SA Footy

Steven Sims v Bruce Lindsay

another grub wrote:

The Jack wrote:Seems pretty cut and dried to me. Eagles through is the only solution. Scored 8 points with a man extra, take those points away. Simples. If it was a horse race... Margin on the line insufficient to cover interference caused to the 2nd placed horse at the top of the straight, protest upheld. Amended placings are...

Thats the logical thing to do but it gets messy with that stupid rule they still have.

Why is it logical? If you are to remove the score then you should remove the time on for that period and the goal to the Eagles in the last 15 seconds. North may have played the game differently in the last 5 minutes if they had one less goal etc., all hypothetical scenarios, don't think it is cut and dried..

First 4-5 minutes of the last quarter should be disqualified, and all scores within that period disqualified too. North scored 1.2 within that time frame, so in all fairness, WWT should be the victors by 3 points ? Just my opinion

WWF

Grenville v J Redden ?

David Robertson Vs Robbie Muir

JK wrote:

another grub wrote:Any other ideas how we could decide a winner?.......

Free Kick shoot out?

Which team got the most magarey votes?

Highest finishing position at end of minor round?

Let the 4,000 ravens fans have a vote?

Grog Squad v the Eagles supporters on who sings the club song better/ louder?

Soggy Sao

Spargo wrote:

JK wrote:

another grub wrote:Any other ideas how we could decide a winner?.......

Free Kick shoot out?

Which team got the most magarey votes?

Highest finishing position at end of minor round?

Let the 4,000 ravens fans have a vote?

Grog Squad v the Eagles supporters on who sings the club song better/ louder?

Soggy Sao

Definitely don't want the extra man there.

another grub wrote:WWF

Grenville v J Redden ?

100m sprint?
probably be just as drawn out!

when will a decision be handed down?

I would suggest a skolling contest between celebrities from each club, but I fear that Grenville Dietrich would confer an insurmountable advantage to the Roosters.

Let's see if I've got this straight. The Roosters caused this cock-up by having
too many players on the ground, but if all this goes to court, they'll be
unfairly outnumbered by legal Eagles. Most perplexing indeed.

Perhaps the winner should be decided by tossing a coin.
Who is the biggest tosser at the SANFL ?

Luv,
Sabre.

another grub wrote:Any other ideas how we could decide a winner?.......

Free Kick shoot out?

Which team got the most magarey votes?

Highest finishing position at end of minor round?

Let the 4,000 ravens fans have a vote?

Grog Squad v the Eagles supporters on who sings the club song better/ louder?

Carr and a Hybrids hardman to go 10 rounds in Ramsgate carpark. If they cant find one, call the Crows to get the Weids number.

Maybe a braveheart scenario ..........Grog Sqaud at one end of the oval, Eagles suppporters at the other end..... YOU CAN TAKE MY LIFE BUT YOU CANT TAKE MY GRAND FINAL......CCCCHHHHHAAAARRRRRRRGGGGEEEEEEE

Can just see Wedgie at the front of the sqaud waving the flag to attack!........

another grub wrote:Maybe a braveheart scenario ..........Grog Sqaud at one end of the oval, Eagles suppporters at the other end..... YOU CAN TAKE MY LIFE BUT YOU CANT TAKE MY GRAND FINAL......CCCCHHHHHAAAARRRRRRRGGGGEEEEEEE

Can just see Wedgie at the front of the sqaud waving the flag to attack!........

Not waving the flag...

Pseudo wrote:I would suggest a skolling contest between celebrities from each club, but I fear that Grenville Dietrich would confer an insurmountable advantage to the Roosters.

The big fella played at Torrens too, so he could represent both sides!

SANFL informed Eagles to train tonight!

They are genuinely looking at 2 options, fine and North Win, 8 points deducted Eagles win.

another grub wrote:Maybe a braveheart scenario ..........Grog Sqaud at one end of the oval, Eagles suppporters at the other end..... YOU CAN TAKE MY LIFE BUT YOU CANT TAKE MY GRAND FINAL......CCCCHHHHHAAAARRRRRRRGGGGEEEEEEE

Can just see Wedgie at the front of the sqaud waving the flag to attack!........

I think wedgie admitted he had his flag out a couple of times on Sunday.

and his wand

Ch 10 reporting its being transfered to a tribunal hearing???

whufc wrote:SANFL informed Eagles to train tonight!

They are genuinely looking at 2 options, fine and North Win, 8 points deducted Eagles win.

It would be a farce if they give it to the Eagles, leave the result as is as nobody acted on it or at worst replay the game.