SA Footy

Toto wrote:I haven't seen any SAAFL because it has no atmosphere compared to country footy but I'm sure the standard of div1 would be right up there with the two southern leagues

haha. Div 1 teams would demolish southern teams.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Didn't say they wouldn't?

I said I couldn't comment on the SAAFL because I won't go and watch any of it because it has absolutely no atmosphere and barely any supporters. GSFL, HFL(both divs) and RMFL I watch a fair bit of because they all have big crowds and good country footy atmosphere!!

I think you'd find Mount Compass, Hahndorf and Meningie would all give the best div 1 sides a fair shake!

Sorry scottyroo, I have seen a few games here and there when I can, but not enough to comment on the standard of the whole competition.
And not having juniors follow, not many grounds have decent parking. A long with what I have heard from recruits from div 1 amateurs to the country I have spoken with all have said exactly the same thing, that country footy leagues atmosphere is what draws them out to these leagues. Obviously div 1 standard is excellent, and probably the closest thing to SANFL footy. I'm not having a dig at the standard, but you can't beat country footy atmosphere in my opinion.

Toto wrote:
I think you'd find Mount Compass, Hahndorf and Meningie would all give the best div 1 sides a fair shake!

Yet only 1 of them won their comp this year?

Toto wrote:Sorry scottyroo, I have seen a few games here and there when I can, but not enough to comment on the standard of the whole competition.
And not having juniors follow, not many grounds have decent parking. A long with what I have heard from recruits from div 1 amateurs to the country I have spoken with all have said exactly the same thing, that country footy leagues atmosphere is what draws them out to these leagues. Obviously div 1 standard is excellent, and probably the closest thing to SANFL footy. I'm not having a dig at the standard, but you can't beat country footy atmosphere in my opinion.

Bit of back pedalling going on here

I'm sure the standard of div1 would be right up there with the two southern leagues

Jimmy_041 wrote:

Toto wrote:Sorry scottyroo, I have seen a few games here and there when I can, but not enough to comment on the standard of the whole competition.
And not having juniors follow, not many grounds have decent parking. A long with what I have heard from recruits from div 1 amateurs to the country I have spoken with all have said exactly the same thing, that country footy leagues atmosphere is what draws them out to these leagues. Obviously div 1 standard is excellent, and probably the closest thing to SANFL footy. I'm not having a dig at the standard, but you can't beat country footy atmosphere in my opinion.

Bit of back pedalling going on here

I'm sure the standard of div1 would be right up there with the two southern leagues

He's been too busy blessing the rains in Africa.

Dogwatcher wrote:I always felt Riverland footy was Div 3 to high Div 4 standard.
Independent footy is about C3 these days, I suspect.

Yet Waikerie would match it with any of the top teams in country footy IMO

Toto wrote:Sorry scottyroo, I have seen a few games here and there when I can, but not enough to comment on the standard of the whole competition.
And not having juniors follow, not many grounds have decent parking. A long with what I have heard from recruits from div 1 amateurs to the country I have spoken with all have said exactly the same thing, that country footy leagues atmosphere is what draws them out to these leagues. Obviously div 1 standard is excellent, and probably the closest thing to SANFL footy. I'm not having a dig at the standard, but you can't beat country footy atmosphere in my opinion.

yep it is the atmosphere why blokes leave to play country, please, do you believe the earth is flat?

Bum Crack wrote:

Dogwatcher wrote:I always felt Riverland footy was Div 3 to high Div 4 standard.
Independent footy is about C3 these days, I suspect.

Yet Waikerie would match it with any of the top teams in country footy IMO

Seems like they were far ahead of everyone else this year. Possible.

Brighton are the best test case at the moment, obviously dominated Div 3 as expected, next year will be interesting in Div 2, I suspect they will make the finals but dunno if they will be in the top 2-3.

I believe Div 1 would be the best under SANFL, the top 10 players in country v Div 1 teams would be very similar in talent/skill. Div 1 would get the top country teams in depth though.

Dutchy wrote:Brighton are the best test case at the moment, obviously dominated Div 3 as expected, next year will be interesting in Div 2, I suspect they will make the finals but dunno if they will be in the top 2-3.

I believe Div 1 would be the best under SANFL, the top 10 players in country v Div 1 teams would be very similar in talent/skill. Div 1 would get the top country teams in depth though.

Spot on.

Just noticed this thread, I'll throw my two cents worth:

1. SAAFL Div 1
2. SAAFL Div 2
3. HFL Div 1
4. GSFL
5. RFL/RMFL
6. SAAFL Div 3

Executive Member wrote:

Toto wrote:Sorry scottyroo, I have seen a few games here and there when I can, but not enough to comment on the standard of the whole competition.
And not having juniors follow, not many grounds have decent parking. A long with what I have heard from recruits from div 1 amateurs to the country I have spoken with all have said exactly the same thing, that country footy leagues atmosphere is what draws them out to these leagues. Obviously div 1 standard is excellent, and probably the closest thing to SANFL footy. I'm not having a dig at the standard, but you can't beat country footy atmosphere in my opinion.

yep it is the atmosphere why blokes leave to play country, please, do you believe the earth is flat?

We all know money plays a role but tend to agree with him.

Having watched a fair bit of country footy in the last year the atmosphere and culture of country footy is a million miles ahead of amateur footy imho.

Id say the Barossa & GSFL look to be on par from what i have seen, maybe bigger bodies in the Barossa.
In my opinion I would put the top sides in these two leagues on par with a mid tear Div 1 side.
HFL Div 1 would also be in that conversation. Hahndorf as the stand out there.

Hmmmm, Langhorne Creek, 3 Flags in a row, go alright they do.

Interesting thread.
I think the local SAAFL top Teir coaches get more out of their players due to proximity to training & more
Assistant coaching options available.
I in order I’d say.
DIV 1
RMFL,
HILLS D1
KNTFL
GSFL
BAROSSA
SFL

Not nearly showing the BLG the respect it deserves. Having the RMFL above it is farcical.

Hills div 1 and BLG strongest country leagues.

Clubs range from div 1 contenders to div 5. Div 7 if you look at Freeling this year.

Good locals in both leagues with top ups due to close proximity to the city.

I do believe southern districts won the country carnival....again!
Considering its made up of SFL and GSFL players I think they're better comps than given credit for.

Maggies2002 wrote:Not nearly showing the BLG the respect it deserves. Having the RMFL above it is farcical.

Hills div 1 and BLG strongest country leagues.

Clubs range from div 1 contenders to div 5. Div 7 if you look at Freeling this year.

Good locals in both leagues with top ups due to close proximity to the city.

Freeling Div 7? Reckon you might be the one not showing the BLG the respect it deserves.

Team for team, BLG, Hills Div 1 and GSFL wouldn't have much between them. Make sense being the three closest to the city.

IMO

HFL D1
Barossa
Great Southern
Top 3 in any order by a bit. KNTFL probably next in line, RMFL 5-10 years ago would easily be top 3. No where near it now.