Page 21 of 43
Re: Adelaide Footy League Division 2 - 2018
Posted:
Fri Jun 22, 2018 8:47 pmby The Big Shrek
jo172 wrote:The Big Shrek wrote:Big call saying that a review of a decision kicking a football club out of their league is likely frivolous or vexatious. In fact that's probably as silly as Trader's post.
If their grounds are "big call" I'm pretty confident tbh
Well that made no sense at all. Can someone explain what that meant?
Re: Adelaide Footy League Division 2 - 2018
Posted:
Fri Jun 22, 2018 8:52 pmby jo172
Ah, the grounds of review are challenging the tribunal's standard of proof, that's been that rule forever. A big call indeed
Re: Adelaide Footy League Division 2 - 2018
Posted:
Fri Jun 22, 2018 9:05 pmby The Big Shrek
Dear Jo,
The grounds of review (if there are any) bear no resemblance to Big Shrek's posts.
Perhaps separating legal proceedings and unrelated social media posts will improve your strike rate on judicial reviews.
Yours faithfully,
Big Shrek
Re: Adelaide Footy League Division 2 - 2018
Posted:
Fri Jun 22, 2018 9:11 pmby jo172
The Big Shrek wrote:Dear Jo,
The grounds of review (if there are any) bear no resemblance to Big Shrek's posts.
Perhaps separating legal proceedings and unrelated social media posts will improve your strike rate on judicial reviews.
Yours faithfully,
Big Shrek
Never had JR gone badly. Probably due to the advice I gave earlier, namely you want an ongoing relationship with someone, namely as a member of an incorporated association, litigating is astonishingly poor strategy.
Re: Adelaide Footy League Division 2 - 2018
Posted:
Fri Jun 22, 2018 9:16 pmby The Big Shrek
jo172 wrote:Surely they're not insane enough to want to go the injunctive root.
I've done a couple of similar cases on behalf on Incorporated associations. Leaving aside that the expelled member remained expelled after both, directly antagonising the body you want to be a part of is pure strategic insanity.
Imagine if the league were to put out a call to fund their own silk. Northies would be really popular
What did this post mean then?
Re: Adelaide Footy League Division 2 - 2018
Posted:
Fri Jun 22, 2018 9:42 pmby The Big Shrek
The harm caused by the punch is very relevant to penalty. However the intention of the person who caused the harm is more relevant to guilt or the penalty. The problem with your comparison is that in a one punch attack the person inevitably intends to punch the person in the head. The argument here is that he didn’t.
Re: Adelaide Footy League Division 2 - 2018
Posted:
Fri Jun 22, 2018 9:46 pmby Computer Crashed
Legal this, legal that.
There should be no tolerance.
SN have had their chances, every year the same thing happens.
Bye Bye.
Re: Adelaide Footy League Division 2 - 2018
Posted:
Fri Jun 22, 2018 9:54 pmby whufc
The Big Shrek wrote:The harm caused by the punch is very relevant to penalty. However the intention of the person who caused the harm is more relevant to guilt or the penalty. The problem with your comparison is that in a one punch attack the person inevitably intends to punch the person in the head. The argument here is that he didn’t.
Fair call
How would the league tribunal ever be able to 100% prove intent other than taking the players word.
I feel like for an amateur league tribunal to be consistent they would be best to take harm caused rather than extremly subjectual intent line.
Cheers for the genuine discussion without all the BS
Re: Adelaide Footy League Division 2 - 2018
Posted:
Fri Jun 22, 2018 10:27 pmby The Big Shrek
But if they only used harm as the guideline then you would end up with ‘football collisions ‘ that cause injury resulting in suspension. It’s a big price to pay for consistency.
The tribunal almost always has very imperfect evidence before it which makes there job difficult. My problem is that decisions with massive ramifications shouldn’t be based on what someone thinks happened.
Re: Adelaide Footy League Division 2 - 2018
Posted:
Fri Jun 22, 2018 10:40 pmby jo172
Is the AAA something the tribunal should have regard to in findings as to an individual charge?
