Collingwood 2014

[carey]

Seedsman has to be better than Toovey? Toovey is shit

[Dogwatcher]

Had enough of noble losses.

[Q.]

Seedsman has to be better than Toovey? Toovey is shit

Two different players, Toovey shuts down a small forward. Seedsman ain't a defender's arsehole.

[Q.]

Had enough of noble losses.

Really missed Marley Williams in those conditions.

Also, you've got to question the reason for having both Grundy and Witts in the side when it was obvious the conditions were going to suit the small blokes.

[Dogwatcher]

Had enough of noble losses.

Really missed Marley Williams in those conditions.

Also, you've got to question the reason for having both Grundy and Witts in the side when it was obvious the conditions were going to suit the small blokes.

Definitely.
Why was Broomhead subbed. Was he injured?
Having Witts, Grundy, Cloke and White all on was debilitating.

And...you can't tell me our mids/half backs are confident going forward and delivering to Cloke/White.
If they were, even in those conditions, I'm sure we would have seen some more incisive delivery into bombs to bloody Broadbent.

[Q.]

Broomhead hurt his shoulder, apparently.

[Dogwatcher]

Be interesting to see how bad it is.

Any thoughts on Adams' incident?
I knew what he was trying to do - get some more balance by planting his knee on the ground. But...that's not what he did and it looks bloody bad.

[tigerpie]

I think oxley has taken seeds spot for now. He didn't have a great game tonight however.
I thought toovey was great at times last night.
Started poorly last night and again didn't finish off in front of goal. Blair's miss was horrible even though conditions were slippery. White missed another gettable goal when we needed him to kick straight. Not sure he's capable of a quality finish when it counts. This hurts us every game.

[stan]

Be interesting to see how bad it is.

Any thoughts on Adams' incident?
I knew what he was trying to do - get some more balance by planting his knee on the ground. But...that's not what he did and it looks bloody bad.

Adams was trying to knee him in the head and suceeded. I think he is in trouble but should get a reduced suspension because Westhoff is a flog [emoji6]

[stan]

Had enough of noble losses.

Really missed Marley Williams in those conditions.

Also, you've got to question the reason for having both Grundy and Witts in the side when it was obvious the conditions were going to suit the small blokes.

Definitely.
Why was Broomhead subbed. Was he injured?
Having Witts, Grundy, Cloke and White all on was debilitating.

And...you can't tell me our mids/half backs are confident going forward and delivering to Cloke/White.
If they were, even in those conditions, I'm sure we would have seen some more incisive delivery into bombs to bloody Broadbent.

Broomhead was injured but loomed good before that.

[Spargo]

Be interesting to see how bad it is.

Any thoughts on Adams' incident?
I knew what he was trying to do - get some more balance by planting his knee on the ground. But...that's not what he did and it looks bloody bad.

He responded the way others would too if they had their hair pulled in a violent manner.

[Dogwatcher]

Be interesting to see how bad it is.

Any thoughts on Adams' incident?
I knew what he was trying to do - get some more balance by planting his knee on the ground. But...that's not what he did and it looks bloody bad.

Adams was trying to knee him in the head and suceeded. I think he is in trouble but should get a reduced suspension because Westhoff is a flog [emoji6]

On another viewing, you're right, he did. And twice.
Two games.

[Dogwatcher]

Be interesting to see how bad it is.

Any thoughts on Adams' incident?
I knew what he was trying to do - get some more balance by planting his knee on the ground. But...that's not what he did and it looks bloody bad.

He responded the way others would too if they had their hair pulled in a violent manner.

I dunno about violent, but watching the replay, it seems Westhoff definitely was pulling his hair.
I'm not sure it justified kneeing him.

I'm also not sure how Boak ended up with the free in the kaffufle afterwards.

[Q.]

Be interesting to see how bad it is.

Any thoughts on Adams' incident?
I knew what he was trying to do - get some more balance by planting his knee on the ground. But...that's not what he did and it looks bloody bad.

Adams was trying to knee him in the head and suceeded. I think he is in trouble but should get a reduced suspension because Westhoff is a flog [emoji6]

On another viewing, you're right, he did. And twice.
Two games.

It's a shame, because he is in ridiculously good form.

[Booney]

Be interesting to see how bad it is.

Any thoughts on Adams' incident?
I knew what he was trying to do - get some more balance by planting his knee on the ground. But...that's not what he did and it looks bloody bad.

He responded the way others would too if they had their hair pulled in a violent manner.

I've just watched it about 5 times, when did Westhoff "violently pull his hair"? I can only see the off with a handful of guernsey.

[Spargo]

Be interesting to see how bad it is.

Any thoughts on Adams' incident?
I knew what he was trying to do - get some more balance by planting his knee on the ground. But...that's not what he did and it looks bloody bad.

He responded the way others would too if they had their hair pulled in a violent manner.

I've just watched it about 5 times, when did Westhoff "violently pull his hair"? I can only see the off with a handful of guernsey.

Open both eyes and watch it a sixth time

[Booney]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2015-07-10/t ... h-westhoff

Tell me at what time in this video Westhoff "violently" pulls Adams' hair.

Thanks in advance.

[Spargo]

http://www.afl.com.au/news/2015-07-10/taylor-adams-facing-mrp-scrutiny-after-clash-with-westhoff

Tell me at what time in this video Westhoff "violently" pulls Adams' hair.

Thanks in advance.

It happened in that same incident only a few seconds earlier.
They showed it a few times last night during the telecast.
Apology accepted in advance.

[Dogwatcher]

During the grapple, it seems he grabs his hair at the nape. Early on.
Still doesn't justify the knee.

[Booney]

Well I've watched the extended version in the game highlights package. Beats me where you see it.

Apology? Bwahahahahaha