SA Footy

This is Michaelanglo Rucci's top 10 players to have played only SANFL (well mostly SANFL)
1. Barrie Robran
2. Russell Ebert
3. Peter Carey
4. Len Fitzgerald
5. Lindsay Head
6. Rick Davies
7. Neil Kerley
8. Ken Farmer
9. Bob Quinn
10. Dan Moriarty

This is a top ten done in the same paper in 1977.

1 – Barrie Robran (North) 1967
2 – Russell Ebert (Port) 1968
3 – Len Fitzgerald (Sturt) 1951
4 – Dan Moriarty (South) early 1900s
5 – Tom Leahy (West, North) 1904
6 – Ken Farmer (North) 1929
7 – Bob Quinn (Port) 1933
8 – Bob Hank (Torrens) 1944
9 – Ian McKay (North) 1946
10 - Lindsay Head (Torrens) 1952

You be the judge!

Peter Carey number 3 on both lists done (by Cornes as well), its not April 1st is it

How could he possibly be there before Farmer

GWW wrote:Peter Carey number 3 on both lists done (by Cornes as well), its not April 1st is it

How could he possibly be there before Farmer

I couldn't agree more big Supe should be #1....

1980 Tassie Medalist wrote:

GWW wrote:Peter Carey number 3 on both lists done (by Cornes as well), its not April 1st is it

How could he possibly be there before Farmer

I couldn't agree more big Supe should be #1....

The sad thing is you're probably serious.

I would have had Knuckles at #3 myself, though Carey would almost certainly feature in my (admittedly biased) top ten. Garry McIntosh might have got a guernsey too.

Let the holy wars begin...

IMO, How can you put a list together when you haven't seen those blokes run around.

In Rucci's list I've only seen Carey, Ebert and Davies. All the other no idea, just go on reputation...

Wacka Scott -- completely ripped off
200 odd games in the era when 200 is a very large number
38 state games straight, which of course reduces his home and away games
6 b and fs
4 premeirships
3 magareys

Surely he rates a mention somewhere in the ten.

Personal view too - Farmer has to be in the top three at a minimum. A decade straight of kicking the ton and the best goal average ever.

One would suggest Mr Rucci do some research next time rather than post a greatest 10 players since the war with two "token" pre WW2 players included.

Good work by Lindsay Head to climb five spots in 30 years without playing a game.

Surprised there was no room for Jim Lihou.

Harry the Horse wrote:
Surprised there was no room for Jim Lihou.

Is that a serious comment? Lihou was good, but he wouldn't be in the top 10 Glenelg players of all time!

GWW wrote:

Harry the Horse wrote:
Surprised there was no room for Jim Lihou.

Is that a serious comment? Lihou was good, but he wouldn't be in the top 10 Glenelg players of all time!

Greg Nicholson had Jim Lihou covered.

rogernumber10 wrote:Personal view too - Farmer has to be in the top three at a minimum. A decade straight of kicking the ton and the best goal average ever.

Agree completely

As a matter of interest this is the complete list from 1976 (sorry not 1977 - my mistake). Compiled by Geoff Kingston and Mike Coward.

1 – Barrie Robran (North) 1967
2 – Russell Ebert (Port) 1968
3 – Len Fitzgerald (Sturt) 1951
4 – Dan Moriarty (South) early 1900s
5 – Tom Leahy (West, North) 1904
6 – Ken Farmer (North) 1929
7 – Bob Quinn (Port) 1933
8 – Bob Hank (Torrens) 1944
9 – Ian McKay (North) 1946
10 - Lindsay Head (Torrens) 1952
11 – Jim Deane (South, Richmond) 1945
12 – Hugh Cumberland (St Kilda, Melb:, Sturt,) early 1900s
13 – Snowy Hamilton (North, West) 1919
14 – Brenton Adcock (Sturt) 1962
15 – Wacka Scott (Norwood) 1920
16 – Jack Broadstock (West, Richmond, Torrens) 1938
17 – John Cahill (Port) 1958
18 – Dick Russell (Port) 1947
19 – Alec Lill (Norwood) 1923
20 – Frank Golding (Sturt) 1909
21 – Ken Eustice (West , Central, Glenelg) 1957
22 – Bruce McGregor (West) 1923
23 – Tom McKenzie (Torrens, North) early 1900s
24 – Jack Tredrea (South) 1903
25 – John Abley (Port) from 1950
26 – John Marriot (Norwood) 1947
27 – Blue Johnston (Glenelg) 1927
28 – Bob Barnes (West) 1921
29 – Paul Bagshaw (Sturt) 1964
30 – Don Lindner (North) 1954
31 – Harold Oliver (Port) 1910
32 – Horrie Riley (Sturt) 1922
33 – Jack Owens (Glenelg) 1924
34 – Jack Oatey (Norwood) 1940
35 – Vic Richardson (Sturt) 1920s
36 – Fos Williams (West, Port) 1946
37 – Neil Kerley (West, South, Glenelg) 1955
38 – Laurie Cahill (South) 1933
39 – Dick Head (West) 1907
40 – Bill Mayman (Sturt) 1913

Leaping Lindner wrote:39 – Dick Head (West) 1907

Leaping Lindner wrote:37 – Neil Kerley (West, South, Glenelg) 1955

So two blokes who watched pretty much his whole playing career rated him at 37 a couple of years after he finished playing, without looking at his career years later and being swayed by the personality or the coaching deeds (which still don't stack up anywhere near those of Oatey / Williams / Cahill).

the one that surprises me is that Bagshaw is so far down, considering he was already with six flags in the bank at that point, and about to hold the games record.

LL, Im interested in your top 10, 20 or 50 players seeing as you have a great historical understanding of the SANFL.

No Malcolm Blight

woodwt wrote:No Malcolm Blight

The list is for players who mainly played SANFL, ie if they played considerable VFL/AFL they're not included.

Reakon it's impossible to find a definitive list.

Any list should be broken into different eras.

Maybe something like...

Pre 1907
1908 - 1944
1945 - 1990
1991 beyond

GWW wrote:

woodwt wrote:No Malcolm Blight

The list is for players who mainly played SANFL, ie if they played considerable VFL/AFL they're not included.

didn't Blighty only play 10 - 15 games fewer with the Peckers then the Roos ?

IMO should be on BOTH...