SA Footy

footys the winner wrote:Clinton clearly beat Milne for mine. Stoppage work was first class. Milne battled well around the ground and still took a few marks but Clinton clearly won the ruck battle. Anyone who didn't see that may have to open their other eye

I was at PNU last night and had a discussion about Milne v Clinton discussion that has taken place on here and has bought me to the conclusion that you may fall into one of the following categories
A) you are a troll
B) you are not a good judge of football
C) you rate yourself higher than a very successful coaching panel of the highest pedigree
D) all of the above

Whilst your post wasn't nearly as offensive as the original it still is quite baffling. Clinton caught holding the ball 3 times for starters.

If we are opening other eyes I can recommend two things you could keep an eye on at your club.

wristwatcher wrote:

footys the winner wrote:Clinton clearly beat Milne for mine. Stoppage work was first class. Milne battled well around the ground and still took a few marks but Clinton clearly won the ruck battle. Anyone who didn't see that may have to open their other eye

I was at PNU last night and had a discussion about Milne v Clinton discussion that has taken place on here and has bought me to the conclusion that you may fall into one of the following categories
A) you are a troll
B) you are not a good judge of football
C) you rate yourself higher than a very successful coaching panel of the highest pedigree
D) all of the above

Whilst your post wasn't nearly as offensive as the original it still is quite baffling. Clinton caught holding the ball 3 times for starters.

If we are opening other eyes I can recommend two things you could keep an eye on at your club.

K

footys the winner wrote:

wristwatcher wrote:

footys the winner wrote:Clinton clearly beat Milne for mine. Stoppage work was first class. Milne battled well around the ground and still took a few marks but Clinton clearly won the ruck battle. Anyone who didn't see that may have to open their other eye

I was at PNU last night and had a discussion about Milne v Clinton discussion that has taken place on here and has bought me to the conclusion that you may fall into one of the following categories
A) you are a troll
B) you are not a good judge of football
C) you rate yourself higher than a very successful coaching panel of the highest pedigree
D) all of the above

Whilst your post wasn't nearly as offensive as the original it still is quite baffling. Clinton caught holding the ball 3 times for starters.

If we are opening other eyes I can recommend two things you could keep an eye on at your club.

K

Well Damn! How's a one letter response meant to fire me up for a big day at footy.

wristwatcher wrote:

footys the winner wrote:

wristwatcher wrote:

footys the winner wrote:Clinton clearly beat Milne for mine. Stoppage work was first class. Milne battled well around the ground and still took a few marks but Clinton clearly won the ruck battle. Anyone who didn't see that may have to open their other eye

I was at PNU last night and had a discussion about Milne v Clinton discussion that has taken place on here and has bought me to the conclusion that you may fall into one of the following categories
A) you are a troll
B) you are not a good judge of football
C) you rate yourself higher than a very successful coaching panel of the highest pedigree
D) all of the above

Whilst your post wasn't nearly as offensive as the original it still is quite baffling. Clinton caught holding the ball 3 times for starters.

If we are opening other eyes I can recommend two things you could keep an eye on at your club.

K

Well Damn! How's a one letter response meant to fire me up for a big day at footy.

John Cena

Well played

The Hamish McLachlan wiki says he studied at stpeters, then Adelaide uni, anyone know if he played ammos for either

Here's a crack at TOTY in divvy 1 from games I've watched and the results I check weekly, I've come up with this... Of course i probably need to include one or two more Rocs players, just not sure what possies though. Tough to sort out with the plethora of talented footy players in Div 1..



F Commane (Rocs) Melville (Ttg) Johncock (Henley)
HF Anderson (Goodwood) Kells (Goodwood) Heath (Henley)
C Klemm (Pnu) A. McKay (Ttg) Holzbauer (goodwood)
BF Broadbent (Henley) Stanton (goodwood) Delminico (Shoc)
B Leahy (Pt Districts) Bower (Pnu) Stengle (Sals North)

Followers
Cockshell (Ttg)
Paynter (uni)
Hand (Ttg)

Bench
Milne (Pnu)
Pavlich (Henley)
Laslett (Portland)
Eichner (Sals North)

Pretty decent effort.

The usual suspects from ROCS all seem to have had good years (Will O'Malley, Kieran Holland, Luke Manuel)

absolutebath wrote:Here's a crack at TOTY in divvy 1 from games I've watched and the results I check weekly, I've come up with this... Of course i probably need to include one or two more Rocs players, just not sure what possies though. Tough to sort out with the plethora of talented footy players in Div 1..



F Commane (Rocs) Melville (Ttg) Johncock (Henley)
HF Anderson (Goodwood) Kells (Goodwood) Heath (Henley)
C Klemm (Pnu) A. McKay (Ttg) Holzbauer (goodwood)
BF Broadbent (Henley) Stanton (goodwood) Delminico (Shoc)
B Leahy (Pt Districts) Bower (Pnu) Stengle (Sals North)

Followers
Cockshell (Ttg)
Paynter (uni)
Hand (Ttg)

Bench
Milne (Pnu)
Pavlich (Henley)
Laslett (Portland)
Eichner (Sals North)

Fwd line is very tall. Brad Hood has hit the scoreboard a lot this year so has Dylan shoenmakers. Both would have to be in for mine. Other then that pretty much spot on.
Benekte (Uni) probably deserves a spot although that midfield is quality.

footys the winner wrote:

absolutebath wrote:Here's a crack at TOTY in divvy 1 from games I've watched and the results I check weekly, I've come up with this... Of course i probably need to include one or two more Rocs players, just not sure what possies though. Tough to sort out with the plethora of talented footy players in Div 1..



