Top 10 Most Hated Players ???

[LPH]

Inline with the alternative thread, how about 'The Most Hated' ?

For what it's worth, here's mine:

1. David Granger ( Port Adelaide )
2. Alan Stringer ( Glenelg )
3. Dermott Brereton ( Victoria State of Origin )
4. Graham Cornes ( Glenelg )
5. Tim Evans ( Port Adelaide )
6. Dwayne Russell ( Port Adelaide )
7. Mark Williams ( Port Adelaide )
8. Rick Davies ( Sturt )
9. Darren Smith ( Port Adelaide )
10. Scott Hodges ( Port Adelaide )

Hmm... me thinks there's a pattern here !!!???!!!!

[schimma]

hate is a strong word but i would give it a go and yes i am a Eagles supporter.

1. GARY HAYLOCK
2. Dean Howard
3. Clive Waterhouse
4. Mark Soderstrem
5. Allan Bartlett
6. Roger Daleny
7. Ron Fuller
8. Mark Tylor
9. Troy Clements
10. Gowans (but also good to watch)

[JamesH]

1) Wayne Mahney
2) Marco Bello
3) Brian Leys
4) Steven Simms
5) John Fidge
6) Darren Smith
7) Damien Squire
Sam McArdle
9) Bruce Lennon
10) Alf Steed

I think all but 1 are premiership players

[am Bays]

Pfft by the looks of the names on these lists it is not most hated it is:

"most wish they we're playing for my team players" or

"no worse than the thugs/hacks on my team but I've got rose coloured glasses so I wont admit it players"

[rod_rooster]

Pfft by the looks of the names on these lists it is not most hated it is:

"most wish they we're playing for my team players" or

"no worse than the thugs/hacks on my team but I've got rose coloured glasses so I wont admit it players"

Where does Mark Soderstrom fit in then

[Cambridge Clarrie]

I think on many occaisions we hate a player because of the way they can rip our side apart. Most of the players on these lists were no angels though either...

[am Bays]

Pfft by the looks of the names on these lists it is not most hated it is:

"most wish they we're playing for my team players" or

"no worse than the thugs/hacks on my team but I've got rose coloured glasses so I wont admit it players"

Where does Mark Soderstrom fit in then

Umm Ahh Umm *shrugs* damn got me on a technicality....

[woodwt]

J. Gowans
C. Gowans
E. Ware
D. Schell
S. Salisbury
J. Clayton
T. Clements
B. Chambers
S. Carslake
S. Sims

I havent listed any gayfl players because thers not point!

[Psyber]

Grainger was the only one on any list so far, who bothered me much, and it wasn't because of his football talent.

[Dogwatcher]

Marco Bello and Sam Mcardle?

[Blue Boy]

Numbers 1 to 10 will all be filled with the name J.Clayton !!!

[smac]

Marco Bello and Sam Mcardle?

I could understand an opponent not liking Bello, he regularly tore sides apart. But Mcardle is a surprise...

[Dogwatcher]

Maybe they just didn't like Sam's hair???

[Wedgie]

In no particular order except for no 1:

Atkinson
Salisbury
A.Stringer
G.Cornes
S.Curtis
M.Aish
N.Roberts
T.Evans
S.Feast (in the past, over it now, he seems to have mellowed)
P.Carey

[redden whites]

McIntosh
Duncan Fosdike
Bomber Clifford
Robin Kidney
Alan Stringer
Atkinson
Chris McDermott
Andrew Payze
Skipworth
Fleming(South via Richmond a few years ago)

[Wedgie]

Robin Kidney's a good one, I went to the same school as him and he was a right royal twit.
His brother Adrian (who I think played some games for West but made his name as a weightlifter) was a top bloke though.

[Dogwatcher]

Robin Kidney played league at a fairly young age. Adrian (his twin?) played a lot of ressies at the Bays too I reckon. I remember watching them both run around in the Magoos when they used to show it on the tv.

I don't remember Adrian playing at Westies, unless it was only ressies.

However, I can't verify your claim that Robin was a twit Wedgie

[Wedgie]

Robin Kidney played league at a fairly young age. Adrian (his twin?) played a lot of ressies at the Bays too I reckon. I remember watching them both run around in the Magoos when they used to show it on the tv.

I don't remember Adrian playing at Westies, unless it was only ressies.

However, I can't verify your claim that Robin was a twit Wedgie

Yeah Robin's first game was at 16, I remember a big article on the back page of the News as he had his trumpet in the photo. I played in the same school band as him but played a real man's instrument like a Tuba!
I think Adrian only did play ressies for West.

[Dogwatcher]

You may have played the tuba Wedgie, but you've never been afraid to blow your own trumpet.

[southee]

What School was it Wedgie??
I went to Brighton High. Some great Football players from there!!
Under 17 for the Bays was as far as I got......
The discovery of beer and women put my SANFL dreams to rest!!!