SA Footy

Crow in's and out

In Jacky,Dangerfield,Maric,Campbell,

Out Jericho and Massie

Goooooooooooooooooooooooooooo Buddy....kick a bag, pity Massie aint playing

Hawthorn to win easily.....

Tipped Hawks

This game won't be easy for either side.

It will be harder for the Crows, coming off a tough win, injury concerns.

Hawthorn have a few players to come back; Crawford, Williams and a few more.....

hearts on fire wrote:It will be harder for the Crows, coming off a tough win, injury concerns.

Hawthorn have a few players to come back; Crawford, Williams and a few more.....

Who are the few more??

Josh Kennedy and Tim Clarke.

This is Kennedy's first game and Clarke is coming back from a calf injury.

Clarke is a handy player but Kennedy is playing his first game after being selected at number 40 in the 2006 NAB AFL draft.

Hawthorn Line-up:

B: Brown, Gilham, Guerra
HB: Ladson, Murphy, Birchall
C: Young, Mitchell, Bateman
HF: Crawford, Franklin, Boyle
F: Rioli, Roughead, Osborne
FOLL: Taylor, Sewell, Hodge
I/C from Campbell, Clarke, Ellis, Kennedy, Stokes, Tuck, Williams

IN: Crawford, Williams, Kennedy, Clarke
OUT: Lewis (suspended)

hearts on fire wrote:Josh Kennedy and Tim Clarke.

This is Kennedy's first game and Clarke is coming back from a calf injury.

Clarke is a handy player but Kennedy is playing his first game after being selected at number 40 in the 2006 NAB AFL draft.

Two guys who are not in Hawthorns best 22 hardly qualify as the side having "a few more to come back".

rod_rooster wrote:

hearts on fire wrote:Josh Kennedy and Tim Clarke.

This is Kennedy's first game and Clarke is coming back from a calf injury.

Clarke is a handy player but Kennedy is playing his first game after being selected at number 40 in the 2006 NAB AFL draft.

Two guys who are not in Hawthorns best 22 hardly qualify as the side having "a few more to come back".

i reckon Tim Clarke would be in their best 22, he is a very good hard running player.

hearts on fire wrote:

rod_rooster wrote:

hearts on fire wrote:Josh Kennedy and Tim Clarke.

This is Kennedy's first game and Clarke is coming back from a calf injury.

Clarke is a handy player but Kennedy is playing his first game after being selected at number 40 in the 2006 NAB AFL draft.

Two guys who are not in Hawthorns best 22 hardly qualify as the side having "a few more to come back".

i reckon Tim Clarke would be in their best 22, he is a very good hard running player.

Tim Clarke is not in the best 22. Not even close.

Don't the Crows like playing on this oval...?

rod_rooster wrote:

hearts on fire wrote:

rod_rooster wrote:

hearts on fire wrote:Josh Kennedy and Tim Clarke.

This is Kennedy's first game and Clarke is coming back from a calf injury.

Clarke is a handy player but Kennedy is playing his first game after being selected at number 40 in the 2006 NAB AFL draft.

Two guys who are not in Hawthorns best 22 hardly qualify as the side having "a few more to come back".

i reckon Tim Clarke would be in their best 22, he is a very good hard running player.

Tim Clarke is not in the best 22. Not even close.

Tim Clarke would walk into Hawthorn and get a game.

You would be surprised of how good he actually is.

hearts on fire wrote:Tim Clarke would walk into Hawthorn and get a game.

You would be surprised of how good he actually is.

Ummmm no. I am a Hawthorn supporter so i have a pretty informed opinion and he is not in our best 22.

rod_rooster wrote:

hearts on fire wrote:Tim Clarke would walk into Hawthorn and get a game.

You would be surprised of how good he actually is.

Ummmm no. I am a Hawthorn supporter so i have a pretty informed opinion and he is not in our best 22.

okay, thats your opinion.

but my opinion is that he deserves to be in that 22 and is good enough to be in it.

only time will tell on his performances.....

Heard a comment from the Victorian media the other day saying the Crows are the most competative side in the AFL. Meaning even on a bad day you rarely walk away with a big win. Interesting point of view I thought. I think the Crows can win, but I would rate the hawks a better chance. Tough draw for the crows in the first few rounds.If they go 3-1 it would be a great start. On paper they would just about have the hardest first 4 weeks in the competition.

hearts on fire wrote:

rod_rooster wrote:

hearts on fire wrote:Tim Clarke would walk into Hawthorn and get a game.

You would be surprised of how good he actually is.

Ummmm no. I am a Hawthorn supporter so i have a pretty informed opinion and he is not in our best 22.

okay, thats your opinion.

but my opinion is that he deserves to be in that 22 and is good enough to be in it.

only time will tell on his performances.....

Clearly the opinion of the coaching staff at Hawthorn as well given he has yet to play this year.

rod_rooster wrote:

hearts on fire wrote:

rod_rooster wrote:

hearts on fire wrote:Tim Clarke would walk into Hawthorn and get a game.

You would be surprised of how good he actually is.

Ummmm no. I am a Hawthorn supporter so i have a pretty informed opinion and he is not in our best 22.

okay, thats your opinion.

but my opinion is that he deserves to be in that 22 and is good enough to be in it.

only time will tell on his performances.....

Clearly the opinion of the coaching staff at Hawthorn as well given he has yet to play this year.

he played round 1 against Melbourne mate.....

that just shows how much you know about Hawthorn and Tim Clarke.....

Whoops, right you are. He did play round one. We had a lot of players missing then though.

Look we will have to agree to disagree about him. You clearly rate him and i don't. I am not saying he is a dud just that he is not in the best 22 at the club.