Re: Port Adelaide 2016
Posted:
Tue Jun 21, 2016 2:35 pmby amber_fluid
Booney wrote:amber_fluid wrote:JK wrote:Haven't seen much of him for a while, but I'd always been impressed enough with what I'd seen from Clurey .. Is it just injury that has stifled his progression to AFL level, or form/ability?
He has a red hot go but is too slow IMO.
Kicking lets him down as well.
DBJ surely has taken his spot now.
DBJ is 181cm Clurey is 193, they don't play the same role. Hombsch went ahead of Clurey and the so too did Jonas when Carlile got hurt late in '14 and then again in '15. Clurey regularly finishes top 5 in our 3km time trials. He had a limited preseason and hasn't got going since.
Yeah Clurey looks like an old fashioned footballer..... Socks down, no frills footballer.
Do you think his skills are good enough for AFL?
Re: Port Adelaide 2016
Posted:
Tue Jun 21, 2016 2:41 pmby Booney
amber_fluid wrote:Wasn't it announced only a couple of weeks ago that Young signed a new 1 year deal?
Is he Victorian........ I assumed he only wanted one at this stage as the lure of going home might be there?
It was announced a couple of weeks ago but it was actually signed in the summer. He only got one more year ( next year ) for the reasons noted, we probably weren't sure we he sat ( we do now! ) and the likely return of Monfries or at least the discussion about that would have been in their thinking.
Re: Port Adelaide 2016
Posted:
Tue Jun 21, 2016 3:06 pmby UK Fan
Rik E Boy wrote:UK Fan wrote:Why port have underachieved and who's at fault is an interesting debate. Usually there isn't a single Bullet theory as to why these things have occurred but usually a combination of differing factors.
The major problem for port is moving forward.
Playing list - widely reported port are up to full capacity re: salary cap with majority of players worth any currency at trade time signed on long term contracts. So little room to move. I expect the likes of Schultz S.Gray Mitchell butcher the most likely to be moved on at years end. Due to they could be replaced by younger cheaper options.
Coaching - same as above Hinkley & Voss on long term contracts and port financially won't be able to even entertain paying them out.
Only solution is to stick fat and roll out the rhetoric "port Adelaide footy" and cross fingers for a better preseason campaign in 2017 IMHO!!!!
Which the loyal port fans will see as the club accepting mediocrity.
Fun times
You're a strange one. You are an anti-barracker. Don't barrack for anyone but loves sledging Port LOL. I can understand the latter, but not the former.
regards,
REB
I'm pretty sure you know who I support REB. If you can't figure it out you are dumber than I thought
Re: Port Adelaide 2016
Posted:
Tue Jun 21, 2016 4:36 pmby marbles
if wasnt for essendon, ryder wouldve played, dougal howard still be in ressies, and his knee would be fine, instead a year off torn ACL
Re: Port Adelaide 2016
Posted:
Tue Jun 21, 2016 5:07 pmby amber_fluid
So it was finalised recently..... That article is early June.
Port must have offered more based on his good year so far and he signed it.
Re: Port Adelaide 2016
Posted:
Tue Jun 21, 2016 5:11 pmby Booney
amber_fluid wrote:So it was finalised recently..... That article is early June.
Port must have offered more based on his good year so far and he signed it.
Trust me, it was done months ago.
Re: Port Adelaide 2016
Posted:
Tue Jun 21, 2016 5:14 pmby amber_fluid
Booney wrote:amber_fluid wrote:So it was finalised recently..... That article is early June.
Port must have offered more based on his good year so far and he signed it.
Trust me, it was done months ago.
If that is the case........ Young is going to miss out on some serious $$$
He's gone from emergency to one of their most important players in the space of 10 weeks or so
Re: Port Adelaide 2016
Posted:
Tue Jun 21, 2016 5:23 pmby Booney
On the other hand he's now got 12 months to work on a deal that's more commensurate with his current output.
Re: Port Adelaide 2016
Posted:
Tue Jun 21, 2016 5:35 pmby amber_fluid
Booney wrote:On the other hand he's now got 12 months to work on a deal that's more commensurate with his current output.
Yeah true.
Although he will be playing next year for peanuts compared to actual worth if he continues his form.
Re: Port Adelaide 2016
Posted:
Tue Jun 21, 2016 6:22 pmby hearts on fire
Young has had a great first half to the year but can he consistently play at the level he is producing ?
I hope he can but no one at the club apart from him, Gray and Wingard can play more than one good game in row, so I'm not confident at all he will continue this form.
To many average players that won't get any better; Broadbent, Jonas, O'Shea, Stewart, Amon, Ah Chee, Neade, S.Gray, Lobbe, White, Westhoff, Carlile, Toumpas, Mitchell and Butcher, couldn't give stuff if we lost any of those players above.
Figjam Hartlett and figjam Ebert, two players who had the potential to become one of the better midfielders in the game, are just embarrassing at the moment, should of just gave North Melboune Hartlett and Ebert should of stayed at WCE.
Only one or two genuine stars on the list Gray and Wingard, but even then Gray cracks the sads when things are tough and Wingard can be inconsistent.
