sydney-dog wrote:REB
Honestly, I think Stoneham at his peak was almost the best going around for a couple of seasons and prob the cats most important player....
My crack was at Ottens, he is not fit enough to play in the ruck, he needs a big pre-season so if required he can lead the ruck, on the weekend he was spent after 2 minutes in the ruck, if required he needs to run with the likes of White, Cox and Symonds all day
His pre-season training was obviously based on him being a stay at home forward
Apologies for getting...er, Catty back there Syd. I always arc up when someone has a crack at Otto because for all of his faults, he's actually had a pretty good season. You are only partially right about his pre-season training tho. In Round 20 of last year Otto ripped the grion off the bone in the match against Melbourne and was nowhere near it in Summer as a result. Even if the Cats wanted to prepare him in the manner in which you suggested they couldn't do so. This year, after playing every match of the season, he will now be able to increase training workload rather than having to do it in Cotton Wool.
Otto will never be a Dean Cox no matter how hard he trains, he's just a different type of footballer. Yes, he can do the centre square work but we'd better off with a Mooney type player to run with any mobile ruckman. Not having a genuine ruckman (King looks shot to me) or Centre Half forward hurts us immensely in terms of team balance. Otto attacks the ball hard and makes a contest of it up forward and takes the responsibility of having the shot (even though his kicking needs improvement judging by this season's efforts) and I would say that Otto would be one of our better players this season so of course I am going to defend him. Leave the Otto bashing to the Richmond fans.
Cheers,
REB