Best team of the 21st Century

[amber_fluid]

I love Warren Tredrea, best step ladder Paul Chapman ever had.

Hey,

You started this crap...............

What crap, good to have decent footy talk

Yes all good mate.
I love good banter as much as the next bloke......

[morell]

We have all forgotten about the small forward?
Cyril, Eddie, Milne, Aker?

Can't have 6 talls up forward can we?

It's a fair criticism and is why I put Aker in there. I guess people put in KPF more because they're deemed as more important structurally.

If I were to choose I would go...

Milne just over Betts.

I'd have Cyril or Eddie first but Milne was a great player.

Milne: 574 goals
Betts: 520 goals
Cyril: 273 goals

beige_liquid: "I'll have Cyril thanks!"

[mots02]

unless the next bloke is Morell.... no one loves banter as much as Morell

[amber_fluid]

We have all forgotten about the small forward?
Cyril, Eddie, Milne, Aker?

Can't have 6 talls up forward can we?

It's a fair criticism and is why I put Aker in there. I guess people put in KPF more because they're deemed as more important structurally.

If I were to choose I would go...

Milne just over Betts.

I'd have Cyril or Eddie first but Milne was a great player.

Milne: 574 goals
Betts: 520 goals
Cyril: 273 goals

beige_liquid: "I'll have Cyril thanks!"

Digby you can't just purely use stats.
Impact in finals surely mark you higher hence why I choose Cyril.

When his career is over Eddie will have the best stats of them all.

[Wedgie]

images (19).jpg (24.67 KiB) Viewed 458 times

[morell]

Digby you can't just purely use stats.
Impact in finals surely mark you higher hence why I choose Cyril.

When his career is over Eddie will have the best stats of them all.

I'm not but it's not even close man. Cyril may very well be the better player in the end but he's got a fair whack of his career left and will need to keep delivering to be ahead of those two (and about 5 others)

[morell]

The safooty.net player rating heirachy

1) Courageousness
2) Crowd excitement
3) Premierships
4) 'Good bloke' rating
5) Daylight
6) Stats/attributes

[Wedgie]

Must admit I don't rate Rioli as high as most as he's very rarely played well against Geelong. Burgoyne on the other hand.........
Gun

[MW]

The safooty.net player rating heirachy

1) Courageousness
2) Crowd excitement
3) Premierships
4) 'Good bloke' rating
5) Daylight
6) Stats/attributes

Which stats did Tredders have over Brown?

[Corona Man]

We have all forgotten about the small forward?
Cyril, Eddie, Milne, Aker, Boomer?
One of these should go in.

Can't have 6 talls up forward can we?

Depends on the match ups.... who is this team playing against?

[Jase]

The safooty.net player rating heirachy

1) Courageousness
2) Crowd excitement
3) Premierships
4) 'Good bloke' rating
5) Daylight
6) Stats/attributes

Morell, what are your rating values?

All Australian - opinion based award
Brownlow - opinion based award
Club Champion - opinion based award
Leading Goal Kicker - qualitative
Premierships - qualitative

Not having a crack, but for you to say what you have about opinions is it somewhat hypocritical to use opinion based awards as a basis of deciding who is better...

However I'm no stat's man or really care that much, just wondering...

Sent from my F8131 using Tapatalk

[Brodlach]

The safooty.net player rating heirachy

1) Courageousness
2) Crowd excitement
3) Premierships
4) 'Good bloke' rating
5) Daylight
6) Stats/attributes

Which stats did Tredders have over Brown?

None!

[MW]

Exactly

[Corona Man]

Must admit I don't rate Rioli as high as most as he's very rarely played well against Geelong. Burgoyne on the other hand.........
Gun

It was only one passage of play in the 2008 GF, but it was a good Cyril moment. Did you miss that Wedgie?

[Wedgie]

Must admit I don't rate Rioli as high as most as he's very rarely played well against Geelong. Burgoyne on the other hand.........
Gun

It was only one passage of play in the 2008 GF, but it was a good Cyril moment. Did you miss that Wedgie?

Might have been when I was walking out!

[LaughingKookaburra]

I think you have sold Johnathon Brown so short Morrell. In my 47 years of watching footy I rate him as one of the best players I have seen. Because he played up in Brisbane too many people dismiss what he did. If he played in SA or Victoria he would be lauded as a pure champion of the game


And I don't support Brisbane

You may very well, but I would suggest that is because of a few moments of gutsy efforts, a personal liking towards a personality type/playing style - rather than an overall body of work.

Dismiss what he did? What exactly did he do? His record is really not that impressive when you factor in the teams he played in and the roles that he had.

It's a bit like people frothing over Glen Archer - who was in all reality a limited footballer. Boy he was tough though

Yeah...... I actually agree 100% with all this. Nice work Morrell, I'll get Scooter to pass on further compliments from my next visit to the Marion.

[daysofourlives]

Dont care where but Burgoyne has to be in this team

[LaughingKookaburra]

Dont care where but Burgoyne has to be in this team

He ain't better than Ricciuto or Black so he misses.

[daysofourlives]

Dont care where but Burgoyne has to be in this team

He ain't better than Ricciuto or Black so he misses.

Isnt he?? In your opinion of course

[Corona Man]

Dont care where but Burgoyne has to be in this team

He ain't better than Ricciuto or Black so he misses.

Isnt he?? In your opinion of course

Depends I guess...Black = Brownlow & Premiersips (3), Roo = Brownlow & Premiersip (1), Burgoyne = Premierships (5... I think?). All bloody good players.