SA Footy

The argument is all over the media as to who is the best player since Carey

Judd, Voss, Ablett etc etc

My opinion - Paul Chapman (Geelong would have nothing without chappy) easily the most valuable player of the era IMO

Whats yours

marbles wrote:My opinion - Paul Chapman (Geelong would have nothing without chappy) easily the most valuable player of the era IMO

There's a difference between Best player and most valuable - sort your crap out.

For me -
Best Player: GAJ
Most Valuable: Nick Riewoldt

marbles wrote:The argument is all over the media as to who is the best player since Carey

Judd, Voss, Ablett etc etc

My opinion - Paul Chapman (Geelong would have nothing without chappy) easily the most valuable player of the era IMO

Whats yours

Are you drunk?

Pendlebury

Best: Ablett.

Most Valuable: Nick Riewoldt, closely followed by Ablett's tenure at Gold Coast.

Lightning McQueen wrote:

marbles wrote:The argument is all over the media as to who is the best player since Carey

Judd, Voss, Ablett etc etc

My opinion - Paul Chapman (Geelong would have nothing without chappy) easily the most valuable player of the era IMO

Whats yours

Are you drunk?

He'd only be four hours ahead of you then....

Ablett Jnr
Voss
Judd
Goodes
Hird/Buckley

Special mentions
R Harvey
Riccuito
Franklin
Cousins - can't stand him
Macleod
Riewoldt

Liam Jarrah

Bootsma

Mark Blake

Rik E Boy wrote:Mark Blake

x2!

And the children have arrived, end of thread

Let the kiddies play now & trash the joint

marbles wrote:And the children have arrived, end of thread

Let the kiddies play now & trash the joint

You started it with Paul Chapman.

carey wrote:

marbles wrote:And the children have arrived, end of thread

Let the kiddies play now & trash the joint

You started it with Paul Chapman.

Giving credit where credits dew... #stuartdew... Hawthorn grand final

Best players of the 2000's I highly doubt Chapmen would be in anyone's top 10!

Brett Burton.

carey wrote:Best players of the 2000's I highly doubt Chapmen would be in anyone's top 10!

Likely cos most peoples decisions are decided by media and is why no one can independently go past Judd Voss or ablett

Ball getters are great, but its the mercurial match changing footballing instincts of the most elite footballer who will go to the grave with far more ability than these glorified marathon runners

Brett burton is a good one, has abilities only most people can dream

Cirol rioli is is up there closest to the football gods, as was Paul chapman at his best

Midfielders are just super fit explosive runners who can get to the ball quicker

Abletts got a poor bruise, and now he couldn't even find a footy in a Kmart store

i would like to state I am a chapman fan....

BUT Marbles, you must be taking the piss??

Best Player- Gary Ablett

Most Valuable- Johnathon Brown

Pavlich would have to up there in the most valuable stakes too