Page 1 of 2
Hypothetical 2007 SANFL State Team
Posted:
Wed Jul 18, 2007 9:46 pmby Aerie
If there was to be a State game in a couple of weeks, who would be playing, purely based on form this year and not on past reputations. AFL listed players NOT to be included.
Perhaps it would be easier to nominate some players from your club who you think would be worthy of consideration and we can create a short list and go from there. Someone like bayman who has seen a lot of games could be a good judge for competing spots.
In order, I'd nominate the following from the Eagles:
Lindsay - ruck
Powell - on ball/back flank
Grocke - CHF
Treeby - wing
Symmons - forward flank
Jarrad - wing
Not to be considered because of long term injury would be McKenzie, but he had a great start to the year for the first 10 rounds or so.
Re: Hypothetical 2007 SANFL State Team
Posted:
Thu Jul 19, 2007 1:48 amby Sam_goUUUdogs
Centrals + Chambers (maybe)
Re: Hypothetical 2007 SANFL State Team
Posted:
Thu Jul 19, 2007 1:48 pmby Shameless
Port Magpies
Ahchee - Full Back
Mieklejohn - Ruck
Jeremy Clayton - Rover
Re: Hypothetical 2007 SANFL State Team
Posted:
Thu Jul 19, 2007 1:49 pmby Shameless
Port Magpies
Ahchee - Full Back
Mieklejohn - Ruck
Jeremy Clayton - Rover
Re: Hypothetical 2007 SANFL State Team
Posted:
Thu Jul 19, 2007 2:10 pmby Bluedemon
from Sturt you would look at Chambers, Feast (leading ruckman), Sheedy, Bratton, Nelson, MacGowan (Coach)
Re: Hypothetical 2007 SANFL State Team
Posted:
Thu Jul 19, 2007 2:30 pmby HeartBeatsTrue
Norwood:
certainty:
Kieran McGuiness (back pocket/back flank)
at a stretch:
James Gallagher (wing)
Jamie Vlatko (forward pocket)
Re: Hypothetical 2007 SANFL State Team
Posted:
Thu Jul 19, 2007 5:03 pmby Aerie
Please let me know if I've put any of them in the wrong positions. Nominations so far...
Tall Forwards (TF): Vlatko (Nw), Chambers (St), Grocke (WWT)
Forward Pockets/Flanks (SF): Symmons (WWT)
Tall Backs (TB): AhChee (PM)
Back Flankers/Pockets (SB): McGuiness (Nw), Nelson (St)
Rucks (R): Feast (St), Mieklejohn (PM), Lindsay (WWT)
On Ballers (OB): Sheedy (St), Bratton (St), J Clayton (PM), Powell (WWT)
Wings (W): Gallagher (Nw), Treeby (WWT), Jarrad (WWT)
Coaches: Macgowan (St)
The team may end up something like:
FF: TF TF OB
HF: SF TF SF
C: W OB W
HB: SB TB SB
FB: TB TB OB
R: R OB OB
I: R OB OB
Re: Hypothetical 2007 SANFL State Team
Posted:
Thu Jul 19, 2007 5:50 pmby G
From NORTH possibly Alleway, Allan and Younie.
Re: Hypothetical 2007 SANFL State Team
Posted:
Thu Jul 19, 2007 5:55 pmby LBT
McConnell and Rudolph from Glenelg
Re: Hypothetical 2007 SANFL State Team
Posted:
Thu Jul 19, 2007 6:07 pmby LBJ8
Agree LBT...
Rudolph-Back pocket and McConnell-Forward pocket. Ben Kane and Ben Moore would be a chance also..
Re: Hypothetical 2007 SANFL State Team
Posted:
Thu Jul 19, 2007 6:34 pmby Wedgie
G wrote:From NORTH possibly Alleway, Allan and Younie.
Allan's not eligible (1st year out of the VFL) but Alleway would be a walk up for CHF.
I think O'Hara would be at least the 2nd ruckman too, hasn't been beaten this year.
Ryswyk if fit and Bamford would get a look in.
Re: Hypothetical 2007 SANFL State Team
Posted:
Thu Jul 19, 2007 6:38 pmby doggies4eva
From Central:
Schell, Gowans x2, Callinan, O'Sullivan, Slade, Thomas, Wilson, Ware. Switala
I've probably forgotten someone
Re: Hypothetical 2007 SANFL State Team
Posted:
Thu Jul 19, 2007 6:39 pmby Wedgie
doggies4eva wrote:From Central:
Schell, Gowans x2, Callinan, O'Sullivan, Slade, Thomas, Wilson, Ware. Switala
I've probably forgotten someone
Can't disagree with a single one of those, all walk ups IMHO.