I realise they're linked, but I don't think the procedure should change depending on that situation.
Best left for the executive (with the GC to review/override as is appropriate) to work out having regard to the tribunal
Re: Adelaide Footy League Division 2 - 2018
Posted:
Fri Jun 22, 2018 11:46 pmby Footy Chick
Next week on battle of the lawyers.....
Re: Adelaide Footy League Division 2 - 2018
Posted:
Sat Jun 23, 2018 12:20 amby LMA
Footy Chick wrote:Next week on battle of the lawyers.....
Proudly sponsored by Vaseline
Re: Adelaide Footy League Division 2 - 2018
Posted:
Sat Jun 23, 2018 5:38 amby Jimmy_041
Footy Chick wrote:Next week on battle of the lawyers.....
Exactly why each tribunal has a lawyer on it, and in many cases, a practising Judge
Re: Adelaide Footy League Division 2 - 2018
Posted:
Sat Jun 23, 2018 10:47 amby whufc
Footy Chick wrote:Next week on battle of the lawyers.....
Sorry about discussing an issue that has huge ramifications for its local community.
Feel free to go back to discussing who is rocking the coolest hair cut and whose legs look the best in the latest cut of footy shorts.
Play on
Re: Adelaide Footy League Division 2 - 2018
Posted:
Sat Jun 23, 2018 2:11 pmby locky801
Footy Chick wrote:Next week on battle of the lawyers.....
Battling over what
Re: Adelaide Footy League Division 2 - 2018
Posted:
Sat Jun 23, 2018 6:36 pmby Computer Crashed
GG finally get their well deserved win.
Out played the opposition for 80% of the game and actually took full use of 80% of their opportunities, makes one hell of a difference.
Well done to Eric and his players for sticking fat with a 0 - 10 record before today.
Some very happy GG footballers.
Congrats lads.
Re: Adelaide Footy League Division 2 - 2018
Posted:
Sat Jun 23, 2018 7:51 pmby bird of prey
Brighton will take the flag out this year. Very very impressive unit. They’re not the first side to touch us up this year. But I reckon they have the cattle to take down SPOC.
Would be a good matchup
Adelaide Footy League Division 2 - 2018
Posted:
Sat Jun 23, 2018 8:09 pmby Jim05
carey wrote:the joker wrote:Lightning McQueen wrote:The Bedge wrote:It has begun..
Salisbury North Hills Football League SA Bingos, Dylan Pending 2018-06-21
Salisbury North Barossa Light and Gawler Football Association Cochrane, Joel Pending 2018-06-21
Salisbury North River Murray Football League Haseldine, Toby Pending 2018-06-21
Salisbury North Barossa Light and Gawler Football Association Hay, Callum Pending 2018-06-21
Salisbury North Barossa Light and Gawler Football Association Hay, Joseph Pending 2018-06-21
Salisbury North Hills Football League SA Miller, Daniel Pending 2018-06-21
Salisbury North Kilburn Owen, Jharien Pending 2018-06-21
Salisbury North West Croydon Wiles, Ben Pending 2018-06-21
Anyone know where Callum is heading? Willaston perhaps? Thought he may end up at Virginia, they could use him right now.
Gawler South I think
No clearances will be processed for this week. All will be processed from Monday.
Clearances processed already and both played for South today
Re: Adelaide Footy League Division 2 - 2018
Posted:
Sat Jun 23, 2018 9:29 pmby Footy Chick
whufc wrote:Footy Chick wrote:Next week on battle of the lawyers.....
Sorry about discussing an issue that has huge ramifications for its local community.
Feel free to go back to discussing who is rocking the coolest hair cut and whose legs look the best in the latest cut of footy shorts.
Play on
Wtf are you on about man
Re: Adelaide Footy League Division 2 - 2018
Posted:
Sat Jun 23, 2018 10:35 pmby daysofourlives
One might be forgiven for thinling that this happens with such monotonous regularity in the ammos that the heirachy actually love the bit of me time they get in the media when they hand down such a penalty.