Page 31 of 55
Re: Port Adelaide 2023
Posted:
Mon Jul 17, 2023 3:05 pmby MW
David Brent wrote:Would Port look at Grundy next year if they only had to trade say a 3rd rounder & Dees/Pies continue to pay the majority of his salary?
Whilst the premiership window appears to be open I don't think its the worst move? Thoughts?
Do each Port player and coach get a daily BJ with this deal also? Fair dinkum...
Re: Port Adelaide 2023
Posted:
Mon Jul 17, 2023 4:23 pmby wenchbarwer
David Brent wrote:Would Port look at Grundy next year if they only had to trade say a 3rd rounder & Dees/Pies continue to pay the majority of his salary?
Whilst the premiership window appears to be open I don't think its the worst move? Thoughts?
If Melb/Coll are paying most of Grundy's pay packet, then Port need to offer something serious. Only way you could trade a 3rd would be to take on his salary.
Re: Port Adelaide 2023
Posted:
Mon Jul 17, 2023 4:31 pmby Armchair expert
Was traded for pick 27 last year
if Port stay 2nd their first pick this season is number 37
Re: Port Adelaide 2023
Posted:
Thu Jul 20, 2023 3:50 pmby The Bedge
Did I miss the review?
Re: Port Adelaide 2023
Posted:
Mon Jul 24, 2023 6:55 pmby mal
Heres my review Bedgie
PA has won something like 13 of the last 14 games
The game they lost[to CA] was the game JHF didnt play in
Re: Port Adelaide 2023
Posted:
Thu Jul 27, 2023 8:40 amby MW
Reports Richmond are into Josh Carr for their head coach position.
Re: Port Adelaide 2023
Posted:
Thu Jul 27, 2023 8:49 amby woodublieve12
MW wrote:Reports Richmond are into Josh Carr for their head coach position.
Well he's got experience being the head coach at port... Interesting to see how Ken goes if Carr leaves.
Re: Port Adelaide 2023
Posted:
Thu Jul 27, 2023 3:03 pmby Booney
David Brent wrote:Would Port look at Grundy next year if they only had to trade say a 3rd rounder & Dees/Pies continue to pay the majority of his salary?
Whilst the premiership window appears to be open I don't think its the worst move? Thoughts?
No.
The agreement for payment is only between Collingwood and Melbourne. If Melbourne look to move him on Collingwood are not required to pay him anything more. So Melbourne now have the 4 remaining years and $900k per year to pay Grundy. If Port can get Melbourne to agree to paying $350-400k per year and Port pay $650-700k per year I would still be no. He turns 30 early 2024 and he'd be nearly 34 at the end of the deal.
If we were to look at him we'd have to let Lycett and Hayes go, we'd then be going with Grundy, Finlayson/Dixon and Visentini as the only back up ( I think Teakle will be delisted ) unless we keep Teakle. Visentini then see's no spot for him for 3-4 years.
It's a no from me.
Re: Port Adelaide 2023
Posted:
Thu Jul 27, 2023 3:14 pmby MW
Booney wrote:David Brent wrote:Would Port look at Grundy next year if they only had to trade say a 3rd rounder & Dees/Pies continue to pay the majority of his salary?
Whilst the premiership window appears to be open I don't think its the worst move? Thoughts?
No.
The agreement for payment is only between Collingwood and Melbourne. If Melbourne look to move him on Collingwood are not required to pay him anything more. So Melbourne now have the 4 remaining years and $900k per year to pay Grundy. If Port can get Melbourne to agree to paying $350-400k per year and Port pay $650-700k per year I would still be no. He turns 30 early 2024 and he'd be nearly 34 at the end of the deal.
If we were to look at him we'd have to let Lycett and Hayes go, we'd then be going with Grundy, Finlayson/Dixon and Visentini as the only back up ( I think Teakle will be delisted ) unless we keep Teakle. Visentini then see's no spot for him for 3-4 years.
It's a no from me.
