SA Footy

From previous chat - list your top 10 AFL Footballers ( I thought 10 players would make more ponit of difference than 5 )

1 C.Judd
2 W.Tredrea
3 J.Brown
4 B.Cousins
5 N.Dal-santo
6 M.Pavlich
7 S.West
8 M.Riccuito
9 N.Brown
10 B.Hall

Unable to seperate my top 5,with out predjudice.
Tredrea
Cousins
McLeod
Voss
Harvey

then,in no particlar order

Judd
Reiwoldt
J.Brown
Ruccuito
Pavlich

with apologies to C.Cornes,Pavlich,Del Santo.

When actually fit enough to take the field .. And not neccesarily in order ..

C. Judd
W. Tredrea
J. Brown
S. West
R. Harvey
N. Buckley
N. Brown
J. Hird
S. Black
D. Cox

With apologies in particular to Cousins, Hall, Riewoldt, Pavlich, Dal Santo, Ricciutio, Ling, Hodge, Scarlett

Actually bugger it, even a Top 10's too difficult!!

Here are my top 10, in no particular order:

M. Pavlich
P. Everitt
W. Tredrea
C. Judd
S. West
N. Brown
J. Brown
B. Hall
J. Hird
N. Riewoldt

These 10 are based on match-winning and match-turning capabilities. Each of these guys can turn a game on its head with their skills and do so frequently. Obviously there are probably 4 or 5 other players in the AFL that could do the same, but these 10 are the best.

My top ten in no order

C Ling
C Judd
J Brown
M Pavlich
S West
A McLeod
L Darcy
B Hall
M Ruccuito
G Ablett Jr.

J.Brown
N.Brown
M.Ricciuto
C.Judd
S.Crawford
S.West
W.Tredrea
N.Riewoldt
A.Goodes
B.Cousins

Would love to include Hird. What he can still do and the influence he still has, even in shorter time on ground roles, I find amazing.

Strawb07 wrote:My top ten in no order

C Ling
C Judd
J Brown
M Pavlich
S West
A McLeod
L Darcy
B Hall
M Ruccuito
G Ablett Jr.

C Ling??????????????????????????????????
G Ablett Jr??????????????????????????????

LMAO - Give me a break, pick the Cats fan?

Booney wrote:Unable to seperate my top 5,with out predjudice.
Tredrea
Cousins
McLeod
Voss
Harvey

then,in no particlar order

Judd
Reiwoldt
J.Brown
Ruccuito
Pavlich

with apologies to C.Cornes,Pavlich,Del Santo.

Ahhh good to see a man who appreciates talent - Brent Harvey in your top 5....love it

My top 10 going in to 2006 are

1. JUDD
2. J BROWN
3. PAVLICH
4. ROO
5. TREDREA
6. VOSS
7. COUSINS
8. WEST
9. DAL SANTO
10. LLYOD

McCleod, unlucky, would not suprise if he has a personal best season, Goodwin at Brownlow odds 35/1 worth a dollar or two based on last years polling

N Brown, would have in top 10 if fully fit and confident, I think he is still 12 months away from playing best footy, while Buckly I am not confident he will stand up.

Darcy would be the best big man in the comp if fit, so was unable to consider, while luke ball and mitchell are not that far away

Judd
Cousins
Pavlich
Brown
Voss
Everitt
Harvey
Hird
Goodes
Ricciuto

If Riewoldt and Tredrea's goal kicking improves this year they would be in. Appologies to many.
Best three coaches would be.......

Paul Roos
Neil Craig
Leigh Matthews

Dutchy wrote:

Strawb07 wrote:My top ten in no order

C Ling
C Judd
J Brown
M Pavlich
S West
A McLeod
L Darcy
B Hall
M Ruccuito
G Ablett Jr.

C Ling??????????????????????????????????
G Ablett Jr??????????????????????????????

LMAO - Give me a break, pick the Cats fan?

Well let's see yours then Double Dutch!

regards,

REB

Robert HARVEY
Warren TREDREA
Matthew SCARLETT
Jonathon BROWN
Mark RUCCUITO
Matthew PAVLICH
Ben COUSINS
Barry HALL
James HIRD
Nick RIEWOLDT

*Apologies to as many as 20 gun players in the league.

regards,

REB

Dutchy Yes i am a cats fan and when i picked my top ten i thought of those two blokes who can turn a game around.
Cameron Ling is a gun he will win a Brownlow. When ling is on fire he is awesome to watch.
Gary Ablett Jr. is another player who is like is his father in a way. Ablett can have just five minutes of brilliance and the cats could win. He is like is father a freak of a player.

Strawb07 wrote:Dutchy Yes i am a cats fan and when i picked my top ten i thought of those two blokes who can turn a game around.
Cameron Ling is a gun he will win a Brownlow. When ling is on fire he is awesome to watch.
Gary Ablett Jr. is another player who is like is his father in a way. Ablett can have just five minutes of brilliance and the cats could win. He is like is father a freak of a player.

Ling will win a Brownlow? pffft.

No doubting his ability,a good player,but Brownlows will lose their gloss if Ronald wins one.

Booney wrote:

Strawb07 wrote:Dutchy Yes i am a cats fan and when i picked my top ten i thought of those two blokes who can turn a game around.
Cameron Ling is a gun he will win a Brownlow. When ling is on fire he is awesome to watch.
Gary Ablett Jr. is another player who is like is his father in a way. Ablett can have just five minutes of brilliance and the cats could win. He is like is father a freak of a player.

Ling will win a Brownlow? pffft.

No doubting his ability,a good player,but Brownlows will lose their gloss if Ronald wins one.

Bull5hit Booney.

regards,

REB

It will REB,the Brownlow night is all about glamour and Cameron Ling is about as glamorous as spending a night in a hotel room with Michael Hutchence.

I should have left it at the pfft,not the gloss part I guess.

Is Liberatore glamerous???

Booney wrote:It will REB,the Brownlow night is all about glamour and Cameron Ling is about as glamorous as spending a night in a hotel room with Michael Hutchence.

I should have left it at the pfft,not the gloss part I guess.

Aye, this much is true but even Lingy managed to pull a glamourous accessory to last year's count, even though he was ineligible to win the award*. I email of the picture with Lingy and his stunner to my workmates entitled..'how can this happen' LOL.

regards,

REB

*he plays for Geelong and we don't have star players see.

BubblesOfBlue wrote:Is Liberatore glamerous???

I dont know it depends If garnden gnomes are glamerous !!!