SA Footy

What because you landed a big eerrrr sardine?

Throwing big money at B Grade footballers

Brodlach wrote:What because you landed a big eerrrr sardine?

Throwing big money at B Grade footballers

You reckon Gaffe a B grader?

stan wrote:

Brodlach wrote:What because you landed a big eerrrr sardine?

Throwing big money at B Grade footballers

You reckon Gaffe a B grader?

We haven’t got him yet.

Brodlach wrote:What because you landed a big eerrrr sardine?

Throwing big money at B Grade footballers

On this seasons form, he’s much better than a B grader.
The fact that it was reported there were 4 clubs into him as well as Port desperate for him to stay reflects that.

Dutchy wrote:Did someone say desperation club?

Spargo wrote:

Brodlach wrote:What because you landed a big eerrrr sardine?

Throwing big money at B Grade footballers

On this seasons form, he’s much better than a B grader.
The fact that it was reported there were 4 clubs into him as well as Port desperate for him to stay reflects that.

Oh please. If Port Adelaide had made him a 5 year $3.5m deal you'd be laughing your arse off.

Booney wrote:

Spargo wrote:

Brodlach wrote:What because you landed a big eerrrr sardine?

Throwing big money at B Grade footballers

On this seasons form, he’s much better than a B grader.
The fact that it was reported there were 4 clubs into him as well as Port desperate for him to stay reflects that.

Oh please. If Port Adelaide had made him a 5 year $3.5m deal you'd be laughing your arse off.

Exactly right

Spargo wrote:

Brodlach wrote:What because you landed a big eerrrr sardine?

Throwing big money at B Grade footballers

On this seasons form, he’s much better than a B grader.
The fact that it was reported there were 4 clubs into him as well as Port desperate for him to stay reflects that.

He ain’t better than a B Grader

Booney wrote:

Spargo wrote:

Brodlach wrote:What because you landed a big eerrrr sardine?

Throwing big money at B Grade footballers

On this seasons form, he’s much better than a B grader.
The fact that it was reported there were 4 clubs into him as well as Port desperate for him to stay reflects that.

Oh please. If Port Adelaide had made him a 5 year $3.5m deal you'd be laughing your arse off.

Sounds like you didn't need to get anywhere near that offer at the start of the season which he would have taken

Spargo wrote:

Brodlach wrote:What because you landed a big eerrrr sardine?

Throwing big money at B Grade footballers

On this seasons form, he’s much better than a B grader.
The fact that it was reported there were 4 clubs into him as well as Port desperate for him to stay reflects that.

So are you suggesting he is an A grader?

I wouldnt of thought so.

Booney wrote:

Spargo wrote:

Brodlach wrote:What because you landed a big eerrrr sardine?

Throwing big money at B Grade footballers

On this seasons form, he’s much better than a B grader.
The fact that it was reported there were 4 clubs into him as well as Port desperate for him to stay reflects that.

Oh please. If Port Adelaide had made him a 5 year $3.5m deal you'd be laughing your arse off.

No I wouldn’t, and that’s irrelevant.
The argument was he’s better than a B grader, something I dare say you’d agree with?

MW wrote:

Booney wrote:

Spargo wrote:

Brodlach wrote:What because you landed a big eerrrr sardine?

Throwing big money at B Grade footballers

On this seasons form, he’s much better than a B grader.
The fact that it was reported there were 4 clubs into him as well as Port desperate for him to stay reflects that.

Oh please. If Port Adelaide had made him a 5 year $3.5m deal you'd be laughing your arse off.

Sounds like you didn't need to get anywhere near that offer at the start of the season which he would have taken

Poor list management.

Brodlach wrote:

Spargo wrote:

Brodlach wrote:What because you landed a big eerrrr sardine?

Throwing big money at B Grade footballers

On this seasons form, he’s much better than a B grader.
The fact that it was reported there were 4 clubs into him as well as Port desperate for him to stay reflects that.

He ain’t better than a B Grader

His best footy is A grade but when he’s not on he’s terrible.
Looks like he was more consistent this year though hence his increase in value.

We are going to see a lot more B+ graders getting coin like that though moving forward.

carey wrote:

Spargo wrote:

Brodlach wrote:What because you landed a big eerrrr sardine?

Throwing big money at B Grade footballers

On this seasons form, he’s much better than a B grader.
The fact that it was reported there were 4 clubs into him as well as Port desperate for him to stay reflects that.

So are you suggesting he is an A grader?

I wouldnt of thought so.

On this seasons form he’d be pretty damn close.

Spargo wrote:

carey wrote:

Spargo wrote:

Brodlach wrote:What because you landed a big eerrrr sardine?

Throwing big money at B Grade footballers

On this seasons form, he’s much better than a B grader.
The fact that it was reported there were 4 clubs into him as well as Port desperate for him to stay reflects that.

So are you suggesting he is an A grader?

I wouldnt of thought so.

On this seasons form he’d be pretty damn close.

Sucks when you can't keep shitcanning the bloke now that he plays for you. You've spent years bagging him.

I had it with Brett Montgomery. I understand.

Poor list management.[/quote]

Lol, won't be saying that when his foot flares up playing on Etihad's surface every second week. As Booney said in the other thread, I think we got this one right. Don't have any problems with him taking the extra coin & years when his foot is still a risk especially on that surface

MW wrote:

Booney wrote:

Spargo wrote:

Brodlach wrote:What because you landed a big eerrrr sardine?

Throwing big money at B Grade footballers

On this seasons form, he’s much better than a B grader.
The fact that it was reported there were 4 clubs into him as well as Port desperate for him to stay reflects that.

Oh please. If Port Adelaide had made him a 5 year $3.5m deal you'd be laughing your arse off.

Sounds like you didn't need to get anywhere near that offer at the start of the season which he would have taken

So you think 5×700 is closer to his value than 3x500?

I think they are both outside his value.
4 years at $600k would have got it done at the start of the season. 4 years at $550k prob would have got it done also.
Leave him on the market and this is what happened...
I understand why Port did it though. His feet are make of chalk.
They gambled and lost. Now North have the upper hand in the trade as he can walk to North in the PSD if they don't trade.

MW wrote:I think they are both outside his value.
4 years at $600k would have got it done at the start of the season. 4 years at $550k prob would have got it done also.
Leave him on the market and this is what happened...
I understand why Port did it though. His feet are make of chalk.
They gambled and lost. Now North have the upper hand in the trade as he can walk to North in the PSD if they don't trade.

He won't end up at the PSD. Even if he did, someone else would take him before North. Also, if we offered him 4 years now he would take it. The club doesn't want to & I back them on this one

Besides STK, who else will pay Polec what North are? He walks to North.