Re: Hypothetical 2007 SANFL State Team
Posted:
Thu Jul 19, 2007 6:46 pmby doggies4eva
Wedgie wrote:doggies4eva wrote:From Central:
Schell, Gowans x2, Callinan, O'Sullivan, Slade, Thomas, Wilson, Ware. Switala
I've probably forgotten someone
Can't disagree with a single one of those, all walk ups IMHO.
I was tempted to also put Lawry, Grima and Havelberg into the squad but I'd play Chambers ahead of Havelberg.
Re: Hypothetical 2007 SANFL State Team
Posted:
Thu Jul 19, 2007 6:54 pmby Aerie
Aerie wrote:Please let me know if I've put any of them in the wrong positions. Nominations so far...
Tall Forwards (TF): Vlatko (Nw), Chambers (St), Grocke (WWT), Alleway (NA), Lawry (CD), Havelberg (CD)
Forward Pockets/Flanks (SF): Symmons (WWT), Younie (NA), McConnell (Gl)
Tall Backs (TB): AhChee (PM), Rudolph (Gl), Schell (CD), Grima (CD)
Back Flankers/Pockets (SB): McGuiness (Nw), Nelson (St), Bratton (St), Kane (Gl), Thomas (CD), Wilson (CD)
Rucks (R): Feast (St), Mieklejohn (PM), Lindsay (WWT), O'Hara (NA)
On Ballers (OB): Sheedy (St), J Clayton (PM), Powell (WWT), Allan (NA), Moore (Gl), J Gowans (CD), C Gowans (CD), Callinan (CD), O'Sullivan (CD), Slade (CD)
Wings (W): Gallagher (Nw), Treeby (WWT), Jarrad (WWT), Ryswyk (NA), Bamford (NA), Ware (CD), Switala (CD)
Coaches: Macgowan (St)
The team may end up something like:
FF: TF TF OB
HF: SF TF SF
C: W OB W
HB: SB TB SB
FB: TB TB OB
R: R OB OB
I: R OB OB
Re: Hypothetical 2007 SANFL State Team
Posted:
Thu Jul 19, 2007 6:59 pmby rod_rooster
Wedgie wrote:doggies4eva wrote:From Central:
Schell, Gowans x2, Callinan, O'Sullivan, Slade, Thomas, Wilson, Ware. Switala
I've probably forgotten someone
Can't disagree with a single one of those, all walk ups IMHO.
Callinan's in the same boat as Allan though Wedgie
Re: Hypothetical 2007 SANFL State Team
Posted:
Thu Jul 19, 2007 7:01 pmby bosvit
The only one from the Bloods I would add would be McCormick
Lenny Clark gets his hands to a lot of ball but is still working on his around the ground.
Dragacevic (or however you spell it) has had a solid season amongst a pile of jelly but dunno if good enough to get state honors??
Re: Hypothetical 2007 SANFL State Team
Posted:
Thu Jul 19, 2007 7:02 pmby Aerie
rod_rooster wrote:Wedgie wrote:doggies4eva wrote:From Central:
Schell, Gowans x2, Callinan, O'Sullivan, Slade, Thomas, Wilson, Ware. Switala
I've probably forgotten someone
Can't disagree with a single one of those, all walk ups IMHO.
Callinan's in the same boat as Allan though Wedgie
I reckon we let them be considered... just for the purpose of this exercise!
Re: Hypothetical 2007 SANFL State Team
Posted:
Thu Jul 19, 2007 7:03 pmby Wedgie
rod_rooster wrote:Wedgie wrote:doggies4eva wrote:From Central:
Schell, Gowans x2, Callinan, O'Sullivan, Slade, Thomas, Wilson, Ware. Switala
I've probably forgotten someone
Can't disagree with a single one of those, all walk ups IMHO.
Callinan's in the same boat as Allan though Wedgie
Yeah true, forgot about that.
Re: Hypothetical 2007 SANFL State Team
Posted:
Thu Jul 19, 2007 7:57 pmby Grahaml
Are we able to agree on any positions 100%? I'd happily slot Schell into CHB, Alleway CHF and Chambers FF. If we allow interstate first year players Callinan would slot in on the ball or forward lines somewhere.
I'd put Grima in for a full back nomination (given no 1 year qualification rule). Been fantastic this year. Only had his colours lowered by Chambers, but given the delivery that day Silvagni wouldn't have been able to do much more than Grima did!