SA Footy

Of course not, no guaranteed flag

Footy Chick wrote:

jo172 wrote:
Maybe they can take Salisbury West's spot in Div 3 or Kilburn's in Div 4

This isn't as stupid as it sounds.

Absolutely. I'm sure there will be more clubs within the merry-go-round between now and March too.

This will test the new "3 player rule" Aloisi, Hickey, Craven, Leigh, McIntyre all played or were signed at Salisbury West last season.

ROOBOY18 wrote:This will test the new "3 player rule" Aloisi, Hickey, Craven, Leigh, McIntyre all played or were signed at Salisbury West last season.

Might be wrong but dont think it matters if they have played 25 games there previously.

If anyone at Brahma Lodge should get paid it should be the ones that stuck by them this year. Not some fly by nighter who has no alliance to the club.

Mr Beefy wrote:

ROOBOY18 wrote:This will test the new "3 player rule" Aloisi, Hickey, Craven, Leigh, McIntyre all played or were signed at Salisbury West last season.

Might be wrong but dont think it matters if they have played 25 games there previously.

Correct

I know it is very hard for a club to do, but would a club ever say no to guys returning after walking out on them for more money elsewhere?

I know it would take a brave club to do so, also how would the blokes who hang around a club and play for the jumper and all the right reasons think about guys walking back after they have hung around and had there arse handed to them each week of the last season.

This is just a general view as well and not about one club!

Mr Beefy wrote:

ROOBOY18 wrote:This will test the new "3 player rule" Aloisi, Hickey, Craven, Leigh, McIntyre all played or were signed at Salisbury West last season.

Might be wrong but dont think it matters if they have played 25 games there previously.

Craven I don't think has played the 25 games but add Kyle Sylva to the list from Salisbury west. Could there be another?

Have heard that Tommy Proctor is also returning and could be bring the Clark brothers back with him.

I wonder how many of those players would still come back if the league forced them to play in Div 3 in 2015...

S Demon wrote:I wonder how many of those players would still come back if the league forced them to play in Div 3 in 2015...

So much this. Ditto the Kilburn blokes.

ROOBOY18 wrote:This will test the new "3 player rule" Aloisi, Hickey, Craven, Leigh, McIntyre all played or were signed at Salisbury West last season.

Hickey and mcintyre haven't signed anything with brahma for next year at this stage

The_Informer wrote:I know it is very hard for a club to do, but would a club ever say no to guys returning after walking out on them for more money elsewhere?

I know it would take a brave club to do so, also how would the blokes who hang around a club and play for the jumper and all the right reasons think about guys walking back after they have hung around and had there arse handed to them each week of the last season.

This is just a general view as well and not about one club!

Would never happen in a million years. Unless they were asking to much.

craven would have been lucky to play 1 game at salisbury west when he left sedan was injuried for most of the season so can see him getting cleared back to brahma with no trouble

Robb_Stark wrote:craven would have been lucky to play 1 game at salisbury west when he left sedan was injuried for most of the season so can see him getting cleared back to brahma with no trouble

Any reason why these blokes didn't go back to Brahma last season when they walked out on Sedan?

The_Informer wrote:

Robb_Stark wrote:craven would have been lucky to play 1 game at salisbury west when he left sedan was injuried for most of the season so can see him getting cleared back to brahma with no trouble

Any reason why these blokes didn't go back to Brahma last season when they walked out on Sedan?

Because Brahma were about 0-14 would be a fair reason why.....

carey wrote:

The_Informer wrote:

Robb_Stark wrote:craven would have been lucky to play 1 game at salisbury west when he left sedan was injuried for most of the season so can see him getting cleared back to brahma with no trouble

Any reason why these blokes didn't go back to Brahma last season when they walked out on Sedan?

Because Brahma were about 0-14 would be a fair reason why.....

do we make the call early and say west croydon vs brahma lodge in the grand final

Robb_Stark wrote:

carey wrote:

The_Informer wrote:

Robb_Stark wrote:craven would have been lucky to play 1 game at salisbury west when he left sedan was injuried for most of the season so can see him getting cleared back to brahma with no trouble

Any reason why these blokes didn't go back to Brahma last season when they walked out on Sedan?

Because Brahma were about 0-14 would be a fair reason why.....

do we make the call early and say west croydon vs brahma lodge in the grand final

No!, I reckon Zedman will have a big influence at Lockleys and turn them into contenders.

He has an amazing knowledge of the div and opposition that will go a long way.

i still cant fathom how they can all leave the club for one year and come back 3 divisions lower!!! doesn't seem right to me but oh well.

wonder_kid wrote:i still cant fathom how they can all leave the club for one year and come back 3 divisions lower!!! doesn't seem right to me but oh well.

It's the lure of The Pleasure Machine bringing them back.