I get all that for a side outside the 8 who won't contend in the next 2-3 years, but for Port's window I think you go for him.
Re: Port Adelaide 2023
Posted:
Thu Jul 27, 2023 3:27 pmby Booney
Absolutely take that into account, if his deal was 2 years, maybe 3 I'd be in but given it's 4 and the money would be at the upper end of any of our player deals along with finding some draft / trade capital, massive investment when you have to ask is he still capable of being AA or leading a side to a GF?
Lots of risk involved, fair bit of reward if it pays off. It's a no from me with all things considered.
Having typed all that, I wouldn't be surprised if we are right up to our necks in a deal for him.
Re: Port Adelaide 2023
Posted:
Thu Jul 27, 2023 4:12 pmby David Brent
Booney wrote:David Brent wrote:Would Port look at Grundy next year if they only had to trade say a 3rd rounder & Dees/Pies continue to pay the majority of his salary?
Whilst the premiership window appears to be open I don't think its the worst move? Thoughts?
No.
The agreement for payment is only between Collingwood and Melbourne. If Melbourne look to move him on Collingwood are not required to pay him anything more. So Melbourne now have the 4 remaining years and $900k per year to pay Grundy. If Port can get Melbourne to agree to paying $350-400k per year and Port pay $650-700k per year I would still be no. He turns 30 early 2024 and he'd be nearly 34 at the end of the deal.
If we were to look at him we'd have to let Lycett and Hayes go, we'd then be going with Grundy, Finlayson/Dixon and Visentini as the only back up ( I think Teakle will be delisted ) unless we keep Teakle. Visentini then see's no spot for him for 3-4 years.
It's a no from me.
Yep fair analysis, when I posted the question I wasn't aware the Collingwood part of the deal didn't carry over, which as you explained means you pay more $$$ for him.
Re: Port Adelaide 2023
Posted:
Thu Jul 27, 2023 4:20 pmby Booney
If we got him for > $500k then I'd be a yes.
We need money in our cap for the up coming deals :
Name / Final year of deal
Farrell 2023
Duursma, Drew, Marshall, Lord, Jones, Finlayson, Rozee, Aliir 2024
Butters, Bergman, Powell-Pepper 2025
All of whom are long term keepers.
Re: Port Adelaide 2023
Posted:
Sun Jul 30, 2023 12:16 amby jackpot jim
Sack Hinkley FFS
Re: Port Adelaide 2023
Posted:
Sun Jul 30, 2023 12:51 amby Vamos
jackpot jim wrote:Sack Hinkley FFS
Yep, untenable. Unleash Warren, hopefully it has the same effect.
Re: Port Adelaide 2023
Posted:
Sun Jul 30, 2023 1:02 amby Vamos
Shopping List
1 x Key Backman
1 x Ruckman
*No EFA's allowed
Re: Port Adelaide 2023
Posted:
Sun Jul 30, 2023 2:52 amby mighty hounds
LMA wrote:Shopping List
1 x Key Backman
1 x Ruckman
*No EFA's allowed
Re: Port Adelaide 2023
Posted:
Sun Jul 30, 2023 8:53 amby Vamos
mighty hounds wrote:LMA wrote:Shopping List
1 x Key Backman
1 x Ruckman
*No EFA's allowed
Nah, he got sacked after the 2020 QF for the use of a loser emoji, yeah that's right an emoji.
Re: Port Adelaide 2023
Posted:
Sun Jul 30, 2023 12:35 pmby Jase
Might need a new Doctor as well
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Re: Port Adelaide 2023
Posted:
Sun Jul 30, 2023 1:02 pmby stan
Jase wrote:Might need a new Doctor as well
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Surely they are getting a please explain from the AFL.
Re: Port Adelaide 2023
Posted:
Sun Jul 30, 2023 7:39 pmby mighty_tiger_79
stan wrote:Jase wrote:Might need a new Doctor as well
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Surely they are getting a please explain from the AFL.
Might be a bit more than that