SA Footy

saintal wrote:Seb Ross won his second Trevor Barker Award (B+F) last night. A little surprising, thought he was fairly mediocre for the first 2/3rds of the season (albeit in a mediocre team..). Thought Billings or Steele may have won it. Marshall will be a star. Wilkie a very handy pick up.

2019 TREVOR BARKER AWARD TOP TEN

Seb Ross (170 votes)
Rowan Marshall (152 votes)
Jack Steele (151 votes)
Jack Billings (140 votes)
Tim Membrey (136 votes)
Jade Gresham (131 votes)
Callum Wilkie (115 votes)
Luke Dunstan (111 votes)
Josh Bruce (108 votes)
Shane Savage (101 votes)

Brodlach wrote:If they can get Hannebery, Jack Steele and the other defender that has had concussion issues ( can’t think of his name, has long hair) back and firing as well as Brad Hill in the trade period they will improve

BZB27 wrote:

Brodlach wrote:If they can get Hannebery, Jack Steele and the other defender that has had concussion issues ( can’t think of his name, has long hair) back and firing as well as Brad Hill in the trade period they will improve

Dylan Roberton is who you are thinking of and its been heart issues

Brodlach wrote:If they can get Hannebery, Jack Steele and the other defender that has had concussion issues ( can’t think of his name, has long hair) back and firing as well as Brad Hill in the trade period they will improve

David Brent wrote:

saintal wrote:Seb Ross won his second Trevor Barker Award (B+F) last night. A little surprising, thought he was fairly mediocre for the first 2/3rds of the season (albeit in a mediocre team..). Thought Billings or Steele may have won it. Marshall will be a star. Wilkie a very handy pick up.

2019 TREVOR BARKER AWARD TOP TEN

Seb Ross (170 votes) - In and under player foot skills have always let him down
Rowan Marshall (152 votes) - Will be a star. Improved alot without any assistance in the ruck. I thought he would be more a pinch hit in the ruck/forward but has showed he is up to being to number 1 man for the club.
Jack Steele (151 votes) - is our run with player and the top tackler in the league.
Jack Billings (140 votes) - had his most consistent season at a good level
Tim Membrey (136 votes) - Always competes hard up forward and good for a couple of goals a game.
Jade Gresham (131 votes) - One of our best players forward of centre
Callum Wilkie (115 votes) - has been outstanding down back all season
Luke Dunstan (111 votes) - another player who had a more consistent season but skills aren’t elite
Josh Bruce (108 votes) - Always makes a contest. Hasnt lived up to his breakout season 4 years ago. Injuries havent helped him
Shane Savage (101 votes) - his run off half back has always been good.

Ratten must look at that top 10 list & realise he has his work cut out. It's a pretty ordinary top 10, can see why they need some influx of players like Hill badly.

JK wrote:

Brodlach wrote:If they can get Hannebery, Jack Steele and the other defender that has had concussion issues ( can’t think of his name, has long hair) back and firing as well as Brad Hill in the trade period they will improve

Haven’t got much from Carlisle either. The times I’ve seen the Saints this year have been very impressed with Wilkie.

Senor Moto Gadili wrote:

JK wrote:

Brodlach wrote:If they can get Hannebery, Jack Steele and the other defender that has had concussion issues ( can’t think of his name, has long hair) back and firing as well as Brad Hill in the trade period they will improve

Haven’t got much from Carlisle either. The times I’ve seen the Saints this year have been very impressed with Wilkie.

Wilkie had an outstanding year. Picked up as a mature age rookie and played every game (I think) to be 7th in their B&F. Was hampered by injury as a junior which is why he wasn't picked up until he turned 22.

BZB27 wrote:

David Brent wrote:

saintal wrote:Seb Ross won his second Trevor Barker Award (B+F) last night. A little surprising, thought he was fairly mediocre for the first 2/3rds of the season (albeit in a mediocre team..). Thought Billings or Steele may have won it. Marshall will be a star. Wilkie a very handy pick up.

2019 TREVOR BARKER AWARD TOP TEN

Seb Ross (170 votes) - In and under player foot skills have always let him down
Rowan Marshall (152 votes) - Will be a star. Improved alot without any assistance in the ruck. I thought he would be more a pinch hit in the ruck/forward but has showed he is up to being to number 1 man for the club.
Jack Steele (151 votes) - is our run with player and the top tackler in the league.
Jack Billings (140 votes) - had his most consistent season at a good level
Tim Membrey (136 votes) - Always competes hard up forward and good for a couple of goals a game.
Jade Gresham (131 votes) - One of our best players forward of centre
Callum Wilkie (115 votes) - has been outstanding down back all season
Luke Dunstan (111 votes) - another player who had a more consistent season but skills aren’t elite
Josh Bruce (108 votes) - Always makes a contest. Hasnt lived up to his breakout season 4 years ago. Injuries havent helped him
Shane Savage (101 votes) - his run off half back has always been good.

Ratten must look at that top 10 list & realise he has his work cut out. It's a pretty ordinary top 10, can see why they need some influx of players like Hill badly.

Marshall, Gresham and Billings are our elite/will be players. Wilkie has had an outstanding first season in the AFL.

Guys like Clark, Coffield, Battle i reckon will take another step up.

Hopefully Hannabery, Geary, Carlisle and the the young guys King and Bytel are over there injuries and can have big pre seasons.

PatowalongaPirate wrote:Geary taken to hospital for scans on a possible broken leg.

Lightning McQueen wrote:

PatowalongaPirate wrote:Geary taken to hospital for scans on a possible broken leg.

He doesn't have much luck, wasn't his hammy in a jar beside his bed a couple of years back?

Eagles2014 wrote:Rowan Marshall injured now and will miss early part of season, big blow as really good player. At least they can pick up Paul Hunter from South Adelaide now