All Australian Team

[Turbo]

Giving positions for the all Australian team is crap anyway. How many players are actually placed in their correct position? Should be simply a team named as the best players in the comp

[Spargo]

Oh and havnt got time to check out Buddy or Pav, but i do have a vague recollection Of Buddy kicking 13 in one match against another top 8 side

Very vague obviously Buddy kicked 13 in round 9 v North - "Oh" who were at the time 11th on the ladder!! But let's not let the facts get in the way of talking bullshit. Stats don't lie do they??

[daysofourlives]

Oh and havnt got time to check out Buddy or Pav, but i do have a vague recollection Of Buddy kicking 13 in one match against another top 8 side

Very vague obviously Buddy kicked 13 in round 9 v North - "Oh" who were at the time 11th on the ladder!! But let's not let the facts get in the way of talking bullshit. Stats don't lie do they??

I notice you gave no comment on Petrie's stats, 2 contested marks and 1 goal per game against the Top 8 sides, really does make it very laughable that Norf supporters think he should be AA. Those of us without blue and white eyes no he is simply carp, even against shoenmakers he only kicked 1

[Jim05]

Oh and havnt got time to check out Buddy or Pav, but i do have a vague recollection Of Buddy kicking 13 in one match against another top 8 side

Very vague obviously Buddy kicked 13 in round 9 v North - "Oh" who were at the time 11th on the ladder!! But let's not let the facts get in the way of talking bullshit. Stats don't lie do they??

I notice you gave no comment on Petrie's stats, 2 contested marks and 1 goal per game against the Top 8 sides, really does make it very laughable that Norf supporters think he should be AA. Those of us without blue and white eyes no he is simply carp, even against shoenmakers he only kicked 1

Petrie couldnt get a kick on Fletcher and a crap Bombers side 2 weeks ago.
My 14yo son could kick goals against our flimsy defense

[Spargo]

Oh and havnt got time to check out Buddy or Pav, but i do have a vague recollection Of Buddy kicking 13 in one match against another top 8 side

Very vague obviously Buddy kicked 13 in round 9 v North - "Oh" who were at the time 11th on the ladder!! But let's not let the facts get in the way of talking bullshit. Stats don't lie do they??

I notice you gave no comment on Petrie's stats, 2 contested marks and 1 goal per game against the Top 8 sides, really does make it very laughable that Norf supporters think he should be AA. Those of us without blue and white eyes no he is simply carp, even against shoenmakers he only kicked 1

I don't doubt Petrie's stats against "top 8" sides that you've put forward and I never stated he was "AA", however if you make a call which is full of shit and obviously not RESEARCHED then expect someone (no matter what colour eyes they have) to bring it to attention. Your opinion on Petrie's talent is up to you, and how many he kicked on your full back is in the record books for all to see, no denying that - but maybe, as you stated earlier you should find the time to "check out" the facts.

[Spargo]

Oh and havnt got time to check out Buddy or Pav, but i do have a vague recollection Of Buddy kicking 13 in one match against another top 8 side

Very vague obviously Buddy kicked 13 in round 9 v North - "Oh" who were at the time 11th on the ladder!! But let's not let the facts get in the way of talking bullshit. Stats don't lie do they??

I notice you gave no comment on Petrie's stats, 2 contested marks and 1 goal per game against the Top 8 sides, really does make it very laughable that Norf supporters think he should be AA. Those of us without blue and white eyes no he is simply carp, even against shoenmakers he only kicked 1

Petrie couldnt get a kick on Fletcher and a crap Bombers side 2 weeks ago.
My 14yo son could kick goals against our flimsy defense

Well then maybe we should delist Dish and draft your son
Come on Jim, read my earlier posts.

[Media Park]

Well the stats (the important ones anyway) say that Petrie is a flat track bully.

[daysofourlives]

How did Petrie go today against another finalist?

[Rik E Boy]

How did Petrie go today against another finalist?

OUCH!

regards,

REB

[JK]

FB: J.Gibson D.Glass L.McPharlin
HB: G.Birchall T.Richards B.Deledio
C: L.Jetta J.Watson T.Cotchin
HF: P.Dangerfield T.Hawkins G.Ablett
FF: S.Milne M.Pavlich D.Beams
Foll: D.Cox S.Thompson J.Kennedy
Int: S.Jacobs S.Mitchell D.Swan K.Jack

Would imagine I've forgotten someone

[valleys07]

FB: J.Gibson D.Glass D.Talia
HB: G.Birchall T.Richards B.Reilly
C: D.Beams J.Watson J.Kennedy
HF: P.Dangerfield M.Pavlich G.Ablett
FF: S.Milne L.Franklin L.Jetta
Foll: D.Cox S.Thompson D.Swan
Int: S.Jacobs M.Boyd T.Cotchin B.Deledio

Unlucky: Stevie J, Pendlebury, Waters, Mitchell, Griffin, Sidebottom, Scotland, Swallow, Petrie, Selwood

Sidebottoms AA chances were effectively over when he was picked in my supercoach team!

[Lightning McQueen]

FB: J.Gibson D.Glass L.McPharlin
HB: G.Birchall T.Richards B.Deledio
C: L.Jetta J.Watson T.Cotchin
HF: P.Dangerfield T.Hawkins G.Ablett
FF: S.Milne M.Pavlich D.Beams
Foll: D.Cox S.Thompson J.Kennedy
Int: S.Jacobs S.Mitchell D.Swan K.Jack

Would imagine I've forgotten someone

Same as mine, but different.

[JK]

FB: J.Gibson D.Glass L.McPharlin
HB: G.Birchall T.Richards B.Deledio
C: L.Jetta J.Watson T.Cotchin
HF: P.Dangerfield T.Hawkins G.Ablett
FF: S.Milne M.Pavlich D.Beams
Foll: D.Cox S.Thompson J.Kennedy
Int: S.Jacobs S.Mitchell D.Swan K.Jack

Would imagine I've forgotten someone

Same as mine, but different.

Always thought you were an astute judge mate

BTW, almost left Jacobs out for Maric, was a tough call.

[MAY-Z]

FB: J.Gibson D.Glass L.McPharlin
HB: G.Birchall T.Richards B.Deledio
C: L.Jetta J.Watson T.Cotchin
HF: P.Dangerfield T.Hawkins G.Ablett
FF: S.Milne M.Pavlich D.Beams
Foll: D.Cox S.Thompson J.Kennedy
Int: S.Jacobs S.Mitchell D.Swan K.Jack

Would imagine I've forgotten someone

Same as mine, but different.

Always thought you were an astute judge mate

BTW, almost left Jacobs out for Maric, was a tough call.

why does everyone have lewis jetta in their team? was a gund for about 8 weeks in teh middle of the season but as soon as he has received the tag he has done very little at all

[JK]

why does everyone have lewis jetta in their team? was a gund for about 8 weeks in teh middle of the season but as soon as he has received the tag he has done very little at all

Fair question. I found it harder to pick him than I would have 2 months ago, but still think he's been damaging enough over the course of the season, even if his output has been a bit lower in recent weeks.

[Lightning McQueen]

why does everyone have lewis jetta in their team? was a gund for about 8 weeks in teh middle of the season but as soon as he has received the tag he has done very little at all

I didn't because I don't like his hair............oh and I thought there were other more consistent players for the whole season.

[Lightning McQueen]

Not a lot of support for Pendles or Boyd, I've been impressed with Grimes and noticed I've been a lone soldier in the dept aswell, oh well.

[Lightning McQueen]

B Enright Richards Scarlett
HB Waters McPharlin Birchall
C Jetta Ablett Crowley
HF Chapman Pavlich Beams
FF Milne Hawkins Cox
Ruck Maric Swallow Swan

Int. Dangerfield Cotchin Deledio Pendlebury

I tried to pick a team that could actually go out on the field and play a game. Not having 6 rebounding defenders and having 8 midfielders.

Enright – I couldn’t think of a small defender
Crowley – Every team needs a good tagger


Probably heaps unlucky but I did this in 5 minutes

No Jurrah or Staker

[daysofourlives]

Why does every one pick Hawkins? He was fairly ordinary until he kicked the goal after the siren against the Hawks 5 weeks ago.
Have i missed something?

By the way Im being serious not just cos he's from Geelong

[Lightning McQueen]

Why does every one pick Hawkins? He was fairly ordinary until he kicked the goal after the siren against the Hawks 5 weeks ago.
Have i missed something?

By the way Im being serious not just cos he's from Geelong

I didn't pick him but he is 3rd on the goalkicker's list and he is becoming one of the best pack marks in the game.