Port Adelaide 2017

[morell]

How come Phillips doesn't get more of a run?

[amber_fluid]

One of the best contested marks in the game. Not overrated at all IMO.

May very well be, but that doesn't make him a good ruckman does it? I mean it helps, but....

He doesn't win enough taps, get enough of the ball or advantage his midfielders.

I see Kruezer as the perfect second ruck rotating forward to be honest

All good and well if you have a first ruckman..........

You did once upon a time...Jacobs.

Don't remind me!
We had a handy small forward too at one stage.
He was pretty good yesterday.

[MW]

Both can play when in form...

[Brodlach]

One of the best contested marks in the game. Not overrated at all IMO.

May very well be, but that doesn't make him a good ruckman does it? I mean it helps, but....

He doesn't win enough taps, get enough of the ball or advantage his midfielders.

I see Kruezer as the perfect second ruck rotating forward to be honest

True

G

Clearly Kruezer must get votes in awards too


Only thing that counts IMO is hit outs, possessions and clearances.

[morell]

One of the best contested marks in the game. Not overrated at all IMO.

May very well be, but that doesn't make him a good ruckman does it? I mean it helps, but....

He doesn't win enough taps, get enough of the ball or advantage his midfielders.

I see Kruezer as the perfect second ruck rotating forward to be honest

True

G

Clearly Kruezer must get votes in awards too


Only thing that counts IMO is hit outs, possessions and clearances.

And the quality of those things therein. Thats what is difficult to measure, which is why you have to use some sort of anecdotal human type perception *in addition* to the raw stats.

Kruezer's quality around the ground and marking prowess is what makes him different, but he isn't up there with the elite as just a ruckman. He is more of your Roughead type IMO. Doing a solid job nonetheless.

Welcome to the SWAM brotherhood Brodlach, its growing by the day!

[amber_fluid]

Kruezer is as good as any ruckman going around today.

[Brodlach]

One of the best contested marks in the game. Not overrated at all IMO.

May very well be, but that doesn't make him a good ruckman does it? I mean it helps, but....

He doesn't win enough taps, get enough of the ball or advantage his midfielders.

I see Kruezer as the perfect second ruck rotating forward to be honest

True

G

Clearly Kruezer must get votes in awards too


Only thing that counts IMO is hit outs, possessions and clearances.

And the quality of those things therein. Thats what is difficult to measure, which is why you have to use some sort of anecdotal human type perception *in addition* to the raw stats.

Kruezer's quality around the ground and marking prowess is what makes him different, but he isn't up there with the elite as just a ruckman. He is more of your Roughead type IMO. Doing a solid job nonetheless.

Welcome to the SWAM brotherhood Brodlach, its growing by the day! [/quote]


Morrell I'm Anti-SWARM, the votes part is ridiculous

[Rik E Boy]

Ryder Swarmed for the second time in three matches. No AA for him.

regards,

REB

[amber_fluid]

True

G

Clearly Kruezer must get votes in awards too


Only thing that counts IMO is hit outs, possessions and clearances.

And the quality of those things therein. Thats what is difficult to measure, which is why you have to use some sort of anecdotal human type perception *in addition* to the raw stats.

Kruezer's quality around the ground and marking prowess is what makes him different, but he isn't up there with the elite as just a ruckman. He is more of your Roughead type IMO. Doing a solid job nonetheless.

Welcome to the SWAM brotherhood Brodlach, its growing by the day!

Morrell I'm Anti-SWARM, the votes part is ridiculous

C'mon mate, join his SWARM club so he can double its membership base

[morell]

The SWARM will win out in the end.

The votes part isnt ridiculous at all Brodlach. It's a great way of measuring how the football coaching community rates each players game. The SEN Rankings aren't votes, they're scores.

[Lightning McQueen]

Stumbled across this, thoughts anyone?

PORT ADELAIDE’S GREATEST TEAM

B: G. Wanganeen, D. Wakelin, M. Wilson

HB: A. Kingsley, C. Cornes, D. Mead

C: K. Cornes, J. Carr, B. Pickett

HF: S. Dew, W. Tredrea, S. Burgoyne

F: P. Burgoyne, J. Schulz, R. Gray

1R: M. Primus, J. Francou, R. James

Int: B. Lade, D. Cassisi, T. Boak, B. Montgomery

Coach: M. Williams

[Jim05]

Thought they are one club?
Where are all the Magpie legends?

