Page 1 of 3

2023 First Semi Final, Sturt v Central District

PostPosted: Mon Sep 04, 2023 12:58 pm
by Spargo
Sunday 10th September, Adelaide Oval - 12:15pm

Re: 2023 First Semi Final, Sturt v Central District

PostPosted: Mon Sep 04, 2023 3:48 pm
by PatowalongaPirate
Sturt’s Will Coomblas has been offered a one-match ban with an early guilty plea for tripping Adelaide’s Jay Boyle in the Qualifying Final at Adelaide Oval on Sunday.

Will Coomblas (Sturt) – Tripping

Conduct: Intentional

Contact: Body

Impact: Low

Base Sanction: 2 matches

Early Guilty Plea: 1 match

* Where a Person has been found or pleaded guilty to two low-level Classifiable Offences within a 12 month period (those Classifiable Offences with a base sanction of 1 match as per Table 2), any third or subsequent low-level Classifiable Offence (with a base sanction of 1 match as per Table 2) within the same 12 month period (as at the date of the offence) will result in a base sanction of 2 matches, with the player able to accept 1 match with an Early Guilty Plea. 

Will Coomblas pled guilty to three low-level, classifiable offences within a 12-month period. These offences occurred on the 1st of April, 27th of May and 4th of June 2023.

Re: 2023 First Semi Final, Sturt v Central District

PostPosted: Mon Sep 04, 2023 4:14 pm
by northerner
So possibly three forced changes to Sturt, with Coomblas, Page and Doyle looking unlikely.
Richards would be a definite inclusion after a strong performance in the ressies on Friday night. Wilson worked hard, but didnt seem anywhere near fit enough to guarantee a call-up.
Dogs only inclusion could be East who missed with a hammie.

Re: 2023 First Semi Final, Sturt v Central District

PostPosted: Mon Sep 04, 2023 7:07 pm
by Hazydog
Wilson listed as out for the season in todays injury update..

Re: 2023 First Semi Final, Sturt v Central District

PostPosted: Mon Sep 04, 2023 9:52 pm
by pmackk
Hasn’t played for weeks not surprising few injuries but have good depth to cover them. Expecting us to bounce back Dogs playing well though so won’t be a easy game.

Re: 2023 First Semi Final, Sturt v Central District

PostPosted: Mon Sep 04, 2023 10:37 pm
by rd
The Band-Aid I've had on my wounds from the 1971 1st Semi Final has been ripped off and I'm reliving the pain all over again. All I need is for Robin Mulholland to run onto the oval wearing a CD guernsey again...

Re: 2023 First Semi Final, Sturt v Central District

PostPosted: Tue Sep 05, 2023 10:14 am
by another grub
Amos out for season? Who does majority of ruck now?

Re: 2023 First Semi Final, Sturt v Central District

PostPosted: Tue Sep 05, 2023 11:30 am
by stampy
rd wrote:The Band-Aid I've had on my wounds from the 1971 1st Semi Final has been ripped off and I'm reliving the pain all over again. All I need is for Robin Mulholland to run onto the oval wearing a CD guernsey again...


great little player the no.23

Re: 2023 First Semi Final, Sturt v Central District

PostPosted: Tue Sep 05, 2023 1:58 pm
by gazzamagoo
rd wrote:The Band-Aid I've had on my wounds from the 1971 1st Semi Final has been ripped off and I'm reliving the pain all over again. All I need is for Robin Mulholland to run onto the oval wearing a CD guernsey again...


He'll be out there, disguised as Aiden Grace :D

Re: 2023 First Semi Final, Sturt v Central District

PostPosted: Tue Sep 05, 2023 2:38 pm
by rd
gazzamagoo wrote:
rd wrote:The Band-Aid I've had on my wounds from the 1971 1st Semi Final has been ripped off and I'm reliving the pain all over again. All I need is for Robin Mulholland to run onto the oval wearing a CD guernsey again...


He'll be out there, disguised as Aiden Grace :D


I don't think Aiden Grace will kick 5 goals in the last quarter as Mulholland did back in 1971 - but then CD had never beaten Sturt prior to that 71 1st Semi...so anything can happen...

Re: 2023 First Semi Final, Sturt v Central District

PostPosted: Tue Sep 05, 2023 3:26 pm
by robranisgod
rd wrote:
gazzamagoo wrote:
rd wrote:The Band-Aid I've had on my wounds from the 1971 1st Semi Final has been ripped off and I'm reliving the pain all over again. All I need is for Robin Mulholland to run onto the oval wearing a CD guernsey again...


He'll be out there, disguised as Aiden Grace :D


I don't think Aiden Grace will kick 5 goals in the last quarter as Mulholland did back in 1971 - but then CD had never beaten Sturt prior to that 71 1st Semi...so anything can happen...


