BARRY HALL v tribunal????

[mighty_tiger_79]

from our sponsors

How many games will Barry Hall miss for striking Brent Staker - 5.5 Weeks



14-4-2008 12:30 AEST
Barry's Ban
Under 5.5 Weeks 2.15
Over 5.5 Weeks 1.70
No Multi's

[Dirko]

Here's the link

http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=TzN4Ly_yd9w

See what it is worth !!

I'd say 8 Weeks !!

[mighty_tiger_79]

havent seen it, but im just amazed you can bet on things like this.

[Dirko]

havent seen it, but im just amazed you can bet on things like this.

Watch the link !!

Funny thing was (well not funny for Staker), was Hall appealed to the Ump for a free kick a second before he decked him !!
Brain fade !!

Actually...His suspension might be lowered for Hunters piss weak "flying the flag" effort (hats off to Beau Waters though at quarter time)

[bayman]

havent seen it, but im just amazed you can bet on things like this.

what if you were on the tribunal & a punter ? i know what i'd be doing 4 weeks & take the 'juicier odds'

[jackpot jim]

Ban the Thug for Life.
Total ****.
Has had more than enough chances.
Should never had played in the '05 GF.
Disgrace to the game.

[Punk Rooster]

Hall's Holiday
Under 6.5 Weeks 1.95
Over 6.5 Weeks 1.85

I'm very tempted to take the 1.95....

[Wedgie]

Im tempted to take the $1.85, I found this reference to another incident in the past, the only difference seems to be the elbow and the subsequent injury but I can see a lot in common that points to well over 6.5 weeks:

E. A PLAYER IS REPORTED ON A
SERIOUS STRIKING CHARGE, WHICH IS REFERRED TO THE TRIBUNAL.
Player O’Shea (Brisbane Lions) is reported on charge of striking player Karns (Hawthorn) with an elbow to the head in the third quarter. Karns is hospitalized, suffering a broken jaw. He is likely to miss eight matches through injury.
The Match Review Panel assessed the report and decided the Conduct was Intentional, the Impact Severe, The Location Behind Play, and the Contact High. This led to a tally of 11 activation points. Under the Chart of Offences – Demerit Points, the matter is automatically referred to the Tribunal.
O’Shea, who had been suspended for three matches in the previous season, and two matches the season before was unable to take a guilty plea.
The Tribunal found the charge proven, and allocated 750 base demerit points under its discretionary powers.
As O’Shea had a prior record, the base points were increased by 30% and 20% (750 + 225 + 150 = 1125). He also had 75.25 residual points from his previous suspension. (1125 + 75.25 = 1200.25) O’Shea was suspended for 12 matches, and has 0.25 residual points.

[Wedgie]

Talked myself into it but just plonked $20 on it.

Won't include it in my footy bets as its a little bit different to the normal predictions.

[Punk Rooster]

Hall's Holiday
Under 6.5 Weeks 1.95
Over 6.5 Weeks 1.85

$25 @ 1.95

[Wedgie]

Well we stuffed up there Punky, could have given each other $2.00

[Dutchy]

Ive taken Under 6.5....cant see him getting 7 or more...

[G]

Hey Jackpot Jim, you dont think you're getting carried away a tad do you ?
Then again I suppose the Powers brilliant start to the season has got you offside and not thinking clearly.

[jackpot jim]

Hey Jackpot Jim, you dont think you're getting carried away a tad do you ?
Then again I suppose the Powers brilliant start to the season has got you offside and not thinking clearly.

Not at all.
If you did that to a person in public, you'd end up in the slammer.
Why does doing that on a footy field give you protection from the law?
About time the Pathetic AFL took a hard line stance on thuggery.
What other sport wouldnt you get a season for that apart from all the American sports where violence is a neccessity to make them interesting.

[another grub]

He is a tool and 100% correct JJ he shouldnt have played in GF.... throw the book at him ....8 weeks

[Punk Rooster]

He is a tool and 100% correct JJ he shouldnt have played in GF.... throw the book at him ....8 weeks

AG's had a "monkey" on Hall +6.5 then...

[another grub]

ALL ABOARD!!!! I think over 5.5 is a monty to be honest......

[Interceptor]

Hey Jackpot Jim, you dont think you're getting carried away a tad do you ?
Then again I suppose the Powers brilliant start to the season has got you offside and not thinking clearly.

Not at all.
If you did that to a person in public, you'd end up in the slammer.
Why does doing that on a footy field give you protection from the law?
About time the Pathetic AFL took a hard line stance on thuggery.
What other sport wouldnt you get a season for that apart from all the American sports where violence is a neccessity to make them interesting.

Another hysterical reaction

Have a good read:

http://www.realfooty.com.au/news/news/sympathy-for-the-devil/2008/04/13/1208024993057.html

[bayman]

he got 7 weeks, or is that 6 weeks for the broken wrist & 1 week for the strike ?

[Wedgie]

Well that was easy moneyafter reading the precedent I found. He was actually only 10 points short of 8.