[JK]

Fair side, and first reaction is it would be hard to displace any/many of those blokes.

[morell]

Thought they are one club?
Where are all the Magpie legends?

its clearly Port's greatest AFL side, don't be obstinate.

[Booney]

Stumbled across this, thoughts anyone?

PORT ADELAIDE’S GREATEST TEAM

B: G. Wanganeen, D. Wakelin, M. Wilson

HB: A. Kingsley, C. Cornes, D. Mead

C: K. Cornes, J. Carr, B. Pickett

HF: S. Dew, W. Tredrea, S. Burgoyne

F: P. Burgoyne, J. Schulz, R. Gray

1R: M. Primus, J. Francou, R. James

Int: B. Lade, D. Cassisi, T. Boak, B. Montgomery

Coach: M. Williams

Incorrect, that's an Advertiser "AFL Stars" line up.

In 2000 we named our "Greatest Team" from 1870-2000

FF Scott Hodges Tim Evans Bob Quinn
HF Dave Boyd "Bro" Dayman Harold Oliver
C Craig Bradley Russell Ebert John Cahill
HB Neville Hayes Greg Phillips Geof Motley
FB Dick Russell John Abley Ted Whelan
Foll Russell Johnston "Bull" Reval Fos Williams
Int Harry Phillips Jeff Potter Peter Woite Lloyd Zucker
Coach Fos Williams

[Lightning McQueen]

Thought they are one club?
Where are all the Magpie legends?

F*** me, you bored mate?

I'll just shut up and let morell instigate conversation.

I support Port Power, I've never liked the Magpies.

[Jim05]

Thought they are one club?
Where are all the Magpie legends?

its clearly Port's greatest AFL side, don't be obstinate.

I gathered that, only stirring.
Interestly for you Port blokes would any from that AFL team make or come close to making Ports greatest side ever?

[Lightning McQueen]

Stumbled across this, thoughts anyone?

PORT ADELAIDE’S GREATEST TEAM

B: G. Wanganeen, D. Wakelin, M. Wilson

HB: A. Kingsley, C. Cornes, D. Mead

C: K. Cornes, J. Carr, B. Pickett

HF: S. Dew, W. Tredrea, S. Burgoyne

F: P. Burgoyne, J. Schulz, R. Gray

1R: M. Primus, J. Francou, R. James

Int: B. Lade, D. Cassisi, T. Boak, B. Montgomery

Coach: M. Williams

Incorrect, that's an Advertiser "AFL Stars" line up.

In 2000 we named our "Greatest Team" from 1870-2000

FF Scott Hodges Tim Evans Bob Quinn
HF Dave Boyd "Bro" Dayman Harold Oliver
C Craig Bradley Russell Ebert John Cahill
HB Neville Hayes Greg Phillips Geof Motley
FB Dick Russell John Abley Ted Whelan
Foll Russell Johnston "Bull" Reval Fos Williams
Int Harry Phillips Jeff Potter Peter Woite Lloyd Zucker
Coach Fos Williams

Yeah, I didn't think the key word mattered, it was obviously a team the chip wrapper put together for the Power.

I'll go back to looking at myself in the reflection of the window seeing which face I pull makes me better looking

[Lightning McQueen]

Thought they are one club?
Where are all the Magpie legends?

its clearly Port's greatest AFL side, don't be obstinate.

I gathered that, only stirring.
Interestly for you Port blokes would any from that AFL team make or come close to making Ports greatest side ever?

Probably just one, a bit hard to compare though with 130 years of prior history.

Yes, I know it's more than 130 years but Booney mentioned his list was made in 2000.

[morell]

Thought they are one club?
Where are all the Magpie legends?

its clearly Port's greatest AFL side, don't be obstinate.

I gathered that, only stirring.
Interestly for you Port blokes would any from that AFL team make or come close to making Ports greatest side ever?

Was going to ask the same question.

Wanganeen, Tredrea and Gray would be the ones.