SA Footy

So the 1-4 year players kicked off pre-season yesterday at the uni loop, for the standard 3k time trial. The rest of the main group returns on December 1st- departing for Dubai on the 5th.

Tom Clurey ended up taking out the time trial, ahead of Sam Colquhoun and Karl Amon. Massive effort from Sam, considering he is still on the comeback trail from a knee recon. Has done a mountain of work at the club whilst the rest of the group have been away on holidays. Will definitely challenge Impey for that small defenders role.

Who is your pre-season bolter for round 1 selection?

Plenty of talk about Karl Amon perhaps breaking into the line up next season. One to watch over the pre-season, especially if Monfries and Ryder are handed penalties, he is one i'd like to see fill that half forward role- exquisite user of the footy and a great runner.

Can we fit Clurey into this side? 190cm players with 15+ beep test results certainly dont come around every day- and our back 6 appears pretty set. Can he become a big bodied midfielder, or a forward? Or are we destined to lose a couple of promising players elsewhere, as our 22 becomes settled in pursuit of a flag?

Chat away, fellas.

B - Jonas Carlile Pittard
HB - Hartlett Trengove Broadbent
C - Cornes Ebert Polec
HF - Wingard Ryder Westhoff
F - Monfries Schulz Gray

R - Lobbe Boak Wines

Int from : White, Moore, Hombsch, Impey, Mitchell, Colquhoun, Young, O'Shea

No surprises for mine valleys, our 22 - 28 is pretty set, IMO.

And a fair assessment too.

I am just becoming increasingly sceptical, regarding the availability of Monfries and Ryder.

I personally think we will be facing the season without these 2.

Booney wrote:B - Jonas Carlile Pittard
HB - Hartlett Trengove Broadbent
C - Cornes Ebert Polec
HF - Wingard Ryder Westhoff
F - Monfries Schulz Gray

R - Lobbe Boak Wines

Int from : White, Moore, Hombsch, Impey, Mitchell, Colquhoun, Young, O'Shea

No surprises for mine valleys, our 22 - 28 is pretty set, IMO.

As usual mate, Your pretty much spot on.

There seems to be some love from the club for O'Shea although I think you've got his spot in the pecking order spot on. I really love what Hombsch give us. I hope he doesn't drop down the order, But who does he replace in that back 6??? Probably only Pittard depending on match-ups. I guess no sides plays more than 2 deep forward so Pittard's rebound off half back could be useful, Although Pittard with ball in hand I am always nervous.

I'd have my round 1 side looking slightly different- I think Jack Hombsch will be a starter in the 18 most weeks, and a midfielder starting on the pine. This wont mean much though, as rotations usually kick in before the 2 minute mark of the 1st quarter anyway!

My round 1 line up (pending possible sanctions):



B: Broadbent, Carlisle, Jonas

HB: Pittard, Trengove, Hombsch

C: Polec, Wines, Hartlett

HF: Wingard, Westhoff, Monfries

F: Gray, Schulz, Ryder

R: Lobbe, Boak, Cornes



I: Ebert, White, Neade, Young



Emeg: Moore, O’Shea

Booney wrote:B - Jonas Carlile Pittard
HB - Hartlett Trengove Broadbent
C - Cornes Ebert Polec
HF - Wingard Ryder Westhoff
F - Monfries Schulz Gray

R - Lobbe Boak Wines

Int from : White, Moore, Hombsch, Impey, Mitchell, Colquhoun, Young, O'Shea

No surprises for mine valleys, our 22 - 28 is pretty set, IMO.

Dont rate Neade Boon? Either do i

Booney wrote:B - Jonas Carlile Pittard
HB - Hartlett Trengove Broadbent
C - Cornes Ebert Polec
HF - Wingard Ryder Westhoff
F - Monfries Schulz Gray

R - Lobbe Boak Wines

Int from : White, Moore, Hombsch, Impey, Mitchell, Colquhoun, Young, O'Shea

No surprises for mine valleys, our 22 - 28 is pretty set, IMO.

maybe

daysofourlives wrote:

Booney wrote:B - Jonas Carlile Pittard
HB - Hartlett Trengove Broadbent
C - Cornes Ebert Polec
HF - Wingard Ryder Westhoff
F - Monfries Schulz Gray

R - Lobbe Boak Wines

Int from : White, Moore, Hombsch, Impey, Mitchell, Colquhoun, Young, O'Shea

No surprises for mine valleys, our 22 - 28 is pretty set, IMO.

