SA Footy

JK wrote:No Dusty? Give me a spell

At who's expense? Yeo?

I think apart from Hawkins, everyone's spot is warranted, we basically had the back 6 picked Monday on here.

Could be embarrassing when the Brownlow Medalist doesn't make the AA team.

whufc wrote:Could be embarrassing when the Brownlow Medalist doesn't make the AA team.

Matt Pridiss

Did a quick player compare on Hawkins vs Brown as i expected Hawkins to be in front on most stats, the two are quite similar - nothing really pushes one over the other. The main decision you would think then comes down to who kicked the most goals this year (Brown). Maybe the selectors discounted his 10 the other week as it was only vs the Port Pushovers.

Lightning McQueen wrote:

JK wrote:No Dusty? Give me a spell

At who's expense? Yeo?

I think apart from Hawkins, everyone's spot is warranted, we basically had the back 6 picked Monday on here.

Treloar, Kelly, Pendels all great players but I’d be taking Dusty ahead of all of them ... Basically carried the Tigers while they were missing the usual input of fellow leaders Cotchin and Riewoldt.

Don’t reckon it was McGoverns best year either from what I saw (albeit I didn’t see a lot of the Eagles)

Unrelated to the AA side but who would you prefer to win you a final Hawkins or Brown? Hawkins for mine, Brown gets pushed off the ball too easily for my liking.

whufc wrote:Could be embarrassing when the Brownlow Medalist doesn't make the AA team.

Dusty isn't eligible .... who else?

LMA wrote:Unrelated to the AA side but who would you prefer to win you a final Hawkins or Brown? Hawkins for mine, Brown gets pushed off the ball too easily for my liking.

Hawkins sets up a lot more goals too and does more around the ground IMO so it's a no brainer he gets the nod

Senor Moto Gadili wrote:

whufc wrote:Could be embarrassing when the Brownlow Medalist doesn't make the AA team.

Dusty isn't eligible .... who else?

Nobody. Will be eithet Cripps, Bont, Danger or Fyfe

LMA wrote:

Senor Moto Gadili wrote:

whufc wrote:Could be embarrassing when the Brownlow Medalist doesn't make the AA team.

Dusty isn't eligible .... who else?

Nobody. Will be eithet Cripps, Bont, Danger or Fyfe

Would like to see Bont win it but Macrae & Dunkley will take a lot of votes off him. Fyfe, Neale, Cripps the front runners for me. Dangerfield may be around the mark, again Kelly will take a lot away from him though

Lightning McQueen wrote:

JK wrote:No Dusty? Give me a spell

At who's expense? Yeo?

I think apart from Hawkins, everyone's spot is warranted, we basically had the back 6 picked Monday on here.

I would have Dusty ahead Macrae. Like Dusty, Macrae had a relatively quiet start to the year. Macrae gets a lot more possessions, but they aren't as effective as Dusty's. I would even argue that Dunkley has had a more consistent year than Macrae and it wouldn't surprise me if he polls better than Macrae in tbe Bulldogs B&F.

LMA wrote:Unrelated to the AA side but who would you prefer to win you a final Hawkins or Brown? Hawkins for mine, Brown gets pushed off the ball too easily for my liking.

I’m taking Brown.

bertiebeatle wrote:

LMA wrote:

Senor Moto Gadili wrote:

whufc wrote:Could be embarrassing when the Brownlow Medalist doesn't make the AA team.

Dusty isn't eligible .... who else?

Nobody. Will be eithet Cripps, Bont, Danger or Fyfe

Would like to see Bont win it but Macrae & Dunkley will take a lot of votes off him. Fyfe, Neale, Cripps the front runners for me. Dangerfield may be around the mark, again Kelly will take a lot away from him though

Bont should not be eligible. If he wins I hope he thanks Michael Christian

bertiebeatle wrote:

LMA wrote:

Senor Moto Gadili wrote:

whufc wrote:Could be embarrassing when the Brownlow Medalist doesn't make the AA team.

Dusty isn't eligible .... who else?

Nobody. Will be eithet Cripps, Bont, Danger or Fyfe

Would like to see Bont win it but Macrae & Dunkley will take a lot of votes off him. Fyfe, Neale, Cripps the front runners for me. Dangerfield may be around the mark, again Kelly will take a lot away from him though

Grundy for mine, Danger, Neale and Fyfe right up his clacker.

Infact, my crystal balls tell me there will be multiple winners.

LMA wrote:

Senor Moto Gadili wrote:

whufc wrote:Could be embarrassing when the Brownlow Medalist doesn't make the AA team.

Dusty isn't eligible .... who else?

Nobody. Will be eithet Cripps, Bont, Danger or Fyfe

Please be Grundy


$$$$$$$$$

Jim05 wrote:

LMA wrote:Unrelated to the AA side but who would you prefer to win you a final Hawkins or Brown? Hawkins for mine, Brown gets pushed off the ball too easily for my liking.

I’m taking Brown.

Hawkins. (The cat is still on the back).

whufc wrote:Could be embarrassing when the Brownlow Medalist doesn't make the AA team.

Tinfoil hat theory, but I reckon the Brownlow Medalist is already known to those in the fold so they aren't missed off awards like the AA team.

Lightning McQueen wrote:Infact, my crystal balls tell me there will be multiple winners.

I've said this most of the year and still think it's likely

JK wrote:

Lightning McQueen wrote:Infact, my crystal balls tell me there will be multiple winners.

I've said this most of the year and still think it's likely

It wont be a high vote count, that increases the odds, but the lower the count the more chance Fyfe has IMO.

Lightning McQueen wrote:

JK wrote:

Lightning McQueen wrote:Infact, my crystal balls tell me there will be multiple winners.

I've said this most of the year and still think it's likely

It wont be a high vote count, that increases the odds, but the lower the count the more chance Fyfe has IMO.

Fyfe, Bontempelli, Dangerfield all look like they'll have high 20's or low 30's.

I hope for the young bloke with the multi of Cameron/Coleman Neale/Brownlow that Neale wins it, unless he cashes out.