To trade or to draft, that is the question.

[mighty hounds]

Meh. As it was said on a previous page. It is like asking which fat chick you want to **** first.

Whether you lose a GF by 1pt or 119, it is the ****ing pits.

Couldn’t agree more with this.

[valleys07]

Plus the 3 that are on the list remaining from 07 are walk up starters in any side

Westhoff??? Stop it.
Boak’s best footy is behind him & quite possibly so is Gray’s who turns 30 in March.

Walk up starters

Carn Spargo. Your lot carried Boomer basically to his transition into a nursing home. Wasn't producing his best football by 38, but was playing a role for the side and many North supporters were very disappointed when Scott helped him clear his locker.

Gray off of the back of AA selection is still one of the elite players of the comp, and Boak was producing very good numbers for a predominant HF rotating through the midfield. Both would start in any side.

Westy is questionable, but would start in most sides I would have thought.

[Booney]

Plus the 3 that are on the list remaining from 07 are walk up starters in any side

Westhoff??? Stop it.
Boak’s best footy is behind him & quite possibly so is Gray’s who turns 30 in March.

Walk up starters

You'll be a lonely member of the club that thinks Robbie Gray doesn't get a gig in every other AFL team.

[Jim05]

Plus the 3 that are on the list remaining from 07 are walk up starters in any side

Westhoff??? Stop it.
Boak’s best footy is behind him & quite possibly so is Gray’s who turns 30 in March.

Walk up starters

You'll be a lonely member of the club that thinks Robbie Gray doesn't get a gig in every other AFL team.

My word Gray does. Not sure about the other two

[MW]

Gray makes every side on one leg

[Booney]

Plus the 3 that are on the list remaining from 07 are walk up starters in any side

Westhoff??? Stop it.
Boak’s best footy is behind him & quite possibly so is Gray’s who turns 30 in March.

Walk up starters

You'll be a lonely member of the club that thinks Robbie Gray doesn't get a gig in every other AFL team.

My word Gray does. Not sure about the other two

I think Boak would find a spot in most if not all sides and I think Westhoff would fit into the bottom 6 or 8 sides, nobody who finished above us in '17 would require his services and to be honest I think he's about 20-25th on our list now and isn't a walk up start with us. It'll be him or Watts in the side, can't see both playing in the AFL side at the same time.

[amber_fluid]

Gray makes every side on one leg

Gray is still a gun, Boak will sit nicely on many teams benches whilst Westhoff is just plain effin useless.......... except when they play the Crows!

[bertiebeatle]

I agree with Booney, but i think we would all find that whichever list Westhoff was on, he would be played in their best 22 by the coaches due to his versatility.

I agree that Watts SHOULD likely push him out of our side especially if Marshall has a strong start to the season, but coaches love talls that have big tanks that they can throw at either end

[Dutchy]

I agree with Booney

Well you are no fun then

[Booney]

I agree with Booney

Well you are no fun then

Smart though.

[bertiebeatle]

I agree with Booney

Well you are no fun then

[mots02]

I agree with Booney

Well you are no fun then

Smart though.

S-M-R-T

[bennymacca]

Plus the 3 that are on the list remaining from 07 are walk up starters in any side

Westhoff??? Stop it.
Boak’s best footy is behind him & quite possibly so is Gray’s who turns 30 in March.

Walk up starters

all of these three would be in your top 5 best players at North

[Spargo]

Plus the 3 that are on the list remaining from 07 are walk up starters in any side

Westhoff??? Stop it.
Boak’s best footy is behind him & quite possibly so is Gray’s who turns 30 in March.

Walk up starters

all of these three would be in your top 5 best players at North

Gray would, yes - but the statement was “any side” not North.
Good try though, benny...

[bennymacca]

Westhoff would be best 22 in every side.

[amber_fluid]

Westhoff would be best 22 in every side.

Don’t agree.
He plays well against you blokes but is very ordinary against other good teams.
He’ll struggle to get a game with all their new recruits.

[am Bays]

Westhoff would be best 22 in every side.

So you're saying he would kick Lynch out of the Adelaide side? That is the role he would play? lead up fwd, swing, 3-4th target.

As other have said Grey's in every side along with Boak. Westoff wouldn't be in the best 22 of the top 10 sides, now.

[amber_fluid]

Westhoff would be best 22 in every side.

So you're saying he would kick Lynch out of the Adelaide side? That is the role he would play? lead up fwd, swing, 3-4th target.

As other have said Grey's in every side along with Boak. Westoff wouldn't be in the best 22 of the top 10 sides, now.

Nor the bottom 8 sides either.
I wouldn’t have him at Carlton.

[Jim05]

Westhoff would be best 22 in every side.

No he wouldn’t.
Will be lucky to be in Ports best 22 this year

[bennymacca]

Westhoff would be best 22 in every side.

So you're saying he would kick Lynch out of the Adelaide side? That is the role he would play? lead up fwd, swing, 3-4th target.

As other have said Grey's in every side along with Boak. Westoff wouldn't be in the best 22 of the top 10 sides, now.

Fair point, maybe not the crows, Lynch is probably the best in the comp at that role.

Would have thought Richmond, Geelong, Melbourne, Essendon, Bulldogs, St Kilda, Hawks, Collingwood Freo North Carlton Gold Coast Brisbane would be playing him. you can argue about his age etc but i still think he plays decent footy

Crows, GWS, Sydney, West Coast? maybe not.