SA Footy

Not saying he should get off but reasons why it happened
He'll get 6

If he was aiming for his head it was a strange punch?
Aiming for the guts but missed lol.

If he hasn't got form he'll get 4.
Should be 6 if he's got any record at all (including fines).

MW wrote:Not saying he should get off but reasons why it happened
He'll get 6

What are the “reasons”, MW?

Already mentioned it

Just saw the Gaff hit, wow!

Will get 5 but should be 8

MW wrote:Already mentioned it

What, he aimed for his chest & Brayshaw “lowered”?
F#ck me, I’ve heard it all now.

Watch the footage mate

You could make a case for what MW is saying.

However its a longish bow to draw.

Cameron got 5 with a terrible record.
Gaff will get 5 down to 4.
Both intentional, high Impact

helicopterking wrote:Cameron got 5 with a terrible record.
Gaff will get 5 down to 4.
Both intentional, high Impact

One was in play, the other was a king hit left hook 50m off the ball

helicopterking wrote:Cameron got 5 with a terrible record.
Gaff will get 5 down to 4.
Both intentional, high Impact

The AFL of course have themselves to blame. These jumper punches that allow only a fine make it 'ok' for blokes to throw punches and get away with it. If they scrubbed them out completely then people wouldn't throw punches at all which means they wouldn't 'accidentally' hit people high.

He deserves 8 only because the comp needs to stop those stupid 'accidental' punches... but they wont.

MW wrote:Watch the footage mate

Heed your own advice.
Watch all the camera angles

Each to their own
I think i know what gaff was intending. Simpson touched on it during the presser
He hit and broke the jaw he'll get 6. Simple and not worth arguing opinions on tbh

gadj1976 wrote:

helicopterking wrote:Cameron got 5 with a terrible record.
Gaff will get 5 down to 4.
Both intentional, high Impact

The AFL of course have themselves to blame. These jumper punches that allow only a fine make it 'ok' for blokes to throw punches and get away with it. If they scrubbed them out completely then people wouldn't throw punches at all which means they wouldn't 'accidentally' hit people high.

He deserves 8 only because the comp needs to stop those stupid 'accidental' punches... but they wont.

He’s getting 6 plus for this. He has king hit a bloke 50 metres away from play. I’m sure Gaff is a decent human being but he’s made a monumental mistake and should pay for it. He’s broken the kids jaw and shattered 4 of his teeth. He deserves 6 as a minimum for this as it is truly a terrible act.

Yep well he's done. Simply as that we now have to plan fokr the rest of the season without him.

No idea what he was doing or intending to do.



Sent from my SM-A530F using Tapatalk

Silly boy. That's all u can say really

Gaff then kicks a goal late on and is mobbed by team mates like it’s his first goal on debut.

Robbo saying there should be police action

I agree. Anything intentional and off the ball leaves you wide open for that avenue imo

Nah, what’s on the ground stays on the ground

I haven't heard one WCE supporter say Brayshaw is soft.
If they applauded Gaff after a goal I dare say they didn't see the footage of the hit considering they were at the game not watching on TV but if they did and still cheered him, then that is disgraceful