SA Footy

Posted: **Wed Feb 28, 2007 5:35 pm**

IN MY OPINION IT WAS JAMES BYRNE, YES HE COULD PLAY BUT HE WAS SELFISH & NEVER LOOKED WHEN KICKING & JUST BLAZED AWAY & WAS SOMEWHAT ABUSIVE TO TEAM MATES

Posted: **Wed Feb 28, 2007 5:52 pm**

Played a bunch of Crows games too

Posted: **Wed Feb 28, 2007 8:16 pm**

Jay Viney

Posted: **Wed Feb 28, 2007 8:18 pm**

Wedgie wrote:Jay Viney

That's a bit harsh. I thought he was OK.

Posted: **Wed Feb 28, 2007 8:24 pm**

rod_rooster wrote:
Wedgie wrote:Jay Viney

That's a bit harsh. I thought he was OK.

I didn't say he wasn't OK (not that I'd argue too strenously with someone who said he wasnt). Why is it harsh when Im just saying the other captains we've had have all been better?

Who do you think was worse a captain than Jay Viney?

Unless you have a lower opinion than myself about North's captains then surely someone who you though was just OK would be bottom of the barrell too?

Posted: **Wed Feb 28, 2007 8:29 pm**

Wedgie wrote:
rod_rooster wrote:
Wedgie wrote:Jay Viney

That's a bit harsh. I thought he was OK.

I didn't say he wasn't OK (not that I'd argue too strenously with someone who said he wasnt). Why is it harsh when Im just saying the other captains we've had have all been better?

Who do you think was worse a captain than Jay Viney?

Unless you have a lower opinion than myself about North's captains then surely someone who you though was just OK would be bottom of the barrell too?

Good point.

Posted: **Wed Feb 28, 2007 8:50 pm**

All Port Adelaide captains are champions

We only accept the best!

Posted: **Wed Feb 28, 2007 8:58 pm**

The Norwood captains since I've been following the Redlegs are:
Kneebone, Bunton, Oatey, Hammond, Wynne, Taylor, Gallagher, Turbill, Jenkins, Roberts, Aish, McIntosh, Harvey, James.

Sorry, no lemons

Posted: **Wed Feb 28, 2007 9:05 pm**

bayman wrote:IN MY OPINION IT WAS JAMES BYRNE, YES HE COULD PLAY BUT HE WAS SELFISH & NEVER LOOKED WHEN KICKING & JUST BLAZED AWAY & WAS SOMEWHAT ABUSIVE TO TEAM MATES

Arguably the worst captain in SANFL history....christ those dark days of the Honor years aren't very honourable for us.... :Hangman:

Posted: **Wed Feb 28, 2007 9:25 pm**

Adelaide Hawk wrote:The Norwood captains since I've been following the Redlegs are:
Kneebone, Bunton, Oatey, Hammond, Wynne, Taylor, Gallagher, Turbill, Jenkins, Roberts, Aish, McIntosh, Harvey, James.

Sorry, no lemons

Show off.

Posted: **Wed Feb 28, 2007 10:00 pm**

The three Eagles captains since 1991:

Peter Schwarz
Andrew Rogers
Gavin Colville

I can't pick a "worst" there.

Posted: **Wed Feb 28, 2007 11:06 pm**

Adelaide Hawk wrote:The Norwood captains since I've been following the Redlegs are:
Kneebone, Bunton, Oatey, Hammond, Wynne, Taylor, Gallagher, Turbill, Jenkins, Roberts, Aish, McIntosh, Harvey, James.

Sorry, no lemons :)

Geez, u must be older than Mal to remember back that far....LOL

Posted: **Wed Feb 28, 2007 11:42 pm**

Adelaide Hawk wrote:The Norwood captains since I've been following the Redlegs are:
Kneebone, Bunton, Oatey, Hammond, Wynne, Taylor, Gallagher, Turbill, Jenkins, Roberts, Aish, McIntosh, Harvey, James.

Sorry, no lemons

Isn't Gags Norwoods captain this year? Theres your answer. Dud player, cant see his captaincy being any better. Anyone who shies away from a contest shouldn't be captain

Posted: **Thu Mar 01, 2007 5:59 am**

pafc1870 wrote:
Adelaide Hawk wrote:The Norwood captains since I've been following the Redlegs are:
Kneebone, Bunton, Oatey, Hammond, Wynne, Taylor, Gallagher, Turbill, Jenkins, Roberts, Aish, McIntosh, Harvey, James.

Sorry, no lemons

Isn't Gags Norwoods captain this year? Theres your answer. Dud player, cant see his captaincy being any better. Anyone who shies away from a contest shouldn't be captain

I hadn't heard the Norwood captaincy decision, but although Gags was V/Captain last season I was expecting Scott Borlace to be captain. Besides, this year's captain hasn't played a game as captain yet, so they can't be included in this discussion.

Posted: **Thu Mar 01, 2007 8:02 am**

I can't think of a bad Centrals captain.

Maybe....Steven Trigg?

Posted: **Thu Mar 01, 2007 8:07 am**

People are getting bad mixed up with worst.
Its like saying who's the worst out of Russell Ebert and Barrie Robran?
Most would agree Robran is the best and that Russell is the worst.
Certainly doesn't make Russell a bad player.

Posted: **Thu Mar 01, 2007 9:06 am**

spell_check wrote:The three Eagles captains since 1991:

Peter Schwarz
Andrew Rogers
Gavin Colville

I can't pick a "worst" there.

Neither can I.

Posted: **Thu Mar 01, 2007 9:09 am**

Clayton Lamb for Westies...correct me if i'm wrong but i think he was named captain for a coming season then Glenelg poached him...like thieves in the night.

Posted: **Thu Mar 01, 2007 1:47 pm**

Adelaide Hawk wrote:The Norwood captains since I've been following the Redlegs are:
Kneebone, Bunton, Oatey, Hammond, Wynne, Taylor, Gallagher, Turbill, Jenkins, Roberts, Aish, McIntosh, Harvey, James.

Sorry, no lemons

Great post. I was thinking the same thing, now if it was Geelong we would have plenty.

regards,

REB

Posted: **Thu Mar 01, 2007 4:43 pm**

Since WWII...

Bob Quinn (1945-1947)
Lew Roberts (1948)
Reg Schumann (1949)
Fos Williams (1950-1958)
Geof Motley (1959-1966)
John Cahill (1967-1973)
Russell Ebert (1974-1978, 1983-1985)
Brian Cunningham (1979-1982)
Russell Johnston (1986-1990)
Greg Phillips (1991-1993)
Tim Ginever (1994-1997)
Darryl Borlase (1998)
David Brown (1999-2000)
Darryl Poole (2001-2003)
Tony Brown (2004-2005)
Mark Clayton (2006)

Best captain is a no-brainer.

But the worst? Hmmm...

Lew Roberts was captain/coach in our worst season.

But he was an absolute gun...

SA Footy

WHO IS YOUR SIDES WORST EVER CAPTAIN ?

WHO IS YOUR SIDES WORST EVER CAPTAIN ?

Re: WHO IS YOUR SIDES WORST EVER CAPTAIN ?