Collingwood whip Ports butts

[sydney-dog]

GWW

Totally Agree

Most over-rated and biggest chockers

[PortAdelaideProud]

go the magpies! you beauty!

Collingwood 1, yes one, yes 1,....thats ONE premiership in 50 years.....most OVERRATED CLUB IN THE HISTORY OF THE WESTERN WORLD!! Should have been relegated to the VFA 30 years ago!!

AMEN!

Port Adelaide Magpies. 36 Premierships, including Australian record, 6 straight.

Hell will freeze over before Collingwood ever comes close to that.

[sydney-dog]

PortAdelaideProud

mate, serious question here, PAFC clubed was registered in 1870, 36 SANFL Premierships, with the last premiership 1999, would that be correct... this means the club won a premiership every approx four seasons

My question, what is the PAFC Magpies longest premiership drought, currently it is 6 yrs, this year could be 7 years

[GWW]

PortAdelaideProud

mate, serious question here, PAFC clubed was registered in 1870, 36 SANFL Premierships, with the last premiership 1999, would that be correct... this means the club won a premiership every approx four seasons

My question, what is the PAFC Magpies longest premiership drought, currently it is 6 yrs, this year could be 7 years

I'm not sure about before the 1950's, but i'd say of recent times it would be 12, 1965 to 1977.

[Rik E Boy]

go the magpies! you beauty!

Collingwood 1, yes one, yes 1,....thats ONE premiership in 50 years.....most OVERRATED CLUB IN THE HISTORY OF THE WESTERN WORLD!! Should have been relegated to the VFA 30 years ago!!

AMEN!

Port Adelaide Magpies. 36 Premierships, including Australian record, 6 straight.

Hell will freeze over before Collingwood ever comes close to that.

LMAO PortAdelaideDumb. I would have liked to see the all conquering Magpies unit of the 1950's defeat the Demons of the same era. Pfft. No chance. Like or lump it the SANFL wasn't as good as the VFL so the **** cares who many SNAFL flags you've won when we are talking about the AFL/VFL? The Chief owns all of your Alberton a55e5 with that signature of his, top work.

BTW, Port were absolutely robbed by the goal umpire tho - no excuse for bad officiating.

regards,

REB

[PortAdelaideProud]

go the magpies! you beauty!

Collingwood 1, yes one, yes 1,....thats ONE premiership in 50 years.....most OVERRATED CLUB IN THE HISTORY OF THE WESTERN WORLD!! Should have been relegated to the VFA 30 years ago!!

AMEN!

Port Adelaide Magpies. 36 Premierships, including Australian record, 6 straight.

Hell will freeze over before Collingwood ever comes close to that.

LMAO PortAdelaideDumb. I would have liked to see the all conquering Magpies unit of the 1950's defeat the Demons of the same era. Pfft. No chance. Like or lump it the SANFL wasn't as good as the VFL so the f*** cares who many SNAFL flags you've won when we are talking about the AFL/VFL? The Chief owns all of your Alberton a55e5 with that signature of his, top work.

BTW, Port were absolutely robbed by the goal umpire tho - no excuse for bad officiating.

regards,

REB

Under Fos Williams, yeah, Port Adelaide woulda whooped Melbourne pretty good.

[PortAdelaideProud]

PortAdelaideProud

mate, serious question here, PAFC clubed was registered in 1870, 36 SANFL Premierships, with the last premiership 1999, would that be correct... this means the club won a premiership every approx four seasons

My question, what is the PAFC Magpies longest premiership drought, currently it is 6 yrs, this year could be 7 years

I'm in a rush at the moment so I'll give you a short version

Port Adelaide Football Club (the Power) Est. 1870. Played SANFL from 1870 to 1996. AFL from 1997 to present. 34 SANFL premierships and 1 AFL premiership.

Port Adelaide Magpies Football Club. Est 1996. Created to keep Magpies presence in SANFL. Both PAFC and PAMFC share all history and records between 1870-1996, after that, they are separate histories and records.

[Rik E Boy]

Under Fos Williams, yeah, Port Adelaide woulda whooped Melbourne pretty good.

LMAO. You should go into comedy, then you wouldn't have to rush your work. You're a natural. Thanks for the belly laugh. GOLD

regards,

REB

[Booney]

The Chief's signature is another glaring example that Victorian fool's,more so Collingwood rock-ape's are under the impression the competition is "theirs".Bull5hit to that.No-one owns the competition,it is no more "theirs" than it is "ours".Their underachieving mob with arrogant attitudes are the direct result of their clubs inability to perform on the field and no-one person is happier than me to let them know they are failures of the highest order.

[Footy Chick]

PortAdelaideProud

mate, serious question here, PAFC clubed was registered in 1870, 36 SANFL Premierships, with the last premiership 1999, would that be correct... this means the club won a premiership every approx four seasons

My question, what is the PAFC Magpies longest premiership drought, currently it is 6 yrs, this year could be 7 years

I'm in a rush at the moment so I'll give you a short version

Port Adelaide Football Club (the Power) Est. 1870. Played SANFL from 1870 to 1996. AFL from 1997 to present. 34 SANFL premierships and 1 AFL premiership.