Dont rate Neade Boon? Either do i

I forgot about him, But saying this he is just to small.

daysofourlives wrote:

Booney wrote:B - Jonas Carlile Pittard
HB - Hartlett Trengove Broadbent
C - Cornes Ebert Polec
HF - Wingard Ryder Westhoff
F - Monfries Schulz Gray

R - Lobbe Boak Wines

Int from : White, Moore, Hombsch, Impey, Mitchell, Colquhoun, Young, O'Shea

No surprises for mine valleys, our 22 - 28 is pretty set, IMO.

Dont rate Neade Boon? Either do i

I don't rate him ahead of Monfries, Wingard and Gray, no. Having said that, Gray spent more time as a mid in '14 and will spend even more there,IMO, in '15 as his fitness base increases after two full pre-seasons under Burgess after his knee.

With Boak, Hartlett, Polec and White goal kicking mids and Wingard and Monfries the bulk of their time as forwards I don't quite see room for Neade in the side.

valleys07 wrote:I'd have my round 1 side looking slightly different- I think Jack Hombsch will be a starter in the 18 most weeks, and a midfielder starting on the pine. This wont mean much though, as rotations usually kick in before the 2 minute mark of the 1st quarter anyway!

My round 1 line up (pending possible sanctions):



B: Broadbent, Carlisle, Jonas

HB: Pittard, Trengove, Hombsch

C: Polec, Wines, Hartlett

HF: Wingard, Westhoff, Monfries

F: Gray, Schulz, Ryder

R: Lobbe, Boak, Cornes



I: Ebert, White, Neade, Young



Emeg: Moore, O’Shea

Fair team that.

Paddy's debut presser in power colours

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k-yHWxtleSQ

Seems to be ALOT of pressure on Paddy Ryder.. Saying he's the missing link to winning a flag is huge!!! Has he earnt that rep??

woodublieve12 wrote:Seems to be ALOT of pressure on Paddy Ryder.. Saying he's the missing link to winning a flag is huge!!! Has he earnt that rep??

Not as much as getting a 9 year contract.

stan wrote:

woodublieve12 wrote:Seems to be ALOT of pressure on Paddy Ryder.. Saying he's the missing link to winning a flag is huge!!! Has he earnt that rep??

Not as much as getting a 9 year contract.

yep, but he earned every cent this year....

Will Paddy? time will tell...

I reckon he's a good get, but there is a massive amount of pressure on him.

woodublieve12 wrote:Seems to be ALOT of pressure on Paddy Ryder.. Saying he's the missing link to winning a flag is huge!!! Has he earnt that rep??

I'll just check, was it Keith Thomas, Ken Hinkley or Travis Boak who said he was the "missing link to Port winning a premiership", or was it a beat up headline used by mainstream media and interweb boffins?

Pretty fair team port have. Depth still an issue though, but if they get their best team on the park more often than not I think they will finish top 4

Booney wrote:

woodublieve12 wrote:Seems to be ALOT of pressure on Paddy Ryder.. Saying he's the missing link to winning a flag is huge!!! Has he earnt that rep??

I'll just check, was it Keith Thomas, Ken Hinkley or Travis Boak who said he was the "missing link to Port winning a premiership", or was it a beat up headline used by mainstream media and interweb boffins?

didn't mention port...
Media and SOME port supporters...

stan wrote:

woodublieve12 wrote:Seems to be ALOT of pressure on Paddy Ryder.. Saying he's the missing link to winning a flag is huge!!! Has he earnt that rep??

Not as much as getting a 9 year contract.

the only thing a west coast player would get 9 years is for a jail sentence...

woodublieve12 wrote:

stan wrote:

woodublieve12 wrote:Seems to be ALOT of pressure on Paddy Ryder.. Saying he's the missing link to winning a flag is huge!!! Has he earnt that rep??

Not as much as getting a 9 year contract.

the only thing a west coast player would get 9 years is for a jail sentence...

Buddy + rumours - Sshhhh.

woodublieve12 wrote:

stan wrote:

woodublieve12 wrote:Seems to be ALOT of pressure on Paddy Ryder.. Saying he's the missing link to winning a flag is huge!!! Has he earnt that rep??

Not as much as getting a 9 year contract.

the only thing a west coast player would get 9 years is for a jail sentence...

Wub, did you just replay a second time to the same comment?

You know there is an edit feature.