And just to refresh your memory, here is the link to last quarter of that famous 1971 game.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZUOt6r-x6ZI

Everyone of the Sturt 18 were either a premiership player or were to become one.

Re: 2023 First Semi Final, Sturt v Central District

PostPosted: Tue Sep 05, 2023 7:19 pm
by Aerie
I'm putting it down to the feelings I gained from the last two Grand Finals we played against them, but I'm finding myself hoping the Dogs go all the way this September. Both games were good to watch last weekend. Often the higher ranked team bounces back from a loss, so Sturt would go in favourites but Central might have found their mojo under Bulldogs legend Paul Thomas and if they have, they'll take some beating.

Re: 2023 First Semi Final, Sturt v Central District

PostPosted: Wed Sep 06, 2023 12:23 am
by Big Phil
Hazydog wrote:Wilson listed as out for the season in todays injury update..

Concerns of a partial ACL tear.

Re: 2023 First Semi Final, Sturt v Central District

PostPosted: Wed Sep 06, 2023 10:08 am
by another grub
How old is PW?

Re: 2023 First Semi Final, Sturt v Central District

PostPosted: Wed Sep 06, 2023 2:13 pm
by am Bays
Centrals are much improved in the 2nd half of the season however this weekends result is purely dependant on which Sturt team rocks up this Sunday.

Sturt at their best are better clearance wise, number of effective disposals and tackle wise compared to Centrals. Hence why over a season their win loss and scores for records are better than Centrals. (no diff in scores against)

Sturt come to play they win this easy. However if Sturt go all timid like they did in the last half, last Sunday . Dogs will get the chocolates as they are peaking but their current peak isn’t as good as Sturts best.

Plus Sturt won’t be resting a bloke at half time for next week.

Re: 2023 First Semi Final, Sturt v Central District

PostPosted: Wed Sep 06, 2023 7:51 pm
by DOC
another grub wrote:How old is PW?



29 in December.

Re: 2023 First Semi Final, Sturt v Central District

PostPosted: Wed Sep 06, 2023 9:14 pm
by Big Phil
am Bays wrote:Centrals are much improved in the 2nd half of the season however this weekends result is purely dependant on which Sturt team rocks up this Sunday.

Sturt at their best are better clearance wise, number of effective disposals and tackle wise compared to Centrals. Hence why over a season their win loss and scores for records are better than Centrals. (no diff in scores against)

Sturt come to play they win this easy. However if Sturt go all timid like they did in the last half, last Sunday . Dogs will get the chocolates as they are peaking but their current peak isn’t as good as Sturts best.

Plus Sturt won’t be resting a bloke at half time for next week.


They lose their number 1 ruckman and best defender, as well as an experienced veteran.

This will struggle to reach their peak with the aforementioned outs.

Double Blues have won 16 of the last 17 clashes against Dogs.

Reckon the red, white and blue are due to salute.

Re: 2023 First Semi Final, Sturt v Central District

PostPosted: Wed Sep 06, 2023 11:37 pm
by TDJ44
am Bays wrote:Centrals are much improved in the 2nd half of the season however this weekends result is purely dependant on which Sturt team rocks up this Sunday.

Sturt at their best are better clearance wise, number of effective disposals and tackle wise compared to Centrals. Hence why over a season their win loss and scores for records are better than Centrals. (no diff in scores against)

Sturt come to play they win this easy. However if Sturt go all timid like they did in the last half, last Sunday . Dogs will get the chocolates as they are peaking but their current peak isn’t as good as Sturts best.

Plus Sturt won’t be resting a bloke at half time for next week.

Lycett was not rested at half time.
He kicked a goal on the 3 qtr time siren.
He did appear to hurt himself during a centre bounce contest also in the 3rd qtr.

Re: 2023 First Semi Final, Sturt v Central District

PostPosted: Thu Sep 07, 2023 10:06 am
by gazzamagoo
Can someone please remind me what the wager was at the start of the season & with whom,
something about buying membership tickets if Central finished somewhere on the ladder?
Thanks

Re: 2023 First Semi Final, Sturt v Central District

PostPosted: Thu Sep 07, 2023 10:20 am
by Spargo
gazzamagoo wrote:Can someone please remind me what the wager was at the start of the season & with whom,
something about buying membership tickets if Central finished somewhere on the ladder?
Thanks

I had a bet with bulldogproud - Glenelg to finish 3 or more positions on the ladder higher than Centrals, loser to buy a 2024 membership to the winner’s club. If Centrals beat Sturt, I’m buying a CDFC membership next year. If CD lose, Glenelg still have to win the flag for me to win the bet.