SAAFL Div 4 & 4R (2009)

[The Ash Man]

Witnessed a strange occurence at North Haven on Saturday that surprise surprise involved an umpire and a rule interpretation and I would like some clarification

A player clearly head butted another player right in front of a central umpire who blew his whistle reached into his sock pulled out a red card and marched the offender to the interchage..all good so far...came back to his position on the field indicated the free kick and play went on..still all good..now here is where I get confused...moments later the player is replaced (is this allowed) one bench didnt think this was allowed so they went to interchange steward who said it wasnt a red card it was yellow which means he can be replaced(true) but also stated that the player that came off cannot go back on for remainder of game(f#@k now I am confused) when a runner asked central umpire for clarification he said it was a yellow card (either hes color blind or 60 others are)

Somebody got stiffed here but I cant work out who
Was anyone else there that seen it happen??
What should have happened...and yes Ive read the handbook and THINK I know what should have happened. ..Maybe someone from North Haven?? has a view

the sixteen year old from north haven did get sent from the oval with a red card after a one on one mellee, the greenacres bloke tried to pick on the lad who stood up for himself some words were said and then i turned away briefly and missed the slight contact as someone put it. mind you we were only 15 mts away. the umpire did give a free and showed the red card and escorted him from the field. the interchange is on the other side of the oval so i donot know what happened after that. the other umpire did want to throw the ball up, but the send off umpire re instated the free. no 50 mts. after the game the club was told it should have been a yellow and the umpire was sorry for the mistake. yellow card is replacable. red card: i got four years ago was 20 minutes on the bench and could not be replaced for 10minutes and to rub salt into my wounds got left off from the charge at tynte st. but the club had already suffered by the report losing the prelim.

one on one melee?

[tinginthewater]

I think the team that kicks the most goals will win the game.

Well you thought wrong, a team can kick less goals but enough points to still be in front and thus, win the game

I just heard Gerard Healy say that on the telly and thought it sounded really smart.

[bucketts]

Witnessed a strange occurence at North Haven on Saturday that surprise surprise involved an umpire and a rule interpretation and I would like some clarification

A player clearly head butted another player right in front of a central umpire who blew his whistle reached into his sock pulled out a red card and marched the offender to the interchage..all good so far...came back to his position on the field indicated the free kick and play went on..still all good..now here is where I get confused...moments later the player is replaced (is this allowed) one bench didnt think this was allowed so they went to interchange steward who said it wasnt a red card it was yellow which means he can be replaced(true) but also stated that the player that came off cannot go back on for remainder of game(f#@k now I am confused) when a runner asked central umpire for clarification he said it was a yellow card (either hes color blind or 60 others are)

Somebody got stiffed here but I cant work out who
Was anyone else there that seen it happen??
What should have happened...and yes Ive read the handbook and THINK I know what should have happened. ..Maybe someone from North Haven?? has a view

the sixteen year old from north haven did get sent from the oval with a red card after a one on one mellee, the greenacres bloke tried to pick on the lad who stood up for himself some words were said and then i turned away briefly and missed the slight contact as someone put it. mind you we were only 15 mts away. the umpire did give a free and showed the red card and escorted him from the field. the interchange is on the other side of the oval so i donot know what happened after that. the other umpire did want to throw the ball up, but the send off umpire re instated the free. no 50 mts. after the game the club was told it should have been a yellow and the umpire was sorry for the mistake. yellow card is replacable. red card: i got four years ago was 20 minutes on the bench and could not be replaced for 10minutes and to rub salt into my wounds got left off from the charge at tynte st. but the club had already suffered by the report losing the prelim.

one on one melee?

you know what i mean

[bucketts]

Sorry Bucketts but Im more confused now...if the umpire said "sorry" after the game why didnt the send off with no relacement stand

Zed..I think youre correct and the ump remembered he was taking the missus out to tea on Wednesday night and didnt want to get in the poo with her so he forgot the head butt no matter how minor the contact was..

Thanks Bucketts for confirming the red card from the ump ...you've saved me a visit to the optomertrist

no probs

[turk186]

Got a whisper tonight that a club local to our area and struggling to both hold players and win a game may have lost yet another from their line up ...and he may well be heading towards "the place to be"

Anyone have a clue who it may be??

[Q.]

You might as well tell us. Who from Ingle Farm is going where?

[turk186]

Quichey..my first thought also but was told it wasnt them

[Jimmy_041]

Club from a higher grade who have a good rivalry with "the place to be"

[Lightning McQueen]

Quichey..my first thought also but was told it wasnt them

Shrek/ Kilburn?

[turk186]

Jimmy..dont know thats what Im trying to find out

LM..we woundn't have him..were a working class club and have no room for his type

[Lightning McQueen]

Jimmy..dont know thats what Im trying to find out

LM..we woundn't have him..were a working class club and have no room for his type

Just like the movie hey, prejudice against ogres.

[Jimmy_041]

Jimmy..dont know thats what Im trying to find out

If it was a question, I would have put a question mark on the end..........

[Johno6]

someone from golden grove? (altho we arent struggling)

you guys gettin azza riley?

[Dolphin Express]

This is all far too cryptic. But thank god we stopped talking about red cards.

[class act]

Come on Turk you can't leave us all hangin round like that ,my guess is its someone from kilburn as I hear they are having a mass exit of players wanting clearances to other clubs,someone correct me if I am wrong

[Jimmy_041]

Come on Turk you can't leave us all hangin round like that ,my guess is its someone from kilburn as I hear they are having a mass exit of players wanting clearances to other clubs,someone correct me if I am wrong

Half of Kilburn are college pooftas so they wouldn't be going to Greenacres

[Johno6]

so their goign to prince alfred instead?

[TEX07]

Got a whisper tonight that a club local to our area and struggling to both hold players and win a game may have lost yet another from their line up ...and he may well be heading towards "the place to be"

Anyone have a clue who it may be??

Kilburn/Tim White?

[zedman]

Jimmy..dont know thats what Im trying to find out

LM..we woundn't have him..were a working class club and have no room for his type

gold!!

where is the big green monster anyway...

[The Ash Man]

Jimmy..dont know thats what Im trying to find out

LM..we woundn't have him..were a working class club and have no room for his type

gold!!

where is the big green monster anyway...