Port Adelaide Magpies Football Club. Est 1996. Created to keep Magpies presence in SANFL. Both PAFC and PAMFC share all history and records between 1870-1996, after that, they are separate histories and records.

What bullshit..... you sound like a bloody brainwashed cult member...

How can PAFC and PAMFC supposedly share these records if PAMFC were supposedly created in 1996?
PAFC (the Magpies) are the unrivalled club to win these premierships pre- 1996. Do you think Fos would have been caught dead in a teal jumper with a thunderbolt on it? Me thinks not...


In 1996 the PAFC won licence to enter A team in the AFL. The team that entered tried to take with it the tradition of the REAL club that played tough, hard and SUCCESSFUL football for over 100 years before it, by employing a large contingent of non PAFC players (for obvious reasons of course, even Jack himself told me that to be successful in the AFL they would need AT LEAST another 9 players). The football that the Power play doesn't resemble in the slightest what the real Port Adelaide is all about....

PS: PAP- Port have won 36 premierships, not 34

[Booney]

Nah this looks really good,our own eating our own in an argument that,even with the fact's presented to them,people like FC still disagree with.

Tradition cant be taken away,it cant be adopted.I agree.Clubs can move,identities can change.No argument.Get over it all and move on FFS!

[Footy Chick]

Its a subject that will ALWAYS hit a nerve with me Boon, and its for this very reason I remain a Magpie but refuse to follow the Power, cos in my eyes it's just not Port....

[Booney]

I just feel it is an argument no one can win,and one that shouldn't need to be debated.The solution would have been to have no Port Adelaide team in the SANFL,that would resolve all arguments,but,that of course was never going to happen,and Im glad it didnt.Just dont bag people who follow the Power,they choose to follow them just as you choose not to.

[MW]

Its a classic case of having your cake and eating it too with Port Power and Port Magpies sharing the history pre 1996.

[PortAdelaideProud]

Read the club history pages, they will tell you exactly what I'm telling you.

Under the PAFC banner, there is 34 SANFL premierships, and 1 AFL premiership. Under the PAMFC, there is only 2 premierships, but like I said, the two clubs share all history and records from 1870-1996.

The Port Adelaide Football Club have been the 'Power' since 1996, and the Magpies have been the Port Adelaide Magpies Football Club.

I aint making up this stuff, it's written in black and white. If this was not the truth, I would not be saying it.

People say the Power are the Port Adelaide Power Football Club, when they are not. They are the same Port Adelaide Football Club that played in the SANFL under the Magpies name from 1870-1996.

I'm not arguing with anyone, coz you can't argue cold hard facts.

[MW]

You've been brainwashed if you believe that crap about sharing the history

[sydney-dog]

PortAdelaideProud

Your website and club history pages is all about Properganda

Both clubs are registered as two seperate identities, operate under different licences, have seperate ABN's, registered as seperate businesses, operate under seperate boards, employ seperate CEO, Directors, Presidents, the constitution is different, revenue, assetts and losses are recorded on different books...

Why don't the other 8 SANFL clubs claim the crows premiership as their club premiership, maybe the Bays have the strongest claim

PortAdelaideProud, you can not be serious

[PortAdelaideProud]

PortAdelaideProud

Your website and club history pages is all about Properganda

Both clubs are registered as two seperate identities, operate under different licences, have seperate ABN's, registered as seperate businesses, operate under seperate boards, employ seperate CEO, Directors, Presidents, the constitution is different, revenue, assetts and losses are recorded on different books...

Why don't the other 8 SANFL clubs claim the crows premiership as their club premiership, maybe the Bays have the strongest claim

PortAdelaideProud, you can not be serious

Read the friggin history pages for crying out loud. I know what the hell I'm talking about.

Read the 3rd to bottom paragraph
http://www.portmagpies.com.au/about.php
Still don't believe me, fine, that's your problem, not mine.

[MW]

Don't believe everything you read or hear...like I said...brainwashed.

[sydney-dog]

PortAdelaideProud

Mate, your kidding, it has nothing to do with the history papers, it's all to do with how the clubs are set up as two total identities

No one is denying that the Power evolved from the magpies but they are two different entities.....

Does fremantle claim south fremantles premierships, no

Mate, I just took a look at your history pages, the Power web-site under Tradition, list past players, brief history and honor role all from 1997, list 1 premiership

Hold me down, but I just logged on to the Port Magpies website, checked the honor role and it DOES NOT list the AFL premiership

PortAdelaideProud

Just to put it beyond any reasonable doubt, I have just read the third bottom paragraph on the Port Magpies website under the history tab, and the last 10 words in this paragraph say

"WHO SHARE THE RECORDS AND HISTORY BETWEEN 1870 and 1996"

meaning, they are two seperate CLUBS

DO YOU GET IT!!!!!!!!!