Match Review Panel

[The Sleeping Giant]

Brisbane Lions Raines
Last week he cleaned up Gary Coast Ablett
This week Geelong Selwood

No further comment

Selwood deserved it

Bullshit. Raines had been picking him off all night.

regards,

REB

Selwood would be highly embarrassed by that. Smacks someone in the chops, and gets knocked the **** out.

What was I saying aboult Selwood's rep?

[goraw]

haha just saw the incident on 7. fair hit by raines. reactive punch though will get him games

[The Sleeping Giant]

Of he will get games.

[goraw]

my point is he doesnt deserve to

[The Sleeping Giant]

They both deserve games.

[goraw]

thats what shits me though, punch for a punch, but the starter should get games where the retaliater shoudnt get any, only my opinion. its like some prick breaks in while ur asleep, but if u hit him,its ur fault

[mal]

Ive seen BL play the last 2 weeks
On several occasions Raines has tackled players vigorously just b4, just after, or as they dispose of the ball
Im thinking he must be instructed to target opposition players in this manner ?
He just happens to do it often enough against 2 of the games greats in Selwood and Gary Coastblett in those games

If the tribunal people watch both of these games they will see this pattern of this 'target' tackling

[goraw]

so there is now a market for snipers in the game? recruit 4 of them so u have 1 per game?or are we going over the top and going soft?

its 1 way or the other?

[bloods08]

Raines offered a week but Selwood gets off.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/ ... fault.aspx

[LMA]

Raines offered a week but Selwood gets off.

http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/ ... fault.aspx

So he should, barely a love tap.

[The Sleeping Giant]

So you can punch someone, as long as you hit like a sheila.

[tigerland09]

Justin Westhoff has been offered a $900 fine from the AFL Match Review Panel for an obscene gesture at fans during Sunday's Showdown at AAMI Stadium

[howzat]

walker got off his slide tackle awell?????

[LMA]

So you can punch someone, as long as you hit like a sheila.

Don't know if I'd call that a punch, but whatever it was there was no force behind it hence why he got off.

[brod]

So you can punch someone, as long as you hit like a sheila.

Don't know if I'd call that a punch, but whatever it was there was no force behind it hence why he got off.

Contact to the head and behind play....

[JK]

walker got off his slide tackle awell?????

Very lucky

[LMA]

So you can punch someone, as long as you hit like a sheila.

Don't know if I'd call that a punch, but whatever it was there was no force behind it hence why he got off.

Contact to the head and behind play....

Yeah so is a pat on the head or a scruff up of the hair congratulating someone, about the same amount of force and intent. If it wasn't Selwood people woudn't give a toss, just like Judd they both have a following of Haters

[Johno6]

The MRP really does boggle the mind.
i cannot believe walker and sellwood both got off

[Footy Smart]

Yeah when i first saw the Walker incident i thought he would get 2 weeks. Another angle shows while he slides in his boot/shin makes only mininal contact..... reckless never the less and couple of inches either way and he is in real trouble as would the other player!

[saintal]

Selwood very lucky.