Page 2 of 2

Re: New ALP leadership

PostPosted: Sun Oct 13, 2013 2:11 pm
by Bully
So mr snake in the grass bill shorten Is the new labor leader .

LAbor won't be in government now for many many years

Good luck to them and bulldogproud ....

Re: New ALP leadership

PostPosted: Sun Oct 13, 2013 6:06 pm
by Gozu
Good to see Shorten win so Labor can burn through him now and then when a viable alternative government in 2019 they will have a new leader and this guy will be ancient history. He's done enough damage to the party already and he's only been there six years.

Re: New ALP leadership

PostPosted: Sun Oct 13, 2013 7:27 pm
by Psyber
The result is announced: http://au.news.yahoo.com/a/19371649/bil ... or-leader/
Bill Shorten has been elected leader of the federal parliamentary Labor Party.
Mr Shorten won with 63.9 per cent of the caucus vote and 40 per cent of the members vote for an overall total of 52 per cent.
"Proud to announce that Bill Shorten has been elected the new Labor Leader!" tweeted the ALP.
Mr Shorten won 55 votes in the 86-member caucus.
Mr Albanese attracted 18,230 rank-and-file votes to Mr Shorten's 12,196.

In this system, it is clearly spelled out that 55 caucus members have more say than the 18,230 ALP members who preferred the other candidate.
I think they need another system as this is as exploitable as the original "faceless men" situation was.

Personally, I feel some tendency to trust Albanese, as I did in Kim Beasley, but I don't trust Bill Shorten any more than I did his two predecessors.
(On the other hand - as I've said before - I'm not a big Tony Abbott fan either.)

EDIT: I didn't see your post above when first posting this, Gozu, but I think your analysis is correct.

Re: New ALP leadership

PostPosted: Wed Oct 16, 2013 11:53 am
by Grahaml
So after all that time and money spent on the new Labor leadership and we end up with the same result had they just gone with the caucus vote from the start. I have a feeling this experiment won't last as long as Abbott's PM tenure......

On the plus side, it did give us all a well deserved break from politics for a bit. It's nice to see a new government coming in and able to set about their task without an opposition jumping the gun on anything that happens. Should make it a rule that every government gets a month to get its act together before politics starts up again.