AFL Finals - Week 3

[whufc]

Seems you can't have any previous experience with an AFL club and hold any position in the AFL anymore...

Or maybe not hang out in the rooms and hang an opponent two weeks later.

regards,

REB

Would have thought that would be pretty obvious really?

Next thing you know Razor Ray will be in the circle singing the club song

[MW]

I think I just have too much trust in people to do the right thing.

[Lightning McQueen]

I think I just have too much trust in people to do the right thing.

Power Corrupts
Absolute Power
Corrupts Absolutely

[MW]

I just watched the replay again this time with the thought process that he was trying to hold the ball in.... I tell you what, he's got a point here. The ball was under Neale's head until the GWS other guy pulls it out.

[Senor Moto Gadili]

I just watched the replay again this time with the thought process that he was trying to hold the ball in.... I tell you what, he's got a point here. The ball was under Neale's head until the GWS other guy pulls it out.

Correct .... Greene's main objective was to stop the ball coming out, so they could get a holding the ball. You can see Greene look up and over at Razor Ray. As soon as Razor pays holding the ball Greene was out of there. Greene made more contact with Josh Kelly's head than he made with Lachie Neale.

[Senor Moto Gadili]

Forecast for Friday night has changed .... looks like it will be a dry game. I think that helps tbe Cats.

[Senor Moto Gadili]

Decision on Toby Greene appeal is imminent after another 2 hours of argument from both QCs. The AFL have gone all out to have him suspended for this offence. Don't know why they didn't try harder the previous week when he actually did something

[Senor Moto Gadili]

Toby is OUT .... boooo

[tigerpie]

He clearly rakes his hand across his face.
See ya later.
I can't believe people are defending it?

[woodublieve12]

He clearly rakes his hand across his face.
See ya later.
I can't believe people are defending it?

Might get a better view if you open both eyes

[PatowalongaPirate]

He clearly rakes his hand across his face.
See ya later.
I can't believe people are defending it?

In other news, the umpires for this week’s Collingwood v GWS Preliminary Final have been announced -

Michael Christian, Paul Williams and Shane Wakelin.

[PatowalongaPirate]

He clearly rakes his hand across his face.
See ya later.
I can't believe people are defending it?

Might get a better view if you open both eyes

“Clearly rakes his hand across his face” yet no marks or effects to be seen. If he eye gouged give him at least 5 matches, but don’t suspend him for 1 match because of bias. What Hawkins did is much worse and he’s the lucky one.

[Bandit]

Interesting that a lot of Greene defenders say you cat take the first incident into consideration when sanctioning for the second. Yet the same people would say Hawkins has been done for striking before so he deserves his week off (maybe more). You cant have it both ways. Greene deserves to be suspended based on both incidents, you cant let him off a second time because clearly he learnt nothing (same with Hawkins). You cant judge it in isolation because its not an isolated incident, its repeated behaviour.

[Spargo]

He clearly rakes his hand across his face.
See ya later.
I can't believe people are defending it?

I wish the other team you follow got as many leg ups as Collingwood...

[woodublieve12]

Interesting that a lot of Greene defenders say you cat take the first incident into consideration when sanctioning for the second. Yet the same people would say Hawkins has been done for striking before so he deserves his week off (maybe more). You cant have it both ways. Greene deserves to be suspended based on both incidents, you cant let him off a second time because clearly he learnt nothing (same with Hawkins). You cant judge it in isolation because its not an isolated incident, its repeated behaviour.

Well you can have it both ways when Greene didn’t do anything wrong and Hawkins did a filthy cheap shot behind play. If it wasn’t finals Tom would have got more

[PatowalongaPirate]

Interesting that a lot of Greene defenders say you cat take the first incident into consideration when sanctioning for the second. Yet the same people would say Hawkins has been done for striking before so he deserves his week off (maybe more). You cant have it both ways. Greene deserves to be suspended based on both incidents, you cant let him off a second time because clearly he learnt nothing (same with Hawkins). You cant judge it in isolation because its not an isolated incident, its repeated behaviour.

Greene wasn’t charged with the same offence as last week.

[tigerpie]

He clearly rakes his hand across his face.
See ya later.
I can't believe people are defending it?

I wish the other team you follow got as many leg ups as Collingwood...

Hopefully we get a good run Sunday

[tigerpie]

He clearly rakes his hand across his face.
See ya later.
I can't believe people are defending it?

Might get a better view if you open both eyes

Seriously....you went there?
He's guilty as charged.....and a dickhead!

[Yank Man]

I reckon they were just happy to give him a week so they didn’t have to go through this again during grand final week. If GWS make the GF they can deal with it all again after it’s over when he reoffends again, and he will, guys got a rap sheet longer than your arm.

[woodublieve12]

He clearly rakes his hand across his face.
See ya later.
I can't believe people are defending it?

Might get a better view if you open both eyes

Seriously....you went there?
He's guilty as charged.....and a dickhead!

I did go there. If you weren’t playing the giants your view would be very different.

Greene is a dickhead. But he should be punished past indiscretions when he didn’t nothing wrong in this case!

Anyone who touches anyone’s face, regardless of no injury happening this weekend better miss the following week! AFL has set the standard