like that. Hope it is not as bad as it looks.

Don't write Centrals off just yet though !!!!!!! Bit sad to see some of the cheap Gowans shots late in the game but I guess they are not used to losing.
Tribunal will have some tough decisions.

Enjoyed both games today in front of the TV. Refering to another post I think other than the GF these finals should be played at the higher ranked team's home ground. How good a crowd would we have seen at Prospect today and how much $ would the club have made ? Ditto for Dogs and Wolves.... or is it Bloods ?

Re: 2012 Qualifying Final - West v Central POST GAME DISCUSSIONS

PostPosted: Sun Sep 16, 2012 7:53 pm
by doggies4eva
congratulations to West. we were outplayed and outcoached.

Well deserved victory.

End of an era? I hope not. We still have next week to continue the tradition.

Re: 2012 Qualifying Final - West v Central POST GAME DISCUSSIONS

PostPosted: Sun Sep 16, 2012 7:56 pm
by Macca19
So that would be the first final Centrals has lost since it started its run (outside of GFs)? Amazing.

Well done to West. They've got a side full of talent and structurally work very well too.

Re: 2012 Qualifying Final - West v Central POST GAME DISCUSSIONS

PostPosted: Sun Sep 16, 2012 7:57 pm
by The Sleeping Giant
Brodlach wrote:
NO-MERCY wrote:Great effort Westies today, Collins masterminded this perfect result.
After making 10 changes coming into a final i thought :shock: WTF is this bloke doing, but Collins must be given alot of credit for how he prepared his team for this final, now for the 2nd semi v Norwood.
End of the Centrals era?
I hope so, go Westies, i think West can play alot better than they did today, how many times did West hang onto the ball too long & turn the bloody thing over? Maybe it was their 1st finals appearance for a while contributed to that, if they can clean up their disposal they'll go a long way in this finals series & they are capable of winning the flag but Collins wouldn't let his side get too far ahead of themselves & he'll be keeping a lid on things & take 1 week at a time.


:shock: :shock:

Great post No Mercy, just about the first bit of credit Collins has received by a non bloods supporter all year.

Should he?

Re: 2012 Qualifying Final - West v Central POST GAME DISCUSSIONS

PostPosted: Sun Sep 16, 2012 8:02 pm
by cennals05
Well done West. We had too many players selected on reputation today and not form. It kills me to also say we were out coached.

I would also like to say it was a piss poor turn out by Centrals supporters today.

2012 Qualifying Final - West v Central POST GAME DISCUSSIONS

PostPosted: Sun Sep 16, 2012 8:04 pm
by Jase
IMHO, that was poo... :(

Well done Westies, stuck to your game plan perfectly...

Norwood v West could be (ahem) interesting ...

Re: 2012 Qualifying Final - West v Central POST GAME DISCUSSIONS

PostPosted: Sun Sep 16, 2012 8:09 pm
by smac
SimonH wrote:So ends what must be the longest ever minor-final winning streak not just in SANFL, but probably in all top tier Aussie rules competitions. When did Centrals last lose a minor final?

Talked about this on the way home. I think, 1998. I was 24,not 38 and my son who was working today was only 3 months old. Good run.

Terrible effort, but probably as good as West allowed. Missed chances early that may have lifted us to different things, while West capitalised on chances much better.

No sleep in next week.