Port Adelaide 2018

[Lightning McQueen]

It was done in February I guess.

The rating of Wines as 28th when it comes to midfielders rankings was updated two days ago.

I was referring to the "elite list" link that you initially posted.

[bennymacca]

http://www.afl.com.au/stats/player-ratings/overall-standings#position/midfielder

yep 28th best mid seems about right to me

I cant see anyone on that list ahead of him that I think is a worse player. (not taking age into account)

He's the 20th ranked midfielder, the 28th (equal) over all.

yep my bad. still, looking at that list I think he's about rightly placed - in fact looking at those below him, theres shiel crouch Merrett Duncan Yeo Sidebottom Kelly macrae Gibbs Adams Whitfield.

on second thoughts 20th overall mid is somewhat generous

still puts him in the top couple in most teams though. which commands top dollar

[Wedgie]

It was done in February I guess.

The rating of Wines as 28th when it comes to midfielders rankings was updated two days ago.

I was referring to the "elite list" link that you initially posted.

I know.
2 lots of stats (not opinions), one for current performance and one for past performance.

I think hes very good but I don't watch every minute of every AFL game so I would be more inclined to look at Champion Data analysis than my own opinion to make a definitive judgement.

It also depends on what people's definition of elite is as its a bit subjective. I think champion data takes it as top 10%.
Some might think top 5%.
Some might think top 40%.
Interesting discussion though.

[Senor Moto Gadili]

It would be good to see the rankings based purely on this season. Clearly Sloane and Zorko have carry over credits from last year. Jack Macrae and Stephen Coniglio have both had ripping seasons so far and would be right up there in rankings. I reckon Wines is in the right place at about number 20 and there is nothing wrong with that.

[bennymacca]

It would be good to see the rankings based purely on this season. Clearly Sloane and Zorko have carry over credits from last year. Jack Macrae and Stephen Coniglio have both had ripping seasons so far and would be right up there in rankings. I reckon Wines is in the right place at about number 20 and there is nothing wrong with that.

yeah those rankings are on their past 40 games, and a sliding weighting, so more recent games are weighted higher

I think theres also some sort of holding provision if you miss games, like Sloane.

The afl player ratings twitter account puts out all sorts of stats,

this one is for ratings for this year

https://twitter.com/AFLPlayerRating?ref ... r%5Eauthor


there is one for biggest overall rise this year

https://twitter.com/AFLPlayerRating/sta ... 7373590529

[bertiebeatle]

Sam Hayes did an ACL at training today. Makes Lycett a priority this off season now

[valleys07]

Sam Hayes did an ACL at training today. Makes Lycett a priority this off season now

FFS.

[Lightning McQueen]

Anyone going tomorrow night? Will there be an safooty catch-up beer?

[Booney]

Yes and hell yes!

[Booney]

Sam Hayes did an ACL at training today. Makes Lycett a priority this off season now

FFS.

Terrible for the kid.

If every cloud has a silver lining he's got 12 months of protein shakes and moving iron up and down ahead of him.

[Brodlach]

Probably similar to what he was going to do anyway

[Lightning McQueen]

Yes and hell yes!

Where you viewing the game from?

[Booney]

Probably similar to what he was going to do anyway

Other than play football and develop his craft.....

[Brodlach]

My point was he his not AFL ready and would be spending most of his time in the gym and bulking up.

[Booney]

My point was he his not AFL ready and would be spending most of his time in the gym and bulking up.

He was probably next cab off the rank.

Ladhams has only just come off the injury list and Frampton isn't looking like he's up to it.

[Brodlach]

My point was he his not AFL ready and would be spending most of his time in the gym and bulking up.

He was probably next cab off the rank.

Ladhams has only just come off the injury list and Frampton isn't looking like he's up to it.

Billy has dropped away, was the great rucking hope not long ago

[Lightning McQueen]

Billy has dropped away, was the great rucking hope not long ago

Bit of a common theme at Port.

[Booney]

My point was he his not AFL ready and would be spending most of his time in the gym and bulking up.

He was probably next cab off the rank.

Ladhams has only just come off the injury list and Frampton isn't looking like he's up to it.

Billy has dropped away, was the great rucking hope not long ago

Oh yeah, where did you read that or are you just trolling?

( No need to answer.... )

[The Bedge]

Yes and hell yes!

Where you viewing the game from?

I'll be there in the Western Stand - attending the Before the Bounce function at 5pm.. I'm hoping the rain doesn't come down too hard coz we are taking the kidlets.

[Lightning McQueen]

Yes and hell yes!

Where you viewing the game from?

I'll be there in the Western Stand - attending the Before the Bounce function at 5pm.. I'm hoping the rain doesn't come down too hard coz we are taking the kidlets.

Boon and I are catching up for a bevvie at quarter time.