F Commane (Rocs) Melville (Ttg) Johncock (Henley)
HF Anderson (Goodwood) Kells (Goodwood) Heath (Henley)
C Klemm (Pnu) A. McKay (Ttg) Holzbauer (goodwood)
BF Broadbent (Henley) Stanton (goodwood) Delminico (Shoc)
B Leahy (Pt Districts) Bower (Pnu) Stengle (Sals North)

Followers
Cockshell (Ttg)
Paynter (uni)
Hand (Ttg)

Bench
Milne (Pnu)
Pavlich (Henley)
Laslett (Portland)
Eichner (Sals North)

Fwd line is very tall. Brad Hood has hit the scoreboard a lot this year so has Dylan shoenmakers. Both would have to be in for mine. Other then that pretty much spot on.
Benekte (Uni) probably deserves a spot although that midfield is quality.

Agree with that sentiment. Lacks a small forward For mine, Hood from the Hawks has hit the scoreboard as Much as any small forward whilst Lowe from PNU has stole the show in a couple of games despite being such a pr@ck to the umpires and having his Haka like war dance celebration that's just to over the top for mine but this team is not a popularity contest.

I'd have Milne as first Ruck but that's because I have seen a lot more of him than Big Co. Both should poll >15

Other possible inclusions that could consider themselves unlucky
TTG - McKay and Sandrey
PNU - Langford
Port - Thurgood

absolutebath wrote:Here's a crack at TOTY in divvy 1 from games I've watched and the results I check weekly, I've come up with this... Of course i probably need to include one or two more Rocs players, just not sure what possies though. Tough to sort out with the plethora of talented footy players in Div 1..



F Commane (Rocs) Melville (Ttg) Johncock (Henley)
HF Anderson (Goodwood) Kells (Goodwood) Heath (Henley)
C Klemm (Pnu) A. McKay (Ttg) Holzbauer (goodwood)
BF Broadbent (Henley) Stanton (goodwood) Delminico (Shoc)
B Leahy (Pt Districts) Bower (Pnu) Stengle (Sals North)

Followers
Cockshell (Ttg)
Paynter (uni)
Hand (Ttg)

Bench
Milne (Pnu)
Pavlich (Henley)
Laslett (Portland)
Eichner (Sals North)

I have seen most TTG games. Dylan Schoenmakers has to be in as a small forward as does Nathan Rudloff, who has been outstanding in defence. Langford at CHF for me.

absolutebath wrote:Here's a crack at TOTY in divvy 1 from games I've watched and the results I check weekly, I've come up with this... Of course i probably need to include one or two more Rocs players, just not sure what possies though. Tough to sort out with the plethora of talented footy players in Div 1..



F Commane (Rocs) Melville (Ttg) Johncock (Henley)
HF Anderson (Goodwood) Kells (Goodwood) Heath (Henley)
C Klemm (Pnu) A. McKay (Ttg) Holzbauer (goodwood)
BF Broadbent (Henley) Stanton (goodwood) Delminico (Shoc)
B Leahy (Pt Districts) Bower (Pnu) Stengle (Sals North)

Followers
Cockshell (Ttg)
Paynter (uni)
Hand (Ttg)

Bench
Milne (Pnu)
Pavlich (Henley)
Laslett (Portland)
Eichner (Sals North)

Kells doesnt play CHF.
Stanton certainly doesnt play CHB.

Jetters wrote:
Kells doesnt play CHF.
Stanton certainly doesnt play CHB.

neither does John Butcher!!! wtf

37 goals as a small forward after missing a couple of games. Young B Hood has to be in it. Not one defender has beaten him this year.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

the joker wrote:37 goals as a small forward after missing a couple of games. Young B Hood has to be in it. Not one defender has beaten him this year.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Schoenmakers has 38 from 15

jo172 wrote:

the joker wrote:37 goals as a small forward after missing a couple of games. Young B Hood has to be in it. Not one defender has beaten him this year.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Schoenmakers has 38 from 15

Easy solution to that....put them both in.

F Melville (TTG) Commane (ROCS) Hood (SN)
HF Schoenmakers (TTG) Langford (PNU) Heath (Henley

Trent Heffernan in for Leahy for me

G_Leonard wrote:Trent Heffernan in for Leahy for me

The two times I have seen ROCS this year would have me leaning towards Will O'Malley ahead of Paynter. Admittedly only seen Seb play twice this year also. Plenty of worthy candidates in Div 1 for T.O.Y

G_Leonard wrote:Trent Heffernan in for Leahy for me

didn't Heff spend some time out with injury?

Interesting to see pnu beat ROCS I wouldn't have tipped that one. ROCS seem to be coming home strong with a lot of momentum in all of their grades