SA Footy

Jim05 wrote:

Armchair expert wrote:

gadj1976 wrote:SEN in Melb had a caller saying that he was linked to the club - and that Rossy and Vossy have been signed up.

Ross would implement a defensive system, something we desperately need.


Not sure what crazy Vossy would do.

Voss coach and Ross head of football department or Ross coach, Voss assistant?

Ross coach, Voss snr assistant.

Armchair expert wrote:

Jim05 wrote:

Armchair expert wrote:

gadj1976 wrote:SEN in Melb had a caller saying that he was linked to the club - and that Rossy and Vossy have been signed up.

Ross would implement a defensive system, something we desperately need.


Not sure what crazy Vossy would do.

Voss coach and Ross head of football department or Ross coach, Voss assistant?

I don't see why Voss would leave Port to be an assistant at Carlton

Succession plan?

Casboult has retired after not being offered a contract

Can't even get shafting the coach right


pathetic

Armchair expert wrote:Can't even get shafting the coach right


pathetic

extraordinarily poorly handled.

Armchair expert wrote:Can't even get shafting the coach right


pathetic

Carlton fan wrote in to SEN this morning basically saying the same thing, was along the lines of "The one thing we should be highly skilled at by now is sacking coaches and we still can't even do that properly"

Interesting meme on Facebook.

Record after 50 AFL games as senior coach

Teague 21-29-0
Hardwick 16-33-1
Clarkson 18-32-0

whufc wrote:Interesting meme on Facebook.

Record after 50 AFL games as senior coach

Teague 21-29-0
Hardwick 16-33-1
Clarkson 18-32-0

Hardwick and Clarkson were smart enough to bottom out, gain a heap of top picks, then build a squad for the next 10 years.
Teague electing to sit middle of the bottom 10ish was never going to achieve what the other two have.

It is obvious to everyone except the Carlton recruiting staff that the list is not as strong as they believe

Zac Williams played 4 good weeks in the midfield back in 2019, they expect him to be a full time mid...there is a reason gws didn't leave him there

Players I think the recruiting team overrate: Fisher, sps, Plowman (actual dud) , Setterfield (actual dud) , Docherty (get well soon), Williamsom (I don't rate him at all) plus a few others

Armchair expert wrote:It is obvious to everyone except the Carlton recruiting staff that the list is not as strong as they believe

Zac Williams played 4 good weeks in the midfield back in 2019, they expect him to be a full time mid...there is a reason gws didn't leave him there

Players I think the recruiting team overrate: Fisher, sps, Plowman (actual dud) , Setterfield (actual dud) , Docherty (get well soon), Williamsom (I don't rate him at all) plus a few others

Outside of Weitering, McKay and Walsh who on the Carlton list makes any of the top 4 sides best 22?

That's how I measure lists, would they ( any given player ) be in a top 4 side at this moment.

Saad would
CCurnow if fit
Jones would but some would disagree
Zac Williams borderline

not many more than listed

Armchair expert wrote:Saad would
CCurnow if fit
Jones would but some would disagree
Zac Williams borderline

not many more than listed

Nick Hind has had a better year than Saad and on about a quarter of his wage.
You don’t pay $800k for a running defender who refuses to defend

Armchair expert wrote:It is obvious to everyone except the Carlton recruiting staff that the list is not as strong as they believe

Zac Williams played 4 good weeks in the midfield back in 2019, they expect him to be a full time mid...there is a reason gws didn't leave him there

Players I think the recruiting team overrate: Fisher, sps, Plowman (actual dud) , Setterfield (actual dud) , Docherty (get well soon), Williamsom (I don't rate him at all) plus a few others

I'd persist with SPS maybe even change his role or something, I think he's going to have something offer personally but you probably see a lot more of him than I do

Armchair expert wrote:Saad would
CCurnow if fit
Jones would but some would disagree
Zac Williams borderline

not many more than listed

Jones - seriously underrated IMO.

JK wrote:

Armchair expert wrote:It is obvious to everyone except the Carlton recruiting staff that the list is not as strong as they believe

Zac Williams played 4 good weeks in the midfield back in 2019, they expect him to be a full time mid...there is a reason gws didn't leave him there

Players I think the recruiting team overrate: Fisher, sps, Plowman (actual dud) , Setterfield (actual dud) , Docherty (get well soon), Williamsom (I don't rate him at all) plus a few others

I'd persist with SPS maybe even change his role or something, I think he's going to have something offer personally but you probably see a lot more of him than I do

Nup, soft as butter, lazy

will hopefully be traded

Been out all day, Teague still held on today?

Dutchy wrote:Been out all day, Teague still held on today?

Teague still in
Brent Stanton gone

Sent from my SM-G781B using Tapatalk

Carlton are going to get crucified tonight on 360 and FC

They arent playing the game.

the media smell a killing and they are being made to wait....

am Bays wrote:Carlton are going to get crucified tonight on 360 and FC

They arent playing the game.

the media smell a killing and they are being made to wait....

And OTC

Sent from my SM-G781B using Tapatalk

A guy I play vets cricket with and is very well connected in footy circles told me Ross Lyon was announced to the playing group last Thursday as the new coach…