I can't see us making the finals anytime soon in the next few years, 13/14 gave great hope the club was finally improving and on the way up but that's all it was, hope, now we are playing the "Port Adelaide way", we are shlt again!
Re: Port Adelaide 2016
Posted:
Tue Jun 21, 2016 7:32 pmby gossipgirl
You can still make the finals this year
Port Adelaide 2016
Posted:
Tue Jun 21, 2016 7:52 pmby Jim05
gossipgirl wrote:You can still make the finals this year
Almost zero chance
2 games plus massive %.
You also have forgotten that the sides above Port still have Essendon to play.
Re: Port Adelaide 2016
Posted:
Tue Jun 21, 2016 8:56 pmby Ruben Carter
hearts on fire wrote:Young has had a great first half to the year but can he consistently play at the level he is producing ?
I hope he can but no one at the club apart from him, Gray and Wingard can play more than one good game in row, so I'm not confident at all he will continue this form.
To many average players that won't get any better; Broadbent, Jonas, O'Shea, Stewart, Amon, Ah Chee, Neade, S.Gray, Lobbe, White, Westhoff, Carlile, Toumpas, Mitchell and Butcher, couldn't give stuff if we lost any of those players above.
Figjam Hartlett and figjam Ebert, two players who had the potential to become one of the better midfielders in the game, are just embarrassing at the moment, should of just gave North Melboune Hartlett and Ebert should of stayed at WCE.
Only one or two genuine stars on the list Gray and Wingard, but even then Gray cracks the sads when things are tough and Wingard can be inconsistent.
I can't see us making the finals anytime soon in the next few years, 13/14 gave great hope the club was finally improving and on the way up but that's all it was, hope, now we are playing the "Port Adelaide way", we are shlt again!
WOW! are you sure you're a Power/PA fan HOF? You sound a bit like a troll....
Re: Port Adelaide 2016
Posted:
Tue Jun 21, 2016 8:58 pmby Ruben Carter
marbles wrote:if wasnt for essendon, ryder wouldve played, dougal howard still be in ressies, and his knee would be fine, instead a year off torn ACL
That's right, nobody ever does an ACL in the SANFL.
Re: Port Adelaide 2016
Posted:
Tue Jun 21, 2016 9:13 pmby Grahaml
hearts on fire wrote:Young has had a great first half to the year but can he consistently play at the level he is producing ?
I hope he can but no one at the club apart from him, Gray and Wingard can play more than one good game in row, so I'm not confident at all he will continue this form.
To many average players that won't get any better; Broadbent, Jonas, O'Shea, Stewart, Amon, Ah Chee, Neade, S.Gray, Lobbe, White, Westhoff, Carlile, Toumpas, Mitchell and Butcher, couldn't give stuff if we lost any of those players above.
Figjam Hartlett and figjam Ebert, two players who had the potential to become one of the better midfielders in the game, are just embarrassing at the moment, should of just gave North Melboune Hartlett and Ebert should of stayed at WCE.
Only one or two genuine stars on the list Gray and Wingard, but even then Gray cracks the sads when things are tough and Wingard can be inconsistent.
I can't see us making the finals anytime soon in the next few years, 13/14 gave great hope the club was finally improving and on the way up but that's all it was, hope, now we are playing the "Port Adelaide way", we are shlt again!
Isn't Rucci due to revive the Dangerfield v Ebert argument again?
Re: Port Adelaide 2016
Posted:
Tue Jun 21, 2016 10:07 pmby bennymacca
Ruben Carter wrote:hearts on fire wrote:Young has had a great first half to the year but can he consistently play at the level he is producing ?
I hope he can but no one at the club apart from him, Gray and Wingard can play more than one good game in row, so I'm not confident at all he will continue this form.
To many average players that won't get any better; Broadbent, Jonas, O'Shea, Stewart, Amon, Ah Chee, Neade, S.Gray, Lobbe, White, Westhoff, Carlile, Toumpas, Mitchell and Butcher, couldn't give stuff if we lost any of those players above.
Figjam Hartlett and figjam Ebert, two players who had the potential to become one of the better midfielders in the game, are just embarrassing at the moment, should of just gave North Melboune Hartlett and Ebert should of stayed at WCE.
Only one or two genuine stars on the list Gray and Wingard, but even then Gray cracks the sads when things are tough and Wingard can be inconsistent.
I can't see us making the finals anytime soon in the next few years, 13/14 gave great hope the club was finally improving and on the way up but that's all it was, hope, now we are playing the "Port Adelaide way", we are shlt again!
WOW! are you sure you're a Power/PA fan HOF? You sound a bit like a troll....
Thought it's a pretty reasonable opinion, how is it a troll?
Re: Port Adelaide 2016
Posted:
Wed Jun 22, 2016 5:49 pmby MW
5AA going into meltdown over state gov giving port 50k compo for late trains with money to be spent on fireworks and LED lights.
Couldn't agree more with the criticism...absolute joke and i hope it was not asked for by Port
Re: Port Adelaide 2016
Posted:
Wed Jun 22, 2016 6:23 pmby PatowalongaPirate
Pretty sure the tram was late last Sunday.
Can the Bays please have 3 million?