NAB Cup LIVE

[mighty_tiger_79]

Stevie J given a 1 week suspension for belting Ballantyne

thats if he accepts it!

oh well he only misses the hawks game - thats pencilled in as a win anyway

[Dogmatic]

Hurley got off for hitting Cooney

Sensible decision.

Clearly was aiming for Cooney's shoulder and when contact was made with the head, made an apology to Cooney.

These sorts of incidents shouldn't even register with the tribunal. Was quite clear that it was accidental contact and the fact that Cooney was in no way effected from the incident and infact wanted to remonstrate, shows there was nothing in it.

Wouldn't that be the reason it should be looked at as it was off the ball?

[valleys07]

Yeah I would agree it was late, but the AFL needs to make a stand on what is malicious and what allows the play(er) to continue. If Hurley did some real damage to Cooney then the answer is simple, however if it was a mis-timed bump that has low impact on a player, id say let it go.

Hurley however, can count himself lucky that he just clipped Cooney.

[Dogmatic]

Yeah I would agree it was late, but the AFL needs to make a stand on what is malicious and what allows the play(er) to continue. If Hurley did some real damage to Cooney then the answer is simple, however if it was a mis-timed bump that has low impact on a player, id say let it go.

Hurley however, can count himself lucky that he just clipped Cooney.

A bump is not a loose forearm aimed at the head. You might want to review the footage.

[valleys07]

Forearm, Elbow, Bicep, Tricep, Wrist, Fingernail, arm hair.......who cares what was aimed at Cooney, simple fact is he hardly touched him.

The point im trying to make is Hurley wasnt suspended and rightfully so as the contact was low impact. Call the act what you like Dogmatic, bump, strike, whatever......low contact was made, Hurley is playing next week.

Play on.

[Psyber]

You can listen to the radio on the INTERNET

Not at the rate it chews through my rather expensive Tesltra Mobile Internet service which is all I have over here in Bunbury, WA. (I do use it at home.)

[the joker]

They said that Scarlett was selfish last year. Well Stevie J is worst, it's a scratch match and he misses the 80,000 crowd of round one now. He has now been suspended in his last 2 games for stupidity. His team mates would be furious. But it was The little wanker so it's funny

[UK Fan]

They said that Scarlett was selfish last year. Well Stevie J is worst, it's a scratch match and he misses the 80,000 crowd of round one now. He has now been suspended in his last 2 games for stupidity. His team mates would be furious. But it was The little wanker so it's funny

Better than Steven Trigg I guess

[the joker]

They said that Scarlett was selfish last year. Well Stevie J is worst, it's a scratch match and he misses the 80,000 crowd of round one now. He has now been suspended in his last 2 games for stupidity. His team mates would be furious. But it was The little wanker so it's funny

Better than Steven Trigg I guess

I can't see where their connected

[UK Fan]

They said that Scarlett was selfish last year. Well Stevie J is worst, it's a scratch match and he misses the 80,000 crowd of round one now. He has now been suspended in his last 2 games for stupidity. His team mates would be furious. But it was The little wanker so it's funny

Better than Steven Trigg I guess

I can't see where their connected

I thought trigg was currently also suspended ???

[mighty_tiger_79]

and selfish!

[Booney]

They said that Scarlett was selfish last year. Well Stevie J is worst, it's a scratch match and he misses the 80,000 crowd of round one now. He has now been suspended in his last 2 games for stupidity. His team mates would be furious. But it was The little wanker so it's funny

Better than Steven Trigg I guess

I can't see where their connected

Not the only one.

[RustyCage]

Ben Jacobs has started well at his new club

[RustyCage]

we can lock Jesse Hogan into our 2014 Supercoach teams!

[RustyCage]

GAME ONE:
Melbourne: 0.2.2.14
North Melbourne: 1.2.2.23

SUPER GOALS:
North Melbourne: Ben Jacobs 1

GOALS:
Melbourne: Jesse Hogan 1, Jack Watts
North Melbourne: Lachie Hansen 1, Lindsay Thomas 1

LEADING DISPOSALS:
Melbourne: Nathan Jones 9, Lynden Dunn 4, Jack Viney 3
North Melbourne: Sam Wright 8, Andrew Swallow 7, Will Sierakowski 6

[RustyCage]

North Melbourne hang on by 2 points in game one. Rich v Melb in game 2

[RustyCage]

GAME ONE:
Melbourne: 0.5.6.36
North Melbourne: 1.4.5.38

SUPER GOALS:
North Melbourne: Ben Jacobs 1

GOALS:
Melbourne: Jeremy Howe 2, Jesse Hogan 1, Jack Watts 1, Dean Kent 1
North Melbourne: Lachie Hansen 1, Lindsay Thomas 1, Robbie Tarrant 1, Drew Petrie 1

LEADING DISPOSALS:
Melbourne: Nathan Jones 14, Jordie McKenzie 8, Lynden Dunn 6, Jeremy Howe 6, David Rodan 6, Dean Kent 6, Dan Nicholson 6
North Melbourne: Sam Wright 12, Andrew Swallow 12, Scott Thompson 10, Shaun Atley 10, Ben Jacobs 10, Scott McMahon 10

[dedja]

WTF, have we time-warped to the 80's with the head shaves???

[dedja]

Ding, ding ... and Vickery's off!

[RustyCage]

GAME TWO:
Melbourne: 0.2.3.15
Richmond: 1.2.9.30

SUPER GOALS:
Richmond: Bachar Houli 1

GOALS:
Melbourne: Jack Watts 1, Jimmy Toumpas 1
Richmond: Jack Riewoldt 1, Tyrone Vickery 1

LEADING DISPOSALS:
Melbourne: Joel MacDonald 12, Jack Watts 8, Jimmy Toumpas 8, Nathan Jones 8, Jack Grimes 7
Richmond: Brett Deledio 12, Dustin Martin 11, Bachar Houli 10, Brandon Ellis 9,

INJURIES:
Melbourne: Frawley (cut head, concussion)