Crows Next Coach

[G]

What odds Gary McIntosh ?

he is well respected.

Absolutely out of his league and in coaching terms, well respected where ?

mark neeld - an assistant at coll who malthouse rates higher then buckley

What a load of crap, especially the "rates higher than Buckley" part

[overloaded]

Macca is well respected in football circles and a down to earth coach that would go well at the crows. Where are you saying he is not respected?

[G]

Macca's coaching ability is far from being labelled as "respected"

Naturally hes got enormous respect in the footy community for his playing ability and for being a good "down to earth" bloke in general, but as coach - sorry NO !!!!

[mighty_tiger_79]

What odds Gary McIntosh ?

he is well respected.

Absolutely out of his league and in coaching terms, well respected where ?

mark neeld - an assistant at coll who malthouse rates higher then buckley

What a load of crap, especially the "rates higher than Buckley" part

so mark neeld isnt an assistant at collingwood??

[G]

YES Mark Neeld is an assistant coach at Collingwood but the CRAP part is in reference to your claim "who Malthouse rates higher than Buckley"

[mighty_tiger_79]

YES Mark Neeld is an assistant coach at Collingwood but the CRAP part is in reference to your claim "who Malthouse rates higher than Buckley"

well it might be crap but that is what Malthouse has said publicly

[eags]

Mark Bickley now at $2.50 ... given he's had 2 wins and a narrow loss to Geelong, plus Gold Coast and Richmond to come which should both be winnable given current form, anyone else think this is pretty good value?

Surely he would be a shoe-in for the job if he wanted it?

[Interceptor]

Mark Bickley now at $2.50 ... given he's had 2 wins and a narrow loss to Geelong, plus Gold Coast and Richmond to come which should both be winnable given current form, anyone else think this is pretty good value?

Surely he would be a shoe-in for the job if he wanted it?

Hasn't done much wrong, but has had a relatively easy run so far (plus Adelaide actually beat Geelong at home last year), which I'm sure the selection panel will take into account.
He is probably too inexperienced to be appointed with confidence.

[mighty_tiger_79]

Eade would definately have to be in the mix now.

i guess the thing for the crows, is Primus took over late last season and his record got him the gig this year, do they think the same could happen if they go with Bickley?

[Mr_Willy]

Eade would definately have to be in the mix now.

i guess the thing for the crows, is Primus took over late last season and his record got him the gig this year, do they think the same could happen if they go with Bickley?

Yes that is true MT but look at what Roos did at Sydney in a similar situation..... Primus is just unlucky that he took over a basket case of a playing list, and a basket case of a football club...... Port will be staying down for a few more years yet.... No one will